StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Montesquieu Encourages His Readers to Identify with or Distance Themselves from the Characters - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Montesquieu Encourages His Readers to Identify with or Distance Themselves from the Characters" states that the Persian characters are Montesquieu’s tools. And they did function effectively, judging from the way The Persian Letters is now recognized as a contributor to the development…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.7% of users find it useful
Montesquieu Encourages His Readers to Identify with or Distance Themselves from the Characters
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Montesquieu Encourages His Readers to Identify with or Distance Themselves from the Characters"

?Discuss the way in which, Montesquieu encourages his readers to identify with or distance themselves from the characters in the "Persian Letters" The Persian Letters (Letteres Persanes) is one of the best remembered works of Charles de Montesquieu. It is a satire published in 1721, about France but narrated through the eyes and exploits of two Persian noblemen. The two leading characters, Usbek and Rica, were vacationing in Paris and their various correspondence contained in-depth and critical perspectives and opinions about the laws, government and morals of France during their time. The opus is considered an epistolary novel because the narrative took the form of letters. This literary style and the socio-political content of the novel as told by two foreign figures enabled its readers to identify with the characters at the same time feel separated from their stories and experiences. It also allowed Montesquieu to achieve his objective in writing the novel. Detachment The first prominent variable that affects the way readers perceive and interpret The Persian Letters is its form. As a collection of letters, which contain discourses and essays on diverse issues, it made the novel disconnected to the readers because the emotional involvement is stunted by the interrupted presentation. This is best explained by Theodore Braun who commented that the novel "moves along in an apparently unpredictable manner from letter to letter, from theme to theme, from interior plot to the exterior plot" making the readers fumble particularly in making sense or identifying the coherence of all the parts provided (Runyon 2005, 13). Readers can also feel the detachment when Montesquieu used Persian characters in his narrative. Their characterizations were depicted as alien for the original intended reading public. They are Persians and that their way of life and their perspectives on the French lifestyle represent a glaring difference that is easily identified and sympathized with by the readers. Montesquieu, wrote Hulliung (1976), substituted Persian travelers with psyches that are long written full by Eastern culture and that the interaction between the East and the West could lead to the threat on the Eastern language of despotism (117). By transplanting the two Oriental characters in Paris, there was a depiction of a striking polarity in culture and ideas. Say, when Montesquieu portrayed the Persians as exotic, with sufficient allusions to their cultural norms and their harem and so forth, the reader naturally sided with the West and/or the French society and that the two protagonists - including all that they stood for - came to constitute otherness, the unknown and the unidentifiable. There was an imposed detachment that came with the double plot of the novel. At one point, there was the criticism of the Parisian way of life. On the other hand, there was the Oriental storyline (e.g. the disorder in the protagonist's seraglio back home). This approach enabled Montesquieu to highlight his themes more effectively, more specifically the kind of skepticism and relativism that he obviously wanted to express about the important questions that characterized his time. Furthermore, the differences and the detachment that the author encouraged were necessary in order to explain his ideal social theory. This is when Montesquieu was able to successfully reject the European social theory and advocate the actual expression of human nature as the ultimate solution to the issues and problems that confronted his day (Rossides 1998, 72). Connection It is, however, important to underscore that even though The Persian Letters assumed a degree of disconnect from its readers, there are times when its characters - or the themes and issues they discussed and were involved in - came close to the readers’ hearts and own concerns. As a political allegory, the novel explored, examined and commented on themes and issues that are relevant to the times. For example, there is the issue about love, social institutions, gender equality, religion, philosophy, social developments, ideas, freedom and melodrama. Readers can easily identify with these themes. The use of the Persian characters and the imposition of detachment are seen as necessary in order for Montesquieu to express his critique of France in his work. There was a repressive environment during the publication of The Persian Letters and steps were taken in order for the novel to get published and achieve its objective in the most effective manner without getting censored, banned or confiscated. Through the innocent/ignorant and “fresh” perspective provided by the Persian guests, Montesquieu was able criticize the French government without being self-righteous or preachy and moralizing. For instance, in the novel, the Persians marveled: The king of France is the most powerful of European potentates. He has no mines of gold like his neighbour, the king of Spain; but he is much wealthier than that prince; because his riches are drawn from a more inexhaustible source, the vanity of his subjects (Gordon 2005, 43). The above depiction was a critique of the French people as much as that of the sovereign. By using the Persians, the satirical approach was achieved with overly angering the French public. They could afford criticism of that kind coming from an outsider without having to worry about an injured pride that comes with an attack from one of their own. Never mind that is merely fiction and a concoction of Montesquieu himself. What this point demonstrates is that, as an allegory, as a satire and through the Persian characters – Montesquieu was able to get away with his many claims and critiques. In fact, they were widely and positively received. In The Persian Letters, Montesquieu attempted to challenge the existing issues of his day as well as encourage the rethinking of what is real. The Persian characters are central to the success by which his thoughts were expressed. Crucial to his arguments are the concepts of despotism and the potency and role of observation. The Persians were products of despotic upbringing and the letters were their observations. These variables resulted in a kind of juxtaposition that allowed Montesquieu to enlighten his readers. By becoming both detached and involved, the reader is able to comprehend each of the author’s points. Had the satire been The English Letters or The Italian Letters, the whole affair would not have achieved the same amount of reception from the reading public. Consider: if an English nobleman would attack the French lifestyle or its government, would it not sound hypocritical when the same dynamics and socio-political system permeate in his own country? So, all in all, the Persian characters are Montesquieu’s tools. And they did function effectively, judging from the way The Persian Letters is now recognized as a contributor to the development of modern political thought. Bibliography Gordon, Susan. Montesquieu: the French philosopher who shaped modern government. New York: The Rosen Publishing Group, 2005. Hulliung, Mark. Montesquieu and the old regime. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1976. Rossides, Daniel. Social Theory: Its Origins, History, and Contemporary Relevance. New York: General Hall, Inc., 1998. Runyon, Randolph. The art of the Persian letters: unlocking Montesquieu's "secret chain". Cranbury, NJ: Associated University Press, 2005. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Discuss the way in which, Montesquieu encourages his readers to Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1419989-discuss-the-way-in-which-montesquieu-encourages
(Discuss the Way in Which, Montesquieu Encourages His Readers to Essay)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1419989-discuss-the-way-in-which-montesquieu-encourages.
“Discuss the Way in Which, Montesquieu Encourages His Readers to Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1419989-discuss-the-way-in-which-montesquieu-encourages.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Montesquieu Encourages His Readers to Identify with or Distance Themselves from the Characters

