StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Big Mart Cheap Goods at What Price - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Big Mart Cheap Goods at What Price" highlights that there is clear evidence that the big-box chains have certain impacts on the economy. It further shows the different views held concerning the issue and the reasons provided for such views…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.9% of users find it useful
Big Mart Cheap Goods at What Price
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Big Mart Cheap Goods at What Price"

Big Mart Cheap Goods at What Price The case study “Stakeholders and Storytellers: Playing Politics and the Policy Process” provides a fictional case concerning the effects of big-box chains on economies. This essay provides a stakeholder analysis, and the way power and democracy shaped the stakeholder analysis. It also provides the linking mechanisms used by the two opposing groups, strategies used by key players, a win-win policy, and an appropriate policy process for VanWood Heights. Key Words: Stakeholder Analysis, Power and Democracy, Linking Mechanisms, Policy Big Mart Cheap Goods at What Price Introduction The world has in the recent past and at present discussed much concerning the impacts that big-box chains have on the economy. As a result, several arguments about the issue have been created with each side fiercely defending their opinion. The proposing sides insist that big-box chains can boost the development of the economy, while the opposing side insists that such business cause unemployment. Additionally, the opposing side usually insists that such businesses provide stiff competition to local businesses thereby leading to their failure (Mitchell, 2010). Generally, the issue is still under discussion and researchers focus a lot on finding the most appropriate answer. Stakeholder Analysis In the case study, the residents of VanWood Heights and a few foreigners strive hard to air their opinions considering the establishment of a new store by Big-Mart in the town. From the views of some few members at the meeting, the following stakeholder analysis can be derived: A local farmer, Mike Zander, who argues that Big-Mart has the possibility of stunting their local economy, has little influence. Most of the issues and arguments surrounding the problem seem to have a political origin. As a result, a local farmer like Zander has little influence on determining the appropriate solution that can be implemented. Zander, however, has a significant importance. If Big-Mart begins its business in VanWood Heights, it will most probably get supplies from the foreign farmers, just as Zander suggests (Yablonsky, 2006). Leah Lindser, a VanWood Treasure’s owner, has a significant influence and significant importance. Since, the town has depended on her business for generations (Yablonsky, 2006); she has a lot of power and influence on the natives of the town. Additionally, she has a political impact on the decisions made concerning the issues since leads the organization “Coalition Save VanWood Heights.” Moreover, her influence and power result from the fact that she acts as a local investor to her town. An individual like Andrew Amers, the president of a workers union has great influence and importance concerning the matter at hand. His power originates form the authority given to him by the members of his union. Amers insists that Big-Mart has a record of offering low wages to workers, poor working conditions and rules, and discriminates both women and minorities when it comes to payment and promotions (Yablonsky, 2006). Generally, he acts as a strong critique of the idea that Big-Mart should open a store in the town. Another criticizer, Alex Stanley, provides the idea that the natives of town should consider reinvesting in their community instead of inviting multinational corporations such as Big-Mart. Moreover, his arguments are based on economic development (Yablonsky, 2006). Stanley has a great influence, power and importance considering the fact that he is president of the organization “Coalition Save VanWood Heights”, which fight to ensure continuity in the development of the town. Alex Stanley’s opinions are strongly supported by Rana Sadiqah, a member of the Regional Environmental Group. A supporter, Suzanne Sturgan has significant importance but has no influence. Her importance results from the fact that she leads the Chamber of Commerce, as a result, has adequate and useful knowledge about the likely impacts that may result from Big-Mart’s investment in the town. Sturgan insists that Big-Mart will offer the local economy the boost it requires, both economic and environmental. Additionally, she asserts that the regulations imposed on Big-Mart business are unnecessary (Yablonsky, 2006). Certainly, she proposes the new investment into town. She, however, may not have influence since the issue has been politicized. John Elko, acts as Big-Mart’s representative. He therefore has much influence and importance about the matter at hand. Generally, Elko exhibits much power since his group has managed to convince 45% of VanWood Heights’ population into favoring the existence of the store (Yablonsky, 2006). He further gains significant influence from the incentives, and arguments he offers. For instance, he claims that his company will ensure environmental conservation, good working policies and conditions for workers, and affordable prices. In addition, Katie Schnitz, a local citizen and teacher, seems to hustle a lot to make end meets. She supports the idea of Big-Mart opening a store in VanWood Heights. Her main reasons for supporting the idea include the fact that the new store will provide goods at a lower price than the local stores and in addition offer affordable health care services. Certainly, she seems not to care much about the economic impact that the existence of Big-Mart will have on her local economy. Generally, she has little influence and importance in this situation since she is a common citizen with no power or authority. Frank Sherrie, also