StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Concept of Individuals Responsibility To other Members of Their Community by Peter Singer - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The argument stated by the author of “Family, affluence and morality” Peter Singer can be said to be one that entails two sides and thus from a utilitarian point of view there are those who would agree with his stance as well as those who would not…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.3% of users find it useful
The Concept of Individuals Responsibility To other Members of Their Community by Peter Singer
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Concept of Individuals Responsibility To other Members of Their Community by Peter Singer"

Famine, Affluence and Morality The argument d by the of “Family, affluence and morality” Peter Singer can besaid to be one that entails two sides and thus from a utilitarian point of view there are those who would agree with his stance as well as those who would not. The main foundation of the argument basically states that individuals are able to do more than they are currently doing to help those in need. Countries that can be said to contribute largely to refugee funds such as Britain and Australia also spend more than they donate to these causes on infrastructure such as a new transport system or Opera house (Singer). By taking a look at the donations from such an angle these countries generosity can be said to take a drastic dive when compared to their other expenses. One could say that these governments care more about their transport system for example than they do about the millions of lives that they could affect with such money (Singer). However, in realistic terms especially from an economic point of view, it is necessary that a government invests in projects that will bring back financial returns in a bid to provide a better stable economy from which they can operate from. Without these investments, they would not be able to donate any money to the causes that they provide funding for. Taking a look at the stance brought about by Singer and the economic defense of such actions by the governments it can be said that two clear sides emerge from this argument with each supporting the opposing sides. A good strategy to determine whether Singer was right in his evaluation of an individual’s responsibility to other members of their community as well as a government’s responsibility to society is by studying the underlying factors that would more or less govern the potential results of what certain actions may bring. This can be done by setting a choice of two potential paths that a society can take and the results that these two paths are most likely to yield. By doing this, it can be said that the path that leads to the best results will be the better option. Taking a look at the basis of the argument taken by Singer it can be said that from an overall perspective he has a good point and if his plan was to be placed perfectly into action there could be a high chance of success should everyone play their part. This is to say that the effect should take place from the grassroots and make its way up to the top echelons of government. This would mean that a regular individual would begin to take more interest in the plight of refugees and ensuring that they are doing everything in their power to improve their conditions. This would include donating more money to affiliated organizations, taking a political interest in the policies as well as changing their lifestyle to a more giving and generous one (Singer). The government on the other hand would divert more of their funds towards helping these causes and concentrate more on the wellbeing of these individuals rather than the other projects they have lined up (Singer). The government in this case would take the stance that the improvement of human life is more important than other issues. If this was to happen exactly as stated there could be a chance that causes such as the wellbeing of refugees will get the attention it deserves and as a result their plight may be significantly reduce as more people take action on the matter. However, this would need the support and co operation of all the people and bodies involved which would also include a somewhat drastic in some change in mindset which is something that would not happen overnight. People would need to be willing to change their ways and adopt a giving policy that may have diminished over the years thanks to the promotion of capitalist values. The changes entailed could also bring about negative aspects as well as positive ones, which is something that should be taken into consideration. As much as helping others and ensuring that the needy are well taken care of it is essential to remember that this should not interrupt the normal day to day activities that take place as well as this could lead to a slow down in the regions economic progress and this would in turn affect the financial capabilities of both the government as well as lone individuals to help those they were rooting for. Suggestions have been made such as having individuals picket and hold demonstrations in support of better refugee support (Singer), but such actions also disrupt the work that is going on around the area and may serve as an inconvenience to some. On a personal basis, this may also affect one’s view of the cause that they are fighting for. When dealing with direct government involvement it should be mentioned that there are a number of responsibilities that an elected body has and thus it cannot fully concentrate on one topic while perhaps completely ignoring another as a result. The issue of ensuring that refugees are well taken care of for example cannot overshadow other important matters as well such as the financial stability of the region. The best way to ensure that the government is in a position to help others is to ensure that it is in a stable economic position itself. In conclusