StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Ethical Relevance of Paying Large Bonuses to Top Executives of Banks that Received Bailout - Term Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper has the intent to explore the ethical range of paying large bonuses to top executives of major banks that received bailout money. The author states that performance-based bonus payment is the best method that would aid banks to take maximum advantage of employees’ potential …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.7% of users find it useful
Ethical Relevance of Paying Large Bonuses to Top Executives of Banks that Received Bailout
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Ethical Relevance of Paying Large Bonuses to Top Executives of Banks that Received Bailout"

 “Ethical Relevance of Paying Large Bonuses to Top Executives of Banks that Received Bailout” Introduction The recent past witnessed the collapse of American and European banking industries which could be attributed to strategic flaws or managerial failures. The poor governmental regulations on banking sector also contributed to this disintegration. It is said that inefficient usage of monetary tools initiated by regulators was one of the main issues associated with the strategic failure of the banking industry, which intensified the scale of bailout. The act of providing additional capital to banks and other organizations when they face the danger of bankruptcy is called bailout. During the last few years, most of the major banks in America were provided with bailout money so that they would be saved from the danger of insolvency and thereby liquidation. Since banking sector is the growth engine of a nation’s economy, government must give great care to its maintenance. In addition, the regulators can also play a vital role in preventing the disastrous effects of bankruptcy by the effective application of various financial tools. This paper has been drafted with intent to explore the ethical range of paying large bonuses to top executives of major banks that received bailout money. Bailout and its impacts on economic sector The bank bailout has a far reaching impact on a nation’s economy as it is spent out of extra budgeted money. The general public of the nation largely suffers from the bank bailout since it leads to the downturn of economy. Similarly, many investors and shareholders may lose money on their investment due to the economic collapse of banks; and therefore they hesitate to go with further dealings. The foreign investors and companies may also lose their interest in a weaker banking sector and it would adversely affect the financial viability of the nation as a whole. In the opinion of McKay (2010), the taxpayer money has been employed to meet the cash reserve needs of the banks. The money from the treasury is used to carry out fund operations, if the banks have not repaid the money (pp. 50-51). Therefore, the Federal Reserve is forced to pay more money to the banking industry at the time of depression and it breaks balanced financial structure of the various policy based operations. McKay also indicates that the banks generally utilize the cash deposits from the customers to ‘purchase mortgage-backed securities, collateralized debt, and loan obligations. In most cases, they are valued worthless and it would badly impinge on the rate of return on bank’s transactions. Likewise, it is reported that some major American banks had inflated their profit in order to attract more investors and creditors. As a result, many creditors have not been still reimbursed for their claims. “When banks fail, getting credit and loans becomes more difficult. This makes the process more difficult for the people looking to buy cars, homes, and property and perhaps for students trying to obtain educational loans” (McKay,2010, p.53). Similarly, the businessmen would not get adequate assistance from the banks and it would impede the industrial growth of the country. The failure of banks and subsequent bailout leads to incredible job losses within the country. Moreover, when the banks are compelled to withstand with the bailout money, they cannot implement new policies and programs. In short, the process of bailout will certainly cause the economic diminution of the whole country. Top executives of banks and their bonus payment Usually, banks pay high salaries to their top executives with intent to retain them in the organization since they are the skippers who lead the day to day activities. I am of the opinion that top executives of the banks that received bailout money should not be allowed to collect large bonuses. As the top executives are the decision takers of the organization regarding various matters, they are also responsible for the results obtained from the business. However, bank’s top executives are paid usual rates regardless the output of the business since the management concerns about their potentials. Andrew Cuomo, the New York Attorney General reports (as cited in Freifeld, 2009) that Citigroup Inc, Merrill Lynch & Co. and seven other US banks have paid $32.6 billion as bonuses to their executives even though they were driven to receive $175 billion in tax payer funds. Similarly, there are a large number of other cases which show the trend of