in the same situation as Schnitz, supports the idea of Big-Mart investing in their town. He believes that whatever Big-Mart has to offer has greater benefits than whatever the town residents usually receives from the local stores. Just like Schnitz, Sherrie has no power to influence the decisions made. Power and Democracy Certain views of power and democracy shape this stakeholder analysis. In most cases, power provides an individual some form of influence and/or importance (Rosa & Scheuerman, 2012). Considering the individuals assessed, the normal citizens have limited or no power. Such individuals include Katie Schnitz, and Frank Sherrie. Certainly, these three individuals are less influential and important since they do not have power. Additionally, their opinions are negligible on the determination of the policies to be made despite them representing a larger section of the population (the 45%). Additionally, from the case study, evidence exists that there is the practice of democracy; however, it is somehow undermined. For instance, despite McGee giving different people the opportunity to air their views during the meeting, not every view receives a consideration. Especially the views of minor individuals like Schnitz and Sherrie. Generally, democracy determines influence and importance among individuals (Rosa & Scheuerman, 2012). This has been used to shape the stakeholder analysis. The Linking Mechanisms The case study provides two groups. One group opposes the policies that allow Big-Mart to operate and invest in VanWood Heights. The other group supports the policy. The group that opposes the policies seems to have a greater level of power (which acts as their linking mechanism) and use it to air their grievances and views. The opposing group therefore has high chances of driving away the foreign investors. The groups that supports the policies consists mainly the common citizens who operate under the authority of those in power. Moreover, poverty and daily hustle to make ends meet appears to be their main linking mechanism. The case study provides that 45% of the town’s population support the idea while 42% oppose. As much as the majority is for the idea, they may end up losing the arguments since they lack power. Strategies Used As much as the Mayor had earlier on politicized the issue in favor of Big-Mart, the same strategy (politics) has a high probability of being used to drive away the foreign investors. Generally, the key players include the individuals like Leah Lindser who have the power. The case study provides evidence that the individuals with power have politicized the issue. In other words, Big-Mart representatives provide clear explanations on the improvements that the company has made in the past years yet those opposing (individuals with power) seem to base so much on the company’s past mistakes. Such individuals end up overshadowing the fact that the common citizens labor hard to make ends meet. For that reason, politics will most probably be used to drive away the investors so that the few individuals with power can thrive. A Win-Win Policy Since every group expects its interests and values to receive a consideration, a policy that can result to a win-win situation has great importance. The authorities of the town should consider implementation polices that allow investment of foreigners in the town. At the same instance, policies that ensure that foreigners receive some of their stock from their natives should also be implemented. Moreover, the town’s leadership should create a policy that controls the level of monopoly in the market, for example, the authorities can set fixed prices for significant commodities for all businesses present in the town. The Appropriate Policy Process The case study depicts a crisis that will probably affect the public either negatively or positively. A public policy process would therefore be appropriate for VanWood Heights’ situation. This process acts as a multi-stage cycle, which involves six phases. These stages include problem identification, setting of the agenda, policy formulation, budgeting, implementation process, and finally evaluation of the process (Sabatier, 2009). The process if correctly followed can help result to a win-win situation in VanWood Heights. Additionally, as a policy analyst, my role in the process would be to assists in the processes of policy formulation, implementation, and evaluation. In conclusion, the case study depicts that there is clear evidence that the big-box chains have certain impacts on the economy. It further shows the different views held concerning the issue and the reasons provided for such views. Additionally, it provides that such views are implementable or ignorable because of factors such as power and democracy. References Mitchell, S. (2010). Big-box swindle: The true cost of mega-retailers and the fight for Americas independent businesses. Boston: Beacon Press. Rosa, H., & Scheuerman, W. E. (2012). High-speed society: Social acceleration, power, and modernity. University Park, Pa: Pennsylvania State University Press. Sabatier, P. A. (2009). Theories of the Policy Process. Boulder, CO: Westview Press. Yablonsky, E. M. (2006). Stakeholders and Storytellers: Playing Politics and the Policy Process. Economic Development Journal. 31-37. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Big Mart Cheap Goods at What Price Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words, n.d.)
Big Mart Cheap Goods at What Price Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. https://studentshare.org/business/1837840-big-mart-cheap-goods-at-what-price
(Big Mart Cheap Goods at What Price Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
Big Mart Cheap Goods at What Price Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/business/1837840-big-mart-cheap-goods-at-what-price.
“Big Mart Cheap Goods at What Price Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”. https://studentshare.org/business/1837840-big-mart-cheap-goods-at-what-price.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Big Mart Cheap Goods at What Price

