StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Political Pluralism in Hong Kong - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Political Pluralism in Hong Kong" holds that diversity in political issues is important to society and that disparate organized or cultural groups should be allowed to enjoy independence in society. Hong Kong seems to be keen on ensuring that pluralism is successful in its jurisdiction…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.6% of users find it useful
Political Pluralism in Hong Kong
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Political Pluralism in Hong Kong"

?Insert Political pluralism in Hong Kong Political pluralism is the perception of liberal democracies which requires the dispersal of power among different economic and philosophical organized groups (Ma 38). Pluralism does not require the concentration of political power on a single group or elites. The philosophy holds that diversity in political issues is important to society and that disparate organized or cultural groups should be allowed to enjoy independence in society. These groups include; religious groups, labor unions, professional groups, and minority ethnic groups. Hong Kong seems to be keen on ensuring that pluralism is successful within its jurisdiction. Chan (198) says Hong Kong's current path to a complete democracy has been influenced by the country’s internal development of democratic structures over the past two decades. As at now, the struggle for establishing and strengthening internal democratic structures in Hong Kong has led to the pan-democratic agents locking horns with the hesitant government of China. The main challenge to democratic pluralism has been the inherent reluctance of the People’s Republic of China to welcome a Western-model democratic structure taking foot in Hong Kong. The central government of China does not appear to approve of the inevitable Western influences that would subsequently follow, and might spillover to China’s mainland. Ma (38) argues that China is wary about such a development because the West could use Hong Kong as the launch-pad for the subsequent complete democratization of the mainland China. As such, Ma (38) notes that the growth of democratic structures and culture in Hong Kong is basically hinged on the very core of the China’s central administrative authorities in Beijing. The authorities however continue to implement paternalistic policies, despite the fact that the Beijing regime seems to have ceded some ground on politically liberalism and pluralism in both territories compared to the state of affairs in the twentieth century. In light of the connection between the two societies, Chan (198) predicts that Hong Kong's development of democracy will grow at a slow pace. This gradual development will likely play out when the society is compared to the pluralism of the Western political culture where political organizations take rotations at the helm of leadership and competitive will of the people is the cornerstone of the processes (Ma 38). Despite these challenges, Hong Kong boasts of its internal organizations as the most liberal in the whole of China. The region’s people are arguably not just agents of democratic processes which manifests in their relentless support for a universal suffrage or its equivalent in the election of the Chief Executive and the members of the Legislative Council, but also adherents of the free expression of political views. Ma (38) has pointed out that Hong Kong also takes pride in civil rights protection, constitutionalism and a government leadership that is not tainted. The close supervisory roles of the reputable oversight organizations like the anti-corruption agency have also increased the level of faith in the regime’s leadership. In light of these tremendous steps involving constitutional pluralism, Hong Kong is experiencing a great level of horizontal transparency. Chan (198) points out that the much needed vertical accountability regarding competitive assumption of political offices based on the people’s will and the rotation of political parties in power has not yet been realized, however. Neo-liberalism in organized groups As Chan (198) has stated, Hong Kong organized groups replicate institutions of neo-liberalism, and as such they are representative the democratic will of their members in the selection of the Chief Executive. The system appears to favor competitiveness in the choice of leadership and public policy which rests with businesspersons, professional bodies, scholars and social welfare organizations (Hague and Harrop Martin 12-47). The organizations are mandated to select through an open, competitive process, representatives to a committee made up of 800 persons that then votes for the top-most political leader. Lawyers, for instance, are entitled to nominate their representatives through a competitive process to fill the 800-man slot that is equivalent of an Electoral College, as do managers who are in charge of financial services, tourism experts, academicians, and caterers. Although, some organized groups are given more slates than others, the main guiding principle is equity. Altogether, an estimated 200,000 members of the territory’s 7 million citizens are fit to vote (Chan 198). The low turnout in the elections, however denies the territory a clear, accurate political representation. Dispersed political power Ma (38) has pointed out that Hong Kong’s pluralism is a replica of the democratic processes in fledged Western countries in the sense that power is not concentrated in the hands of the ruling elite. For instance, by virtue of the delegate’s role in electing the top-most holder of office in the land, organized groups undeniably have a vital role to play in the running of the political affairs within the jurisdiction. This close, participatory relationship through people’s representatives is based on dispersed political powers and public policy-making initiatives within the territory. Government’s impartiality Hong Kong’s supreme political leadership prides itself in playing the impartial arbiter’s role in the operations of organizations where matters political arise. As such Hong Kong citizens enjoy a more impartial government role in terms of overseeing the affairs of various organizations within the region (Chan 198). However, China’s handling of Hong Kong as a semiautonomous territory within its borders, has complicated matters for the impartiality of Hong Kong’s highest leadership as far as the handling of organizations is concerned. China is not willing to allow the various organizations to enjoy a wider mandate in political spheres. The end result has witnessed the creation of a pseudo-electorate system for electing the political leadership where Beijing has a hand in the election of the chief executive. Pseudo-electorate system Despite the political pressure from Beijing, which threatens to scuttle a nascent democratic culture in Hong Kong, Ma (38) suggests that organized groups like that of lawyers seem to be in favour of a more transparent system for electing the chief executive. Judging by the recent elections, Chan (198) says the organizations have argued that Hong Kong’s citizens prefer competitive electoral processes in the country; hence it needs to move with speed in strengthening its democratic processes. Conclusion The rise of political pluralism in Hong Kong, and the equal level of resistance from China demonstrate a conflict between two political civilizations. In light of this, the more Hong Kong moves to strengthen the independence of its various organizations along Western models of civilization as supported by a majority of Hong Kong citizens, the more Chinese civilization struggles to stamp its sectarian authority in the smaller territory. China’s influence on Hong Kong has reversed and to some extent continues to slow the pace of political pluralism in the region. Works Cited Chan, M. Joseph, and Lee, L.F. Francis. Media and Politics in Post-Handover Hong Kong. New York: Routledge, 2013. Hague, Rod and Harrop, Martin. Comparative Government and Politics: An Introduction. London: Palgrave, 2013 Ma, Kit-Wai Eric. Culture, Politics and Television in Hong Kong. New York: Routledge, 2013. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Discuss political power distribution in regard to neo-pluralism. To Essay”, n.d.)
Discuss political power distribution in regard to neo-pluralism. To Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1492055-discuss-political-power-distribution-in-regard-to
(Discuss Political Power Distribution in Regard to Neo-Pluralism. To Essay)
Discuss Political Power Distribution in Regard to Neo-Pluralism. To Essay. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1492055-discuss-political-power-distribution-in-regard-to.
“Discuss Political Power Distribution in Regard to Neo-Pluralism. To Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1492055-discuss-political-power-distribution-in-regard-to.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Political Pluralism in Hong Kong

