StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Freedom and Determinism Problem - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
I. 1. Determinism Determinism is a metaphysical theory that all events (a category that subsumes the subcategory of human events and actions) are subjected to causes external to the willful choices of human beings. This idea is similar to the idea in physics that cause-and-effect occurs for every phenomenon in the known universe…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.3% of users find it useful
Freedom and Determinism Problem
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Freedom and Determinism Problem"

Download file to see previous pages

One should distinguish between the idea that events in the universe are linked causally and the idea that events in the universe are linked correlatively. In the first view, exemplified by Newtonian physics, is that the trajectories of billiard balls are determined by their interactions (using factors such as velocity, momentum, and so on). In the second view, certain events are correlatively linked to others, leading to the perception of a causal relationship. 2. Libertarianism Metaphysical libertarianism is the contrary position to determinism, holding that a human free will does exist and that free will is incompatible with determinism.

A completely free will implies that no external events act upon or causally determine the chosen actions of human beings. In other words, a person is able to take any of a set of actions under particular circumstances; that is, his choice is not limited to only one possible choice, as is claimed by determinism. One should distinguish between the idea that libertarianism applies to non-physical objects and physical objects. In the first view, the mind is a non-physical entity outside of physical causation and does not rely on the brain for causative explanations.

In the second view, libertarianism implies indeterminism in the physical world (invoking ideas of newer quantum physics), which extends to the physical mind. 3. Compatibilism If libertarianism and determinism are two sides on a continuum, then compatibilism is the middle ground between those two positions. Essentially, the idea is that free will and deterministic causation are compatible ideas, making it possible to logically believe in both at the same time. Of course, compatibilists do not believe in the same kind of free will that libertarians do.

While libertarians define free will in a way that is logically inconsistent with a physically deterministic universe, compatibilists define it in a manner that is consistent with a deterministic physical universe, making how one defines his terms very important in the debate. A common way of expressing the compatabilist view is explaining that man is not coerced into following his will; however, what he wills is likely subject to forces outside of his mental life. For instance, many human motivations and drives are unconscious, which points to a role both for determinism and man’s choice of actions in human life.

This implies also that notions of “alternatives” used by metaphysical libertarians are not real. II. A. Do humans have free will? Humans have free will, but it is not a completely free will. Clearly, certain constraints inhibit the complete freedom of a human free will. For instance, a person cannot fly off a roof or breathe under water, even if there is a clear wish to do so. Moving physical and non-physical constraints aside, any person can clearly demonstrate a free will by choosing their actions among many alternatives.

For instance, I can continue typing or get up to get something to drink. But one should notice that both of these actions are at the top of my mind because they are motivated by some process in my physical brain, subject to the causes and effects of electrical and chemical processes. This produces the compatabilist notion of free will: courses of action are suggested by my brain, which my mind eventually chooses from. Are all human actions determined? Not all human action is determined. From psychology, there are numerous examples of how human

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Freedom and Determinism Problem Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
Freedom and Determinism Problem Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1435053-freedom-and-determinism-problem
(Freedom and Determinism Problem Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
Freedom and Determinism Problem Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1435053-freedom-and-determinism-problem.
“Freedom and Determinism Problem Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1435053-freedom-and-determinism-problem.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Freedom and Determinism Problem

The Mind-Body Problem, Freedom and Determinism Problem

Class Title Date Mind-Body Problem and Freedom and Determinism Problem Overview Descartes suggested that consciousness is a part of the mental part of the mind.... There has been a lack of agreement on what really is the relationship between mental and physical phenomena in psychology and this is what is traditionally known as the mind body problem (Cooney 25).... It is a philosophical problem that occurs in the fields of metaphysics and philosophy of mind....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Free Will and Moral Responsibility

This paper ''determinism'' tells that In western philosophy such terms as ddeterminism, free will, and moral responsibility are treated differently by different authors.... There are three main positions on determinism.... nbsp;Those who adhere to hard determinism assert that everything in our world and our actions are predetermined.... hellip; Soft determinism philosophers' view is that free will and moral responsibility can be combined with determinism....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Determinism versus Free Will

As Einstein's position suggested, one might profit from challenging the belief that free will and determinism represent polar opposite extremes of a single dimension.... ight a similar reformulation of the free will-determinism question stimulate new solutions to an antinomy that has perplexed thinkers for more than 25 centuries Before sketching a re-conceptualization of the free will versus determinism issue, this article will offer a working scientist's or a counseling practitioner's specification of the issues--not a philosopher's reformulation of this seemingly everlasting controversy....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Determinism Versus Libertarianism

Free will presents a problem in this case as to whether human beings have freedom over their choices.... The paper "determinism Versus Libertarianism" discusses that libertarianism argues that the decisions of human beings are not caused.... One form of determinism is called casual determinism which advances the theory that free will is based on physical laws and the events of the past and present.... Logical determinism emphasizes that human plans and schemes are either true or false....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework

Exercise assignments

Research any of the following men and their work and explain in full the extent to which you think their theories are valid or invalid where freedom and determinism are concerned: Calvin and predestination; Newton and scientific determinism; Darwin and biological determinism; Hegel and historical determinism; Marx and economic determinism; Freud and psychological determinism; Skinner and behaviorism; William James and indeterminism; and Sartre and freedom.... In other word, determinism implies the same thing as widespread causation; that… There is no such thing as an uncaused occasion. ...
2 Pages (500 words) Coursework

Analyzing the Problem of Freewill

The problem of free will emanate when one tries to merge the component of freedom with the apparent determinism in this world that has causes and effects.... They argued that, a causal chain can be broken by a random event and the end result would be a nullification of determinism and thus pushing further for a greater room for human freedom.... great number of philosophers of all ages, tend to commit themselves to one or a number of dogmas of determinism....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Free Will and Its Critical Concepts in Philosophy

William James displays mixed views about FREE WILL and determinism.... nbsp;Determinism has a variety of meanings with the corresponding different problem of free will.... bull; Under Causal (or nomological) determinism past, present events and laws of nature governing the universe control the future.... bull; Logical determinism complicates the idea of free will.... bull; Theological determinism rejects free will because God is omniscient, predicts and directs the actions of the humans in advance (Shermer, 2004)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

Comparing Technological Determinism Theory to Social Construction of Technology Theory

The author of the "Comparing Technological determinism Theory to Social Construction of Technology Theory" paper compares and contrasts the two theories through the use of technological artifacts that is available in our society that we use on a daily basis.... Technological determinism has, therefore, has been argued to be the driving force of the changes that are taking place in society.... echnological determinism theory has been criticized, especially by contemporary theorists who believe that the theory presents an inaccurate relationship between technology and society....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us