The Impact Of Globalization On The Multinational Corporations

It is difficult for an American made vehicle to compete effectively with a Korean or Indian made vehicle in terms of price.... price wars are getting intensified in the automobile sector in recent times and hence the profit percentages of the automakers are coming down drastically.... Prominent automobile manufacturers are currently offshoring their manufacturing operations to cheap labour oriented countries such as India and China to reduce manufacturing cost....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

The Role of Globalization in Promoting Inequality in the United States and the World

Manufacturing companies like Rubber Maid have had to risk losing volume since Wal-Mart could not take the price increase proposed by Rubber Maid to counter the... In a bid to understand the role of globalization in promoting inequality, this essay seeks to answer the following question; what is globalization?... what does unequal distribution of globalization effects around the world mean?... what relationship exists between inequalities and globalization?...
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Wal-Mart: The High Cost of Low Prices

Wal-Mart is able to go into towns, and offer goods at low prices that the Mom and Pop stores cannot compete with.... In the essay 'Wal-mart: The High Cost of Low Prices' the author discusses the first major effect that Wal-mart has on society.... The author states that eventually, the only thing that is left is Wal-mart, and the people have no choice left but to shop there.... People may have no stores for miles except for Wal-mart because ever place has had to close because it couldn't compete with Wal-mart....
1 Pages (250 words) Case Study

Wal-Mart Effect by Charles Fishman

The cost per pound, Charles Fishman points out in this carefully investigate and richly subjective book, is less than the postage it would price you to send the fish rear to Chile (Charles Fishman). ... Its cheap plan, so all-encompassing that additional stores follow suit still when they are not straight contestant, plays a main role in holding down US price rises; its persistent demand for short prices from suppliers has been a main driver in the sell abroad of US developed jobs to China and elsewhere (Michael C....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Wal-Mart and Kmart - the Structure of the Five Main Business Functions

The paper "Wal-mart and Kmart - the Structure of the Five Main Business Functions" compares and contrasts the ways in which marketing, operations, human resource management, accounting and finance, and information management are structured and organized.... With this in mind, we shall consider here the success or failure of two competitors namely, Wal-mart and Kmart, both of which are general merchandise discounters.... While Sam Walton (CEO Wal-mart) did start off with the basic idea borrowed from Kmart but his strategy was unique....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

The Wal-Mart Effect

It can negotiate with, though some critics would call it 'force,' suppliers to sell goods to them at a lower price since they can purchase larger volumes.... When large firms such as Wal-Mart enter communities, they have economies of scale and scope that allow them to affect the prices of goods, wages, and demand for different products in these communities.... The following paper "The Wal-mart Effect" explores if it is a valid criticism that large corporations, such as Wal-mart and Home Depot, have driven out mom-and-pop shops out of business and other factors that resulted in dead small stores through examining the Wal-mart effect....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Developing a Marketing Plan for Nestle

This paper attempts to develop a marketing plan for the company in its plan to enter a new market.... Paper discussed different modes of entry to an international market and the marketing.... ... ... The marketing approach done goes along on the corporate objectives and mission. ... ... ince Nestle S....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Wal-Mart's Inhumane Practices

The reason is very simple: the price Wal-Mart offers is cheaper than other places, which is the main marketing slogan of 'Everyday Low Prices'(Fast Company para.... Recently, a documentary was produced: Wal-Mart: The High Cost of Low price.... After I learned and acknowledged what kind of company Wal-Mart is, I have joined thousands of people avoiding Wal-Mart.... The writer of this assignment "Wal-mart's Inhumane Practices" discusses the problems Wal-mart's employees are currently facing and the measures to deal with them....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us