StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Ethics in Disaster Relief - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Ethics in Disaster Relief" discusses that generally, obviously, compassion, courage, and generosity are some of the basic virtues of a disaster relief worker. Disaster relief workers attempt to save others' lives by risking their own lives…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.3% of users find it useful
Ethics in Disaster Relief
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Ethics in Disaster Relief"

? Ethics in Disaster Relief Ethics in Disaster Relief Ethical Conflict in Relief Planning While analyzing the contemporary disaster management and relief planning practices, certain elements of ethical conflicts are usually found. The most important ethical conflict identified in relief planning is that underdeveloped communities around the globe are excluded from relief management practices on the ground of caste discrimination. According to National Dalit Watch-National Campaign (n. d.), on Dalit Human Rights (NCDHR), nearly 260 million caste-affected people are living in the world. The organisation also points that caste-affected population are most likely to be discriminated even during disaster relief practices. The case of Dalit, a mixed and untouchable population living in South Asia, will provide a clear view of the caste discrimination practices in relief planning. Dalits are underdeveloped socio-economically and most of them are low educated people. The events of disasters like 2004 tsunami and flooding in India, Nepal, and Pakistan demonstrated the degree to which the issue of caste discrimination can enhance inequity and affect underdeveloped populations including Dalits (NCDHR). Studies identified that Dalits are highly vulnerable to natural and human made disasters because they do not have improved habitation settlements. In many areas, Dalits are segregated from other communities or Dalits do not have access to mainstream settlements. Hence, vast majority of the Dalit people are living in places that are highly prone to all kinds of disasters. Even though disasters dreadfully affect the lives of Dalits, legal authorities or other interest groups do not still prioritize needs of Dalits. The fairness or justice approach can be applied in this case. This approach was evolved from the teachings of the ancient Greek philosopher Aristotle, who argued that “equals should be treated equally and unequal unequally”. Evidently, the justice approach is against favoritism or discrimination. The above identified ethical conflict is clearly a case of discrimination because Dalits’ lives are equally important as of others. Referring to the fairness approach, Dalits have the right to obtain quick and improved disaster relief services like in the case of other people. In addition, they have to be evacuated from disaster prone areas to other safe regions. Furthermore, governments at local and national levels should make necessary legal amendments to make Dalits less vulnerable to disasters and provide Dalits with immediate response actions in times of disaster situations. International interest groups have also a crucial role to play in reducing Dalits’ vulnerability to different kinds of disasters. In short, Dalits and other populations have to be served on an equal footing in terms of disaster relief planning. Ethics of Disaster Compensation The US Federal Government created the September 11th Victim Compensation Fund shortly after the 9/11 event. At the end of this fund collection process, a total of $7 billion was awarded to over 97% of the victims’ families. Reports indicate that the average payout was around $1.8 million (Department of Justice). This huge compensation raised expectations of a similar compensation package to the victims of other disasters. Evidently, it is ethical to provide compensation to the victims of 9/11 terrorist attack. However, the same ethical approach cannot be applied to the victims of Hurricane Katrina. The 9/11 disaster caused as a result of the failure of the US government’s national security systems and hence it was avoidable. In contrast, the Hurricane Katrina was a natural disaster, which is unavoidable. The right approach can be applied to the first (9/11) case. This approach (as cited in Velasquez, Andre, Shanks, and Meyer, 1996) was developed from the thoughts of the 18th century thinker Emmanuel Kant and his contemporary counterparts. According to these thinkers “what makes human beings different from mere things is that people have dignity based on their ability to choose freely what they will do with their lives, and they have a fundamental moral right to have these choices respected” (Velasquez et al, 1996). The philosophers state that fundamental human rights include right to the truth, right of privacy, right not to be injured, right to what is agreed. The 9/11 event, which occurred as a result of the government’s security failure, breached the people’s right not to be injured. Hence, the federal government has an ethical obligation to offer such a huge compensation to victims’ families. On the other hand, Hurricane Katrina cannot be attributed to a governmental fault as it was a natural disaster. Therefore, the US government is not obliged to compensate Hurricane Katrina victims in a way that was adopted for compensating 9/11 victims. This argument is also supported by the justice approach, which says that unequal should be treated unequally. It is recommendable for governments to compensate future terrorist attack victims hugely because such events show governments’ failure in securing their citizens. The same policy must be applicable to the victims’ of manmade disasters. However, governments should not offer huge compensations to the victims of natural disasters. Compensation for Disaster Relief Workers Disaster relief workers injured during relief operations must be exemplarily compensated. The virtue approach justifies this argument. According to this approach, “there are certain ideals toward which we should strive, which provide for the full development of our humanity” (as cited in Velasquez et al, 1996). Obviously, compassion, courage, and generosity are some of the basic virtues of a disaster relief worker. Disaster relief workers attempt to save others lives by risking their own lives. Undoubtedly, disaster relief workers are an inspiration to all and they motivate others to involve in disaster relief operations. In addition, they contribute to basic human values and fuel integral development of the society. From various perspectives, disaster relief workers are a priceless asset of any society as they promote humane activities. In addition, provision of attractive compensation packages to injured disaster relief workers would motivate more people to enter this field of human service. Evidently, more number of relief workers would effectualize disaster response operations, which in turn may save the lives of many people. It must be noted that majority of the disaster relief workers are not paid for their services or they are voluntary workers. These people add value to the nation’s common good. Therefore, there is an ethical obligation lies with governments to compensate their disaster relief workers attractively who get injured during disaster relief operations. References Department of Justice. September 11th victim compensation fund of 2011. Retrieved from http://www.justice.gov/archive/victimcompensation/ NCDHR. Addressing caste discrimination in Humanitarian Response. Retrieved from http://www.idsn.org/fileadmin/user_folder/pdf/New_files/India/2012/IDSN-EU_study_on_CBD_in_humanitarian_response_by_NDW.pdf Velasquez, M., , Andre, C., Shanks, T & Meyer, M. (1996). Thinking ethically: A framework for moral decision making. Issues in Ethics V7 N1. Retrieved from http://www.scu.edu/ethics/practicing/decision/thinking.html Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Ethics in Disaster Relief Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1457204-ethics-in-disaster-relief
(Ethics in Disaster Relief Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1457204-ethics-in-disaster-relief.
“Ethics in Disaster Relief Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1457204-ethics-in-disaster-relief.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Ethics in Disaster Relief

