StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Competition among Hospitals for HMO Business - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
The study of the effect of price and non-price attributes to the share of HMO business among hospitals based on an empirical analysis of Florida acute hospitals covering the period from 1992 to 1997 centered on finding answers to two questions: (1) In the competition among hospitals for HMO business, what is the relative importance of price versus non-price attributes and (2) Do patterns of competition among hospitals for HMO business appear to differ depending on market characteristics The theoretical framework used by the authors states that a hospital's share of HMO business in its market is a function of a combination of several price and non-price attributes, and that hospitals that offe…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.1% of users find it useful
Competition among Hospitals for HMO Business
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Competition among Hospitals for HMO Business"

Summary: Competition among Hospitals for HMO Business Research Questions, Theoretical Framework, and Variables The study of the effect of price andnon-price attributes to the share of HMO business among hospitals based on an empirical analysis of Florida acute hospitals covering the period from 1992 to 1997 centered on finding answers to two questions: (1) In the competition among hospitals for HMO business, what is the relative importance of price versus non-price attributes and (2) Do patterns of competition among hospitals for HMO business appear to differ depending on market characteristics The theoretical framework used by the authors states that a hospital's share of HMO business in its market is a function of a combination of several price and non-price attributes, and that hospitals that offer lower prices to HMOs have a competitive advantage.

The study attempted to add to the literature that contradicts Porter's theory that firms rarely achieve competitive advantage by applying both price and differentiation strategies. To measure the market share of hospitals, the dependent variables are (1) HMO revenue and (2) HMO admissions. The independent variables are: an index of relative hospital prices for HMO business in each market (price); high tech-capability; teaching status (teaching or non-teaching); ownership status (non-profit, for-profit, or public); and location.

To provide answer to the second research question, that is, to account for the effect of the structure of the hospital market on market share, three variables were added: no. of hospitals in the market, no. of HMOs in the market, and the HMO penetration rate.Key Findings: For both price and non-price attributes, the regression test pointed to an effect on market share variables. Hospitals with lower prices had a bigger share of HMO business. The more high-tech a hospital was, the greater the share in the HMO business.

Teaching hospitals were more preferred by HMOs than non-teaching ones. On the effect of ownership: on average, nonprofit and public hospitals had less market share than for-profit ones. Location: hospitals located relatively farther from the market center had lessmarket share. Among the competitive attributes, high-tech capability had the largest effect on market share, followed by price and location. As to the effect of market structure on market share, all were statistically significant: the number of hospitals was associated with lower hospital-level market share; the number of HMO plans was associated with lower market share and; the HMO penetration rate was associated with higher hospital-level market share.

Further tests whether patterns of competition among hospitals for HMO business vary in relation to market structure revealed that the more HMO plans, the less effect of the competitive attributes on the share of HMO business for hospitals, whether based on revenue or admissions. On analysis of the hospitals with more than 30% of market share based on revenues, these hospitals were found to have relatively lower prices, greater high-tech capability and a closer geographic proximity to the market centroid.

However among the rest of the hospitals apart from the market leaders, the study revealed that those with relatively lower prices typically had less rather than high-tech capability, and are relatively farther than closer to the market centroid. Thus, market leaders successfully combined price and non-price attributes in a strategy that was different from the rest. The authors claim that the study is among the first to investigate whether and to what degree hospitals compete for HMO business on the basis of price and non-price strategies.

The study proves that hospitals appear to compete for HMO business on the basis of both price and non-price attributes. It also supported the theory that firms can compete successfully by combining cost leadership and differentiation strategies.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Competition among Hospitals for HMO Business Case Study”, n.d.)
Competition among Hospitals for HMO Business Case Study. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1526576-competition-among-hospitals-for-hmo-business
(Competition Among Hospitals for HMO Business Case Study)
Competition Among Hospitals for HMO Business Case Study. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1526576-competition-among-hospitals-for-hmo-business.
“Competition Among Hospitals for HMO Business Case Study”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1526576-competition-among-hospitals-for-hmo-business.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Competition among Hospitals for HMO Business

The Market for Health Insurance

Some commerce analysts have expressed competition amid primary health care providers as strong, and some pricing trends show that competing has stalwartly impacted on insurers' market plans.... Name Instructor Course Date The Market for Health Insurance Overview It is a well known fact that most American citizens with health coverage obtain their insurance via health programs which are provided by the companies in which they work for....
20 Pages (5000 words) Essay

Human Services Issues

Statistics show that children make up 25% of the homeless in urban areas, and among the homeless adult, 14% are unmarried females and 47% are unmarried males (McNamara 2008, 52).... Name Name of Professor Social Problems in the United States: Homelessness, Unemployment, and Health Care/Managed Care The Homeless There is no generally recognized data of the actual population of homeless in the United States currently obtainable, and the most current figures by the Bloomberg administration, as cited by Julie Bosman (2010), successfully evade the problem of concrete figures of homeless people....
14 Pages (3500 words) Research Paper

Managing Business Operations

It starts by giving a brief explanation of the concept of operations management, analyzes the nature of the business at the Swedish Medical Centre, the scope of services offered and selected areas of operations management.... Operations management touches on all aspects of the business, not just on ‘operations' (Slack et al....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

Role of Healthcare Marketing and Advice to American Health Care Association

Thus, it shows that transmission of exact information at accurate time helps to enhance the customer satisfaction, corporate image, increase of customer response resulting in augmentation of the business prospects.... Process includes the diverse tasks that are performed by the hospitals such as admission, diagnosis, and treatments by experts, results and discharges.... In case of hospitals, place or location plays a crucial role.... Along with this, types of Medicare services offered by the hospital also play a vital part such as 'The Mount Sinai Medical Center' for cancer treatment is located at the heart of New York in the US rather than other hospitals (Mount Sinai Medical Center, 2012)....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Management Accounting at Hospital

The characteristics of employment relations in the Hospital's SMEs are different from State Owned Enterprises (SOEs), Joint Ventures (JVs) or large private the hospitals (Owens, 2006, p.... This makes him more likely to seek hospitals that provide better extrinsic and intrinsic rewards.... among the HR professionals, there was 38 percent of them had an increased employee turnover in the past 12-18 months.... hellip; There is always a high employee turnover rate among skilled laundry supervisors....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Cost and Quality Anaylsis

Although some of these including certain employer contribution techniques, managed care for addressing the cost implications of parity mandates, and competition among HMOs - have been at least to a certain extent successful, many of the others have mixed results.... The other initiative is the adoption of health maintenance organizations (HMOs) and competition.... For example, the competition between HMOs in a competitive market leads to lowering of premiums while at the same time forcing individual HMOs to maintain high quality in their services so they can remain competitive....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Job Satisfaction among Healthcare Employees in Hospitals in Saudi Arabia

The objectives of each and every healthcare organization are to ensure health and provide healthcare services, through the promotion of health and the prevention of disease.... However, these health services can not be delivered without the presence of a professional medical team… physicians, nurses, lab technicians, and others)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

History of Managed Care in the US

Legislation to HMO would promote competition in the healthcare market, which would offer an alternative to outpatient to attend expensive hospitals for treatment.... It also required companies that had 25 or more employees to register for an hmo by giving health insurance cover to all their employees.... Michael started by establishing a health cooperative for farmers without involving any specialist or general hospitals....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us