StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

The Criticisms of Scalon's Millan Principle - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The Millian Principle Course Institution Date The Millian Principle “There are some harms, which even though would not transpire but for some acts of expression, however, cannot be included in the justifications for legal limitations on these acts…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97% of users find it useful
The Criticisms of Scalons Millan Principle
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Criticisms of Scalon's Millan Principle"

Download file to see previous pages

The Millian principle on Liberty simply means that certain harms may have had no probability of occurring if, not for some expressed actions. However, once these harms occur, the perpetrators may not justify their actions by legally restricting the actions. These harms include; those that originate from certain acts of expression, which include deceiving the individuals into having false beliefs and acts of expressions, which lead people into acting in ways that may lead to harmful consequences, especially in situations where there is a correlation between the act of expression and the succeeding harmful consequences.

This correlation simply includes a mere fact that the act of expression facilitated the agents’ belief or led them to believe that it would be worthy performing the acts. Scanlon defended this principle by illustrating that it was a consequence of a certain idea regarding limits of justifiable political authority. That the government’s legitimate powers are restricted to people that can be protected on incompatibility grounds, with the citizen’s authority Scanlon (1979, p. 529). However, Scanlon does not fully agree with this principle.

In his criticism, Scanlon argues that the Millian principle aimed at ruling out censorship arguments to which Mill was responding. The principle did this by declaring that the harmful consequences appealed by this argument cannot count as prospective justification for lawful restrictions of expression. However, Scanlon argues that there are supplementary ways of arriving at policies that would seem incompatible with freedom of expression. Freedom of expression refers to the participant’s right not to be prohibited from expressing themselves Bosmajian (1988 p. 122). Scanlon argues that the principle obtains what seems to be an implausible consequence in certain instances.

He says that it would be difficult to see how this principle squares laws against misleading advertising on television. In this respect, Scanlon articulates that probably the regulation policies violate the freedom of expression Scanlon (1979, p.534). However, if the policies are acceptable, then they could be paradigms of paternalism. In Scanlon’s view, if anyone could take the first clause of the Millian principle as a restriction set aside in instances where rational capacities are rigorously diminished, it would constitute a dismissal of paternalism.

An adequate justification doctrine of paternalism must consider certain factors such as the value associated with the ability for an individual to make their own decisions, the costs of making these decisions and the risks associated with empowering the government to make decisions on people’s behalf. These factors are unique to every case, and may be applicable even in cases where there is no common loss of rational capabilities. However, Scanlon argues that the problems associated with the Millian principle are not only limited to justification of paternalism.

The principle also protects the interests of important audiences. These interests include the interest of choosing their beliefs and reasons to act on their beliefs. These interests rely not only on the freedom of expression, but also on means of accessing information, education and other issues critical to decision making. Sometimes, supplementary information is

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Criticisms of Scalon's Millan Principle Essay”, n.d.)
The Criticisms of Scalon's Millan Principle Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/journalism-communication/1447975-explain-and-assess-the-criticisms-of-scalon-s
(The Criticisms of Scalon'S Millan Principle Essay)
The Criticisms of Scalon'S Millan Principle Essay. https://studentshare.org/journalism-communication/1447975-explain-and-assess-the-criticisms-of-scalon-s.
“The Criticisms of Scalon'S Millan Principle Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/journalism-communication/1447975-explain-and-assess-the-criticisms-of-scalon-s.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Criticisms of Scalon's Millan Principle

Functioning of Tanning Salons

A tan is a brown colour that the skin turns into by exposure to the sun.... There are different ways of tanning your skin.... Skin can be tanned naturally by exposure to the sun or artificially by going to a tanning salon.... Skin tanning is done by exposing the skin to Ultraviolet radiations which changes the colour of the skin in to variant of brown....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Common Criticisms of Psychology

This essay highlights that much of the criticisms of psychology as a discipline of study are aimed at its status as a science.... nbsp;… According to the report most of the informed criticisms adopt a sort of positivist stand.... Critics of various hues argue that psychology is too fuzzy to be a science....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Ideological Criticism

In the context of socio-political impact, it becomes all the more important for ideological criticisms to have strong and viable platform.... Criticism of literary and non literary work has been categorized into two prominent formats, formal criticism and ideological criticism.... Criticism has helped maintain a minimum standard of works that passes through the ages while throwing a very pertinent socio-political scenario of that time....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Age of Enlightenment and How It Affected Art

It was mainly concerned with the emphasis on airy grace and refined pleasures of boudoir and the salon, porcelain and delicate jewelries, artful dances, wooded scenes and women, especially women in the nude (millan 196).... Jean Fragonard and Francois Boucher were his French successors (millan 195)....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Criticisms and Arguments Against Transformational Leadership

The paper identifies the criticisms and arguments against transformational leadership and makes comments and counter-arguments after identifying the sources.... It presents a position for or against transformational leadership and the defensive position.... hellip; Transformational leaders who may happen to have narcissistic tendencies can apply a very powerful influence over followers, who may give them trust and respect as to manipulate the latter....
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework

Literary Criticism of Edna St Vincent Millay

Edna's strategies that used to express the theme of love in her poems is through simple and comprehensive communication (www.... ighbeam.... om).... In her work, “Love is not all” she applies simple forms, words as well as concepts to describe the theme of love.... In this… Edna is not talking about the challenges that were facing the 21st Century, but rather attempting to answer the question: What would one give or do to for love?...
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Source Criticism

This research will begin with the statement that many modern scholars believe that the present text of the Bible is the final product of a long evolution and that source criticism is a method that is used to detect text evidence of its earlier stages.... hellip; According to the research findings, it can, therefore, be said that source criticism would particularly look for apparent discrepancies and contradictions in texts to indicate the work of redactors who had collated disparate sources....
21 Pages (5250 words) Article

Nature of Criticism

Based on these definitions, it can be argued that criticisms are for the most part about the critic rather than the object being criticised.... … The paper "Nature of Criticism" is a good example of a literature review on architecture.... nbsp;In describing the nature of criticism, Attoe (1976) points out that criticism is primarily concerned with interpreting, judging, prescribing and describing an object of interest....
6 Pages (1500 words) Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us