Hurricane Katrina's Effect on African American Community

As expected, after such a tragic event would bring to the fore some of the better qualities of humanity, the spirit of self-sacrifice, compassion, endurance, and unselfishness of the relief workers that often rush to the place to relieve the suffering of the victims by providing relief goods and medical assistance.... White, Philpot, Wylie and McGowen (2007) report that subsequently, while relief and assistance such as the series of evacuation, relocation and rebuilding must have brought comfort to the victims, the aftermath of hurricane for the African Americans was the storm feeling of anger and depression from perception of racial and class differences....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Ethics, Innovation and Technology

It was only after the engineers were confronted with the graphic, photographic imagery of numerous oil soaked marine life and birds, and heard the testimonies of the Gulf coast residents (whose culture was adversely threatened) that they began to focus their attention as a society on the imminent disaster.... The Deepwater Horizon oil spill disaster has raised many ethical issues on the engineering profession (Catalano 2011, p1).... These issues include; what exactly occurred, the role played by the engineering profession in regard to the disaster, how such disasters can be prevented in the future, ethical responsibilities, in events like the Deepwater Horizon oil spill, and if the codes of conduct developed by the engineers are adequate (Catalano 2011, p2)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Humanitarian Ethics System

The overall poor quality of life and the growing violence at all levels derived in large part of a broad crisis of values that affects the fundamentals of ethics in twenty first century. … Humanitarian aid to save lives of the neediest, while respecting the dignity of each person affected by armed conflict, famine, disease or natural disasters.... lote (2007) mentions that in its 2003 report on disasters, the International Federation of Societies of Red Cross and Red Crescent, in addition to analyzing some timely topics such as famine in southern Africa, the conflict between power and ethics in humanitarian aid to Afghanistan, the phenomenon of forced migration, framed conceptually ethics humanitarian disasters and wars, reflect on the measurement of disasters (challenges, opportunities and ethics) and provide data on disasters and refugees....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

MHE512 Disaster Relief Module 3 Case

In my opinion the application of the common good and virtues culture for relief and recovery provision for victims is the most effective application to be considered in the process of assisting victims of disasters to recover from the situation that they have been under.... I do believe that it is only through this that the rights for relief of every individual involved in the situation are given practical attention to.... Considerably, the importance of the mission of relief and recovery operations are practically given way through the application of common good and virtues culture in providing assistance....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Normative Ethics

 Natural disasters are inevitable, so these disaster relief agencies have predefined protocols in place to keep the most efficient and effective resolution within reach....  There are many agencies in place to handle the disaster like the CDC, Federal Emergency Agency, American Red Cross and Homeland Security.... Thie essay entitled "Normative ethics" deals with the moral rules and laws....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Humanitarian Supply Chains & Disaster Relief Management

The author of this assignment "Humanitarian Supply Chains & disaster relief Management" focuses on the impacts of humanitarian logistics and supply chain activities in the context of disaster management.... his study considers the critical appraisal and evaluation of the importance of logistics and supply chain management aspects and their impacts on humanitarian supply chain and disaster relief management.... There needs to be maximum consistency, coordination and assimilation between discrete, independent and diverse agencies along the humanitarian supply chain if the main objectives of such efforts are to fructify the threat of disasters itself rather than to undertake relief and rescue operations after the horses have bolted from their stables....
17 Pages (4250 words) Assignment

The Deepwater Horizon Disaster

This paper “The Deepwater Horizon disaster” explores some key decisions which might have led to the accident and the lack of ethical conduct behind the same.... The Deepwater Horizon disaster which occurred in the Gulf of Mexico in 2010 is recorded as the greatest oil spill.... hellip; The author states that millions of dollars were lost in the aftermath of the disaster.... Though each actor is responsible for the disaster in some way or other, the chief responsibility lies with BP and Transocean from whom most of the pieces of equipment were rented....
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment

UK's International Search and Rescue Team

I will consider the fire services and its impact on UK operators and rescue team, globalization, the role of the United Nations disaster assessment and coordination team, ethical considerations that are dealt with in the fire and rescue services and the role of the practitioner in a changing world environment (Kramer 2009, pp....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us