StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Dunlap v. Tennessee Valley Authority - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
DUNLAP V. TENNESSEE VALLEY AUTHORITY Name University Course Instructor Date Introduction Dunlap, an African-American applicant submitted his application details for a boilermaker position at TVA. Boilermaker union referred Dunlap for an interview as a skilled and qualified person…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.2% of users find it useful
Dunlap v. Tennessee Valley Authority
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Dunlap v. Tennessee Valley Authority"

Download file to see previous pages

Dunlap felt that the system of scoring was extremely skewed and in favor of white candidates. This discussion investigates the legal issues in the episode and the decision to credit the claim of desperate treatment and neglect the disparate impact claim. Similarly, the discussion will suggest different ways in which Tennessee Valley authority can improve their process of interview. Discussion Legal issues They include David Dunlap, who believes that the process of interviewing in the TVA is discriminating and violates the Title seven of the 1964 Civil Right Act.

David feels that he suffered prejudice under both disparate treatment and impact by the interview, which was increasingly subjective. Dunlap believes that the selection criteria favored white people. The committee evaluated all the applicants during the interview, but Dunlap felt that the evaluation process lacked merit and had limited rhyme. For instance, he scored low marks on a safety question than his colleague who has had more than two accidents in a span of 11 years, and for Dunlap, he had no accident, (Markusen, 2003).

The system of evaluation itself can lead to various legal issues, for instance, the Tennessee Valley Authority’s subjective hiring and evaluation process allowed racial discrimination against Black applicants such as Dunlap. The Court of Appeal verified the claim of disparate treatment, reversed the claim of disparate adverse and verified the award of the district court of damages and fees to David. Why the disparate impact claim failed The theory of disparate claim demands the plaintiff to show that a seemingly impartial employment practice influences one team increasingly harshly than the other and that the practice of employment is unjustified by business requirements.

Under the doctrine, discriminatory testimony intent is not necessary. Even though, the district court construed that Tennessee Valley Authority process of interviewing was influenced to exclude black applicants, the Appeals Court objected, citing inadequate statistical evidence that a protected team was negatively affected, therefore, creating a prima Facie argument. Dunlap could not support his case by just challenging the employed process in his interview; therefore, his case failed. Success of disparate treatment argument The doctrine of disparate treatment demands a plaintiff to show that the employer has favored some people against others based on their race, origin or cultural background.

It also requires the plaintiff create a prima Facie condition of racial bias, the employer to demonstrate a number of legitimate nonbiased reasons for his actions and the plaintiff to show some evidence that the articulated accusation was pre-textual. In this theory, a discriminatory proof is crucial. Nevertheless, in different circumstances it may be concluded from the sole disparities in treatment. Discriminatory motive proof may be gathered from the employers’ false explanation for the actions.

To refute a prima Facie argument, a defendant should show a legal nonbiased reason for rejection of plaintiff. In Dunlap’s case, Tennessee Valley Authority demonstrated the selection medium employed during the interview of Dunlap, and indicated that Dunlap’s interview score did not put his last marks into the best ten. The challenge then turned back to Dunlap to show that the process of selection was pretext for biasness. The district court

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Dunlap v. Tennessee Valley Authority Research Paper”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/business/1467205-dunlap-v-tennessee-valley-authority
(Dunlap V. Tennessee Valley Authority Research Paper)
https://studentshare.org/business/1467205-dunlap-v-tennessee-valley-authority.
“Dunlap V. Tennessee Valley Authority Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/business/1467205-dunlap-v-tennessee-valley-authority.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Dunlap v. Tennessee Valley Authority

Music in Tennessee

In this essay describes tennessee's contribution to the development of music in the US, which is vital because it is home to some of the most renowned musicians and other artists of all time, in the world.... tennessee is a state in America in the Southeastern region of the country.... … This paper discusses the interaction of tennessee and commercial music in the first half of the twentieth century.... Music in tennessee tennessee is a in America in the Southeastern region of the country....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Domestic Abuse in Tennessee

The paper “Domestic Abuse in tennessee” focuses on the legacy of family violence, which is often passed from generation to generation as the children who witness abuse today will become the perpetrators of domestic violence tomorrow.... This has been the legacy of the tennessee laws regarding domestic violence.... One of the key areas that tennessee law has changed in recent years is the ability of the state to intervene in the prosecution of domestic violence with or without the cooperation of the victim....
3 Pages (750 words) Assignment

The Accounting Malpractices of Sunbeam

dunlap was a management expert who specialized in quick fix solutions for ailing companies.... They point to the fact that most of dunlap's previous firms have been put up for sale after the dramatic recovery they staged and have never been capable of outdoing its competition on its own.... dunlap's aim has always been to improve the performance of the company on the books and then sell it off at higher prices as the stock value escalates in the expectation of higher returns....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Al Dunlap at Sunbeam

In the paper “Al dunlap at Sunbeam” the author discusses Sunbeam, which was on the verge of bankruptcy, thus Albert.... dunlap was hired as CEO of the corporation, in 1996, to rescue it.... hellip; The author states that dunlap began his tenure as CEO by rightsizing the company – halving the workforce from 12000 to 6000, reducing the number of factories from 26 to 8 and warehouses from 61 to 18.... The final step of the rescue plan was identified by dunlap in his own words as an aggressive growth plan (2)....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Recruitment Drives

In the case, an African American, David Dunlap applies for a job with the tennessee valley authority as a boilmaker.... The plaintiff is David Dunlap who had filed a suit at the District Court against the tennessee valley authority, claiming that he was racially discriminated against, and in violation of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.... The District Court in its ruling statement pointed out that tennessee valley authority [TVA] was subjective in its recruitment process and procedures and exacted out racial biasness against Dunlop and other applicants of African Americans descent....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Business Employment Law

tennessee valley authority reflects the course of events when there is manipulation in the hiring process to achieve the desired result.... hellip; The case scenario of dunlap v.... In this case, it features an African-American applicant called David dunlap who is 52 years old.... dunlap presented claims that showed the aspects of priority given to the white over the black people, irrespective of them having better qualifications and work experiences than the white people....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

Tennessees Political, Economic, and Social Development

The paper “tennessee's Political, Economic, and Social Development” will discuss the most significant political development in 1970s, which was the rebirth of the Republic Party which made tennessee one of the actual two-party states from the South.... hellip; The author states that the tennessee-Tombigbee Waterway was completed in 1985.... In 1992, the tennessee legislature approved school reform laws.... tennessee's Political, Economic, and Social Development Thesis statementThe most significant political development in 1970s was the rebirth of the Republic Party which made tennessee one of the actual two-party states from the South....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Vote of the Court of Cohens v. Virginia

In the paper “Vote of the Court of Cohens v.... Virginia” the author provides the facts of the Case Cohens v.... Virginia, 19 U.... .... (6 Wheat.... 264 (1821).... The Cohen brothers went on to sell D.... .... lottery tickets in the state of Virginia, breaking state law.... hellip; The author states that the Cohens appealed to the Supreme Court of the United States against the fine imposed by the Virginia court, pleading the legality of their sale under the 'Act to amend the charter of the city of Washington', passed by Congress in 1812, which permitted the drawing of lotteries....
22 Pages (5500 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us