StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Representation of an Indigenous Culture - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper is about the depiction of a First Nations Group in Canada. The group that I have selected is the Inuit and I have chosen a few articles to critique based on the way they have been represented. The point of debate is whether they have been depicted as “noble savages” or “savage beasts”…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.4% of users find it useful
The Representation of an Indigenous Culture
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Representation of an Indigenous Culture"

RUNNING HEAD: CULTURE IDENTITY: THE DEPICTION Culture Identity: The Depiction of “Noble Savage” and “Savage Beast” Abstract Culture Identity: The Depiction of “Noble Savage” and “Savage Beast” Introduction This paper is about the depiction of a First Nations Group in Canada. The group that I have selected is the Inuit and I have chosen a few articles to critique basing on the way they have been represented in the articles. The point of debate is whether they have been depicted as “noble savages” or “savage beasts”. Is there a point of view that is in favor of the group or against it? These are some of the questions that I hope to tackle in this paper. The articles selected have been listed in the reference at the end of this paper. Ethnocentricity The concept of ethnocentricity is particularly useful for the analysis that I seek to do. Ethnocentricity argues that the representation of an indigenous culture by outsiders must be done with a view to portray them as they would see themselves as. Thus, the concept applied to the Inuit is that the portrayal by outsiders should be analyzed from the frame of reference that of trying to understand their views about themselves. This does not mean that any outsider’s view of the Inuit is necessarily derogatory or biased. It just means that the views presented in the article must be balanced with the perspective of this concept. As such, the terms of reference for this paper reflect the concept very much and the attempt is to find out if the articles do so. The Inuit Paradox Though the title of the article may sound patronizing and condescending, it nonetheless is a good representation of the way in which the article has been developed. My opinion on this is that the article should not be judged by the title alone and the contents of the same should be scanned for a deeper reading of the article. The article goes to great lengths to delve into the eating habits of the Inuit and makes a point that the way in which they have developed their eating habits is a function of the climatic conditions that they have been used to. Thus, the use of fatty foods is not because they do not want to stay healthy or fit, but the living conditions make them eat the fatty foods in order to survive in the extremely cold conditions. Of course, the living habits of the Eskimos are detailed to a great extent to indicate the fact that their lifestyle may not be healthy and hence they need the kind of foods that they take. The tone of the article is a bit patronizing, though. My feeling is that we are unable to shake off the tendency to look at ethnic groups in more favorable terms and thus we need to ensure that the same comes through in our representation of the groups. There are umpteen sentences in the article that have the Inuit portrayed as humane and the like but again there is a danger of falling into the trap of the “noble savage” concept that was one of the questions for this paper. However, the article has conveyed in a proper sense the living conditions of the Inuit and has managed to draw the distinctions between the way in which the Inuit lives and eats and the conditions that create these habits in the first place. Though I mentioned that the tone is somewhat patronizing, an attempt has been made to integrate the views of the Inuit person along with the narrative so that they gel in. The article is quite lengthy and describes the conditions of the Inuit in their habitat. The narrative is structured and there is a genuine attempt to understand the ways of the Inuit. However, there could be more emphasis on turning the section on the lifestyle of the Inuit into a synthesis rather than merely attempting to use it as a reference point for their eating habits. In conclusion as the title states there is indeed a paradox but that if seen from the point of view of the Inuit would look like the same about the writer’s way of life. Inuit Art This article is much more about the way in which the Inuit’s art has evolved from being a very personal and opinionated to one where sharply political overtones are being expressed. The author seems to have a genuine concern for the way in which the trappings of modern life have taken over the Inuit’s lifestyle and have impacted them to such an extent that their art forms are getting impacted as well. The writer makes a point about how changing lifestyles with the advent of modernization have contributed to the art forms of the Inuit changing in texture and flavor. The article is a balanced view point of the Inuit and their art forms and there is a deep felt concern for the rush of modernization that has resulted in the art form changing its look and feel. Who Own Native Culture When the question of appropriating symbols associated with a particular culture is concerned, everyone seems to be on the same side and on opposing sides at the same time. This is because the people who protest against appropriation from their native culture are on the same side as those whose culture has evolved by borrowing ideas and concepts from other cultures. Thus, it is by no means possible for one culture to say that they are exclusivist and that they have the right over the symbols that their culture has. And the opposing sides are that they seem to be fighting over the fact that their symbols belong to them alone. As such, culturally exclusivist tendencies need to be curbed and we need to ensure that no one culture has rights over the same. There is a need for acceptance of the rights over the cultures of others and also a need to tolerate and respect different cultures. Coming to the point about the culture of the savages, there is a movement from the indigenous communities all over the world to protest appropriation of their symbols and ensure that they own the symbols. Thus, the title about “who owns native culture” is not only apt but also a pointer to the fact that as indigenous cultures adapt to modern conceptions, they need to ensure a balance between the need to preserve their culture and integrate at the same time. Eugenics This is an interesting article on the nature of Eugenics and the “nature versus nurture” debate. The author firmly places himself against the selection of specific races stating that “Eugenics should, therefore, not be allowed to deceive us into the belief that we should try to raise a race of supermen, nor that it should be our aim to eliminate all suffering and pain. The attempt to suppress those defective classes whose deficiencies can be proved by rigid methods to be due to hereditary causes, and to prevent unions that will unavoidably lead to the birth of disease-stricken progeny, is the proper field of eugenics” (Boas, 1916) . Thus, the article can be said to be sympathetic to the concept of the “savages” who want to have their life undisturbed by concepts of racial superiority and the like. The author makes clever use of the metaphors used to describe the relativistic concepts used by several writers used to justify the genetic mapping. As the author points out, any attempt to remove deficiencies would only lead to social unrest and thus the concept of a “perfect” society cannot be achieved. The world exists because there are deficiencies to counter the perfection and as the article points out; many great works of art are the result of mental agony and are a form of catharsis for the artists. Thus, we live in a non-ideal world and it is much better for us to accept our deficiencies and move on instead of aiming for a society free of impurities. My opinion on the article is that the concept of a “noble savage” as well as a “savage beast” is conceptions applied by supposedly normal people. What we have to realize is that emotions are universal and it is human to be emotional. As the author points out, we use our emotions to act and then justify our actions using reason. Thus, there is no way in which the emotional side of us however deficient we may be can be wiped out. Conclusion In conclusion, what is apparent is that native cultures and modern cultures are two sides of the same coin with different yardsticks being applied to judge them. A closer reading of geography, history and culture shows that as we evolve we pick up strands from other cultures and the process of evolution also consists of trying to protect our native culture from extinction. Thus, what is needed is a balance between adapting to the modern world and a desire to preserve one’s uniqueness. References Boas, F. (1916). Eugenics. The Scientific Monthly. Brown, M. (2003). Who Owns Native Culture? Harvard University Press. Gadsby, P. (n.d.) The Inuit Paradox. Discover Magazine. Retrieved Nov 27 2008 from http://discovermagazine.com/2004/oct/inuit-paradox/article_view?b_start:int=3&-C= Reeves, J. (n.d.). On Inuit Art. The Walrus. Retrieved Nov 27 2008 from http://www.walrusmagazine.com/articles/2007.11-inuit-art/ Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Representation of an Indigenous Culture Essay, n.d.)
The Representation of an Indigenous Culture Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/culture/1549899-culture-identity
(The Representation of an Indigenous Culture Essay)
The Representation of an Indigenous Culture Essay. https://studentshare.org/culture/1549899-culture-identity.
“The Representation of an Indigenous Culture Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/culture/1549899-culture-identity.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Representation of an Indigenous Culture