giving high bonus amount to top executives out of bailout money. The top executives assume that they are entitled to get a fixed amount of bonus as a percentage of salary whether the company has performed well or not. From the Deontological point of view, the bonus payment rules do not change with changing business situations so that the top executives have the right to be paid high bonuses irrespective of the profit graph of the company. In contrast, Utilitarian view would suggest that the pain and pleasure of all actions are determined on the basis of total happiness derived from those actions (Vesilind, Morgan & Heine, 2009, p.69). Hence, the top executives of the banks must be paid well when the company performs well, and their payment must be curtailed as the company faces depression. As Freifeld (2009) comments, in usual practices, bankers pay money ranging from $80,000 to $60,000 depending on the seniority and performance of their executives rather than bank’s performance This argument is strongly supported by the AP Review as it says banks’ top executives earn an average of $2.6 million in ‘salary, bonuses and benefits’ (The Washington Times). Majority banks fear about the resignation of their top executives if they are paid in accordance with business fluctuations. In my opinion, banks must give priority to their business survival rather than their top executives’ retention. The huge bonus payment to top executives in times of crises would cause many ethical issues within the organization as it drives other employees to oppose management strategies. If the top executives are paid huge bonuses irrespective of their weaker performance, they would not take maximum efforts to run the organization more efficiently. Freifeld also points out the Cuomo report which suggests that employees must share the upside when the bank’s overall performance is strong and they must adjust with the down side when the bank weakly performs. Bailout money is the last resort for banks with which they can try to survive; hence it should not be utilized to treat the top executives. It is advisable to provide bonuses as a percentage of bank’s profit since it facilitates financial flexibility to banks. Melissa Murray, a spokeswoman for Wells Fargo (as cited in Freifeld, 2009) suggests that it is good to adopt “pay-for-performance” culture where executives are treated on the basis of their performance. This plan will motivate the top executives largely as it enables them to acquire unlimited income based on their performance. The Federal Reserve can take some effective steps regarding the top executives’ bonus payment policies, and it would prevent the failure of the banks to a large extent. The top executives must also understand the fact that their existence is based on company’s future so that they should adjust with changing financial environment. Conclusion The act of providing large bonuses during the times of bailout is an unfair practice that can adversely affect the sustainability of a bank. Although, the top executives are the inevitable cells of the business body, their bonus payment has to be regulated for the effective functioning of the whole system. Since top executives play a vital role in determining the success and failure of a business, they should have the moral obligation to share the downfall of the business. To be more specific, performance based bonus payment is the best method that would aid banks to take maximum advantage of their employees’ potential. Reference “Despite bailout, bank chiefs received bonuses”.(Dec 22, 2008). The Washington Times. Retrieved from http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2008/dec/22/despite-bailout-bank-chiefs-received-bonuses/ Freifeld, K. (2009). Banks Paid $32.6 Billion in Bonuses Amid U.S. Bailout (Update4). Bloomberg. Retrieved from http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=newsarchive&sid=aHURVoSUqpho McKay, C. (2010). Smart Real Estate Deals in the Bank Bailout Era and Beyond. Bloomington, USA: AuthorHouse. Vesilind, P. A, Morgan, S. M & Heine, L. G. (2009). Introduction to Environmental Engineering. USA: Cengage Learning. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Ethical Relevance of Paying Large Bonuses to Top Executives of Banks Term Paper - 1”, n.d.)
Ethical Relevance of Paying Large Bonuses to Top Executives of Banks Term Paper - 1. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1748155-should-the-top-executives-of-the-major-banks-that-received-bail-out-money-be-allowed-to-receive-large-bonuses
(Ethical Relevance of Paying Large Bonuses to Top Executives of Banks Term Paper - 1)
Ethical Relevance of Paying Large Bonuses to Top Executives of Banks Term Paper - 1. https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1748155-should-the-top-executives-of-the-major-banks-that-received-bail-out-money-be-allowed-to-receive-large-bonuses.
“Ethical Relevance of Paying Large Bonuses to Top Executives of Banks Term Paper - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/human-resources/1748155-should-the-top-executives-of-the-major-banks-that-received-bail-out-money-be-allowed-to-receive-large-bonuses.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Ethical Relevance of Paying Large Bonuses to Top Executives of Banks that Received Bailout

Transparency and leadership in organisations

The principal aim of this dissertation is to assess the degree to which transparency and good governance have been advanced by organizational leadership in the United Arab Emirates, as they impact upon the management of projects within the federation.... ... ... ... The dissertation seeks to answer the question: How far has transparency and good governance been enhanced in the institutional infrastructure and private corporate environment in the United Arab Emirates, and to what extent has such enhancement in transparency impacted upon the UAE's economic progress?...
45 Pages (11250 words) Dissertation

Ethical perspectives: Alahmad, Freidman vs Drucker, Murphy

As the ethical guidelines in any business organization is framed by the business leaders, so specifying the codes of ethics for the leaders is an important concept.... Adherence to such practice by the leaders will give rise to ethical leadership in the organization and the business will strictly follow the ethics.... In order to introduce the concept of ethical leaderships in the international arena much stress was also provided by the United Nations through their peace and governance program, besides the United Nations also established the ethics office in order to regulate the practice of ethics on organizations....
48 Pages (12000 words) Essay

The Historical Context of the UAEs Imperative for Transparency and Governance

To stabilize the extremely volatile financial markets, massive bailout packages and debt restructuring efforts were urgently put together as quickly as possible.... The principal aim of this dissertation is to assess the degree to which transparency and good governance have been advanced by organizational leadership in the United Arab Emirates, as they impact upon the management of organizations within the federation....
92 Pages (23000 words) Dissertation

Investigation of the causes of failure of Lehman Brothers with special reference to agency problems

The high amount of incentive compensations offered to the top executives encouraged them to resort to such business strategies.... he findings of this study suggested that agency problems played a significant the fallout of Lehman Brothers with the company managers involved in taking several risky investment decisions, less on behalf of the owners of the company and more in the interests of top management....
34 Pages (8500 words) Dissertation

Should the Top Executives of the Major Banks That Received Bail-Out Money Be Allowed to Receive Large Bonuses

This paper has been drafted with the intent to explore the ethical range of paying large bonuses to top executives of major banks that received bailout money.... I am of the opinion that top executives of the banks that received bailout money should not be allowed to collect large bonuses.... As the paper "Should the Top Executives of the Major banks that received Bail-Out Money Be Allowed to Receive Large Bonuses?... op executives of banks and their bonus payment ...
5 Pages (1250 words) Term Paper

How Can Retail Banks in the UK Restore Customer Confidence

Customer satisfaction in UK Retail Banks has been damaged by the recent recession whether by force of circumstances following the argument of banks or by malpractices resorted to by banks.... The paper "How Can Retail banks in the UK Restore Customer Confidence" discusses that productive endeavors that produce more goods and services can result in more supply and lower cost.... In other words, there can be a way to reduce inflation if banks help in the build-up of greater productivity....
30 Pages (7500 words) Dissertation

Role of Business Ethics in Corporate America

The author of this paper "Role of Business Ethics in Corporate America" casts light on the current financial crisis as it hit the American economy and sent shock waves and repercussions to all global economies.... Reportedly, one of the reasons for this is the issue of business ethics.... ... ... ...
86 Pages (21500 words) Research Paper

Global Financial Crisis 2008 and Its Impact on the European Union

This thesis "Global Financial Crisis 2008 and Its Impact on the European Union" compares the nature and characteristics of some of the crucial financial crises of the world and considers examples of some nations like China, the USA, the UK and India who have faced it.... ... ... ... The discussion begins with a short introduction to the Great Depression of 1929 with the intention of analyzing the possible causes and theories behind the event....
89 Pages (22250 words) Thesis
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us