The Pluralist Theory of Politics in our Political Systems

The paper "The Pluralist Theory of Politics in our Political Systems" presents the classical theory of pluralism.... Classical pluralism is the view that politics and decision-making are mostly located in the government, but there are also non-governmental groups who use many resources to exert their influence on politics and decision-making (Barzilai 2003).... Discussion What we observe these days in our local politics is new pluralism.... It is the reconstruction of political science and advancement in the fundamental and traditional structure of classical pluralism of political sociology....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

The Political System within the United Kingdom

political life can be measured through sociological variables and this helps to understand the class model of the society very easily.... There have been a number of philosophers and thinkers who have been able to base their theories on class and model structures within a political economy.... This however sometimes is at the cost of others and thus a proper political, social as well as economic structure needs to be set in place in order to avoid conflicts among people....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Pluralism and Urban Regime

Name Institution Instructor Course Date pluralism and Urban regime Introduction pluralism refers to the wide range of topics that denote diversity of views and stands.... The common worry in the pluralism is that, common persons lack intelligence and direct democracy that is required in leadership.... On the issue of pluralism, Robert Dahl rejected the idea of democracy as an open form of governorship.... Clarence stone also had a say on the urban regimes and pluralism....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Introduction to American Politics

Term Paper, History and political Science Introduction to American Politics Pluralist and Elite Views of democracy Elite Views of democracy says that less members of a population manage the nation regardless the consequences of election.... In the past, political scientists asked whether it was necessary for Developmental democracy to persist.... Small effect towards election propagates declaration of many political dilemmas.... This low interest gives direction for political shifts mandated for an intricate society....
5 Pages (1250 words) Term Paper

Trade Unions and Economy

Today, from many quarters, we come to know that pluralism is a very outdated and never-to-come-again part of industrial relations.... pluralism is acceptance of diversity, democracy, many voices, and views; it is against totalitarianism, monism and dualism.... It is having multiple numbers of vocal viewpoints, ethics, cultures, religions, political diverse views, many social and economical perspectives. ...
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Theories of Business Power

For example, the political candidates were able to get wide exposure, the government subsidized and later regulated these railroads too.... The present paper "Theories of Business Power" explores the ideas of business power.... As the author puts it, business power is defined as the driving force for an act by an industry, a company or sector with its primary source being a grant of authority from the society....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

Classical Pluralism Comes Nowhere Near Capturing

Classical pluralism is the view that politics and decision making are mostly located in the government, but there are also non-governmental groups who use many resources to exert their influence on politics and decision making (Barzilai 2003).... It is the reconstruction of political science and advancement in the fundamental and traditional structure of classical pluralism of political sociology.... Our societies have come a long way from the traditional classic era of classic pluralism of the post second world war era....
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment

The Dominance and the Pluralist Theory of Business Power

In recent years, power has become an even more far-ranging meaning in social and political theories, because of the claims of certain researchers that power is a contested concept, which means that people having different values and beliefs will disagree with its nature eventually.... Power is not the peculiar normative concept either, because different political parties as well as the ethnic nationalists and religious believers that dispute endlessly about whom should have power and to what extent, how should it be organized and directed....
15 Pages (3750 words) Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us