Syncretism . The ways indigenous traditions shape and inform Latina/o expressions of Christianity

In relation to religious syncretism, it refers to the introduction of foreign belief systems within an indigenous belief pattern.... In relation to religious syncretism, it refers to the introduction of foreign belief systems within an indigenous belief pattern and the blending of the different teaching patterns.... To this end, millions of people embraced Christianity and the message of love brought by Our Lady of Guadalupe, substituted the pervasive institutional violence synonymous with Aztec culture....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Child protection in Australia

Over-representation of indigenous or aboriginal Australian children in the welfare system is a cause for concern in this sector.... Historical practices and events, which took place at the time of first contact and onwards, have presented a crucial link to issues such as over-representation of indigenous people affecting aboriginals in this country today.... This paper seeks to address the historical and more recent ideologies, welfare practices and government policies that have the current situation of over-representation of indigenous people....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Cultural Experiences

Thus knowledge of "Indian Literature"(however controversial the term is) is being generated in the medium of English, since the rare combination of, say, a Punjabi folklore (in a Punjabi local dialect or even major language) being integrated into Bengali literature by another Bengali author who has quite a deft hand at understanding that specific sub-division of Punjabi language or culture.... Again, this lead to the very question of information and its readers, since, the finer points of intercultural translation are no necessary to a class of people who are literate, dependent on the print media for preservation of culture that cannot but precipitate the words and ideological, spiritual and social practices of the Subalterns in their complex standing....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Correcting Representation and Giving Self-Representation: The Work of George Caitlin and Etahdleuh Doanmoe

Self-representation of oppressed and minority populations has proven an effective way to create a voice in the public discourse and to question the validity of particular suppositions which underlie the dominant paradigms of understanding.... Though these Doanmoe sketches lack the formal compositional techniques of Caitlin's oeuvre the contrast between representation and self-representation of Native American populations is well manifested in the juxtaposition of these two bodies of work....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Indigenous Australians - Field Trip at the Australian Museum

More specifically, it allowed me to understand deeply the Indigenous Australians culture and lifestyle, especially where the resources for their daily lives were shown.... In this assessment, I was also able to… Activities involved in the activity included the following: designing the layout of the presentation, its animation, and photos; and placing the information that the other group members wrote and researched Reflection for HSIE The topic that was chosen was indigenous Australians....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Why Should the Indigenous Languages of Panama Be Preserved

The indigenous populations of Panama are indeed native to the state,… This is roughly a 5% representation of the overall state population, hence symbolically being referred to as the minorities.... Panama is a South American state, which is widely diversified, in terms of indigenous populations; languages and dialects; cultures and tradition, as well as in terms of the environment and eco-systems present.... Two major tribes – the Ngäbe-Bugle and the Guaymi, represent bout a half of the indigenous populations of the state, and are thus an important facet of the existing agitation for state recognition and subsequent preservation of indigenous languages....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

Stereotyping the Australian Aboriginals in Film Representation

The film, “Australia”, has been extensively analyzed in order to establish an over-all representation of the stereotyping associated with Australian Aborigines.... The film, “Australia”, effectively portrays racial discrimination as experienced by the indigenous Australian population.... The non-indigenous actors in “Australia” support the prevalent racial ideologies through replacement, insinuation as well as the subordination of the Aborigines....
6 Pages (1500 words) Movie Review

Indigenous Approaches to Holistic Education

The goal of the paper is to bring a clarity to the indigenous approaches to holistic education.... Such clarity facilitates and aids a comparison of holistic education approach with other educational initiatives and permits curriculum designers to examine their claims about their ideas of indigenous approaches … The author of the paper examines a holistic education as encompassed by indigenous education calls for learners to take ownership of their wholesome development....
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us