An Analysis of the Writings of Rousseau, Montagu and Montesquieu

Rousseau notes that on the contrary, the average person who is the ideal man after creation, before the invention of the evils that were eminent in eighteenth-century Europe, is the most rational man that existed from the beginning.... A question then lingers in our minds whether all these people owe the same origin from one particular place.... These classes were distinguished in various ways and in various places that it was quite easy to segregate the society into classes depending on the manner in which they carried out themselves, the languages are spoken as well as their dressing modes and the complexity in their abodes....
4 Pages (1000 words) Term Paper

MODERN FRENCH THINKERS-POLITICAL SCIENCE PHILOSOPHY

e epigraph for the Spirit of the Law is taken from the Metamorphoses of the ancient Roman poet Ovid: “An offspring created without a mother” (2.... Montesquieu understands his work as offering a creative or original approach to both longstanding and novel problems of his political science thus harnesses the new natural science of the Enlightenment to address despotism, which he deems mankinds fundamental problem in older and newer times and in every land....
36 Pages (9000 words) Essay

An Overview of Turkish and Greek Epistolary Novels

The epistolary novel carries a greater impact on the readers because the writer is able to probe into the recesses of the characters' minds and the tensions within the subjectivity of the self.... The writer allows his characters to think on paper and to directly communicate their innermost feelings and emotions to each other and to the readers without interference from the author.... from this research, it is clear that novels transport readers into a whole new world where through vicarious experiences of the heroes and heroines, their lives are enriched and colored and their horizons greatly expanded....
37 Pages (9250 words) Essay

Comparison between Mores Utopia and Montesquieus Persian Letters

from the paper "Comparison between Mores Utopia and Montesquieus Persian Letters" it is clear that More's Utopia and Montesquieu's Persian letters criticize the forms of governments and politics in France and England while they depart on views on religion, human rights, gender and economic issues.... While the genre is significantly characterized by journeys, the forms of writing range from letters, maps, instructions, narrations and diaries.... Both Thomas More through his voice Hythloday and Montesquieu view the politics of their countries as corrupt and full of vices and evils....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Which Form of Governance is the best, Compare views of John Locke and Montesquieu

Although Locke and Montesquieu do not use similar terms because they were removed from each other by time and space, yet the similarity between the two is founded on the principles they vouched for.... ohn Locke's ideas that characterize his persuasion on his opinion concerning the best form of government are mostly found in his Second Treatise on Civil Government.... Interestingly, a look at John Locke and montesquieu's treatises on the best form of government seem to have a point of....
16 Pages (4000 words) Term Paper

In what ways is it evident that paine and publius were influenced by montesquieu and locke

he American idea of equality, freedom and human rights that came from Paine's and Publius's mind and the philosophies of their predecessors Locke and Montesquieu set the 18th century world on fire.... In his.... In his book, The Spirit of Laws, Thomas Paine was an English-American political writer who lived between (1737–1809).... mong his most remarkable publications, Common Sense (1776); Paine argued that the British colonies in America should revolt against the Crown....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Health & Australian Federal Government

The examination comprises of questions ranging from the country's history and values such as cultural and political values the Australians hold dear.... There is a contention that a test such as this may not succeed as nation states are not spurred by values since a national character could not spawn from the directive of an overlord whose convictions are immoral and self-serving.... For Rawls, nation-states are moral societies that could foster cooperation from its citizens who behave with self-respect and gentle manners....
17 Pages (4250 words) Case Study

In What Ways Is It Evident That Paine and Publius Were Influenced by Montesquieu and Locke

It has had a lot of critics, especially from activists and scholars.... Paine, who appears to be an activist, seems to have been moved by this observation and opinion from Locke.... Being a failure in most of what he had tried in life, he became a radical democrat and started handling matters that emulated to a certain level, the work of his predecessors in the names of John Locke and Montesquieu.... In his opinion, Paine prefers the state of liberty enjoyment through society without a government....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us