StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Abortion and the Rights of the Father: Inequality or Necessity - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
While the debate surrounding abortion is heated and tense in any case, the added issue relating to the rights of the father in such cases makes the topic of abortion increasingly controversial…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98% of users find it useful
Abortion and the Rights of the Father: Inequality or Necessity
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Abortion and the Rights of the Father: Inequality or Necessity"

Download file to see previous pages

While the approach to the paternal figure in abortion cases differs greatly worldwide, past case law in the UK shows a clear lack of paternal rights, particularly when the father attempts to stop the abortion.2 There are of course critics of such an approach to fathers, which have increased their level of rigour since the coming into force of the Abortion Act 1967. Movements supporting father’s rights and the men’s movement lay a claim to the inequality of the importance afforded to women over men, and require that both be considered equally.

Such critics claim that the greater importance placed on women’s rights is unjustified, unreasonable and discriminatory.3 It is claimed that the law allows for women to force a man into fatherhood as well as deprive him of his right to become a father,4 and critics thus call for men to be given the legal right to prevent the woman from having an abortion. It is evident that the law places greater importance on the desire of the woman because she must carry the baby; the issue directly concerns her right to her body and her choice over what should happen to it.

5 Despite the evident delicacy of the issues surrounding fathers’ rights in relation to abortion, it is often argued that there is a considerable degree of exaggeration in terms of the father’s response. Disagreement is often rare between couples, and men seldom resort to legal action.6 Yet should this be interpreted as making the right of the woman rights trump those of the man in every case?7 It is argued that the woman’s right to freedom of choice over what happens to her body and private life should always trump those of the father.

The law is extremely clear on the matter: the spouse or partner of the woman simply has not legal ability to prevent or enforce an abortion.8 This stubborn yet clear stance of the law has not been declared to be in breach of the European Convention of Human Rights; the stance of the European Court clearly considers that the rights of the father do “not embrace procedural rights to be consulted where the woman intended to have an abortion”.9 This also extends to state that the woman is under no obligation to notify the father of her intention to abort the child.

There is an evident conflict in the law, however, in that it requires that the father provide financial support to the child from birth; this serves to invest not only rights in the father, but also obligations. The stance of this requirement at law is based on the assumption that “the father’s responsibility for his offspring stems from the fact that he engaged in an act, sexual intercourse, which he fully realized could result in the creation of another human being”.10 The argument progresses as thus: if the law actively invests rights and obligations in the father when the child has been born, why does it decline to invest the same rights and obligations before the child has been born?

This stance taken by the law allows the woman to abort despite the fact that the father may want the child, yet forces the man to pay for the child if he wanted to abort and the woman did not11 – the fairness and equality afforded to each side is extremely uneven. There is obvious fear expressed in assigning the father rights in terms of whether the woman can abort or not. Are grave dangers or injustices risked if the father is given rights to contribute to the abortion decision of the woman?

The very imposition of obligations on the father once the child has been born suggests that the approach of the law concludes that: “

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Abortion and the Rights of the Father: Inequality or Necessity Essay”, n.d.)
Abortion and the Rights of the Father: Inequality or Necessity Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1437928-medicine-and-the-law
(Abortion and the Rights of the Father: Inequality or Necessity Essay)
Abortion and the Rights of the Father: Inequality or Necessity Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1437928-medicine-and-the-law.
“Abortion and the Rights of the Father: Inequality or Necessity Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1437928-medicine-and-the-law.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Abortion and the Rights of the Father: Inequality or Necessity

Abortion:legal discussion

oes such a balance sufficiently address the moral conscience of today's society… Present day legal discussion on abortion is concerned with both the autonomy of the pregnant woman and the rights of the foetus.... and it seeks to explore whether the law provides equal attention and priority to both the autonomy of the pregnant woman and the rights of the foetus.... Legal discussion on abortion has concerned the autonomy of the pregnant woman as balanced against the rights of the foetus....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Assessment of the Conflicting Approaches to Reproductive Rights - Rights-Based Analysis

Fetal “personhood” has become a tool to challenge women's rights of self-determination with respect to their bodily integrity.... Reproductive rights are basically of three types: (1) the freedom to decide how many children to have, and when to have them; (2) the right to have information and means to regulate one's fertility: and (3) the right to have and exercise control over one's own body.... hellip; The notion of women's reproductive rights sought to challenge the reduction of women through gendered and patriarchal institutions of government, on, and health professionals, who justified intervention in women's reproductive self-determination in the name of public order, morality, and public health....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

Abortion: Does a foets have a human right to life

The rising debate in the society as for the rights of the woman to kill the unborn child made it clear that the necessary laws had to be created for the definition of the basic terms and for giving (or not giving) the fetus the right to live and the right to exist.... While it mostly touched moral and ethical sides, it became clear that without legal definition of the terms as abortion, fetus, embryo and the related subjects and situations it will be impossible to regulate the situation with abortions....
20 Pages (5000 words) Essay

The War Against Boys

hellip; The author refers feminism as a social spectrum, which incorporates aspects like the pursuit of various schemes and fantasies, delusional feminist aspects to the rationality concepts, all aimed towards advocating for the recognition and application of women rights principles.... On the other hand, equity feminism is associated with equal rights and equal treatment of women in the society.... On the opposite side, equity feminism is credited because it is occupied with the purpose of advocating and supporting the aspect of equal rights to every member of a society....
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment

Reproductive Rights and Welfare as Issues Facing American Families

ithens (2014) in the “Mercy killing," "reproductive rights" and other ill-conceived liberal phrases” claims that there is no necessity to fight for women's reproductive rights since today females are so liberal in their choice of every possible aspect of childbearing.... The paper "Reproductive rights and Welfare as Issues Facing American Families" discusses the social welfare in the United States.... hellip; American families face numerous critical issues today including reproductive rights and welfare....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Stalins Policies on Women and Family

In the following paper “Stalin's Policies on Women and Family” the author examines how official Soviet State policy on women and the family changed after Stalin came to power, and what were the effects of the Stalin years on women and the family.... hellip; The author states that Joseph Stalin, a renowned Russian leader has been of great interest to historians all over the world....
12 Pages (3000 words) Assignment

Abortion: the Law and Its Impact on the Rights of Young Women and Victims of Rape

It can also be argued that abortion affects the rights of the unborn fetus.... From the paper "Abortion: the Law and Its Impact on the rights of Young Women and Victims of Rape" it is clear that if the law requires us to look after our own well-being, and the well-being of others in our societies, then the question of abortion becomes even more complicated.... nbsp; Society's laws should reflect the values of the community but also protect the individual's rights....
11 Pages (2750 words) Coursework

Abortion, Choice and a Right

This paper “abortion, Choice and a Right” presents the pro-choice and right-to-life view positions, both of which are compelling then concludes that legal abortions should remain legal and safe.... It's an election year meaning the abortion debate is again a main focus of the national dialogue.... The often contentious national discussion concerning legalized abortion is emotional and divisive.... abortion is a multi-faceted subject and both sides of the issue present credible, thought-provoking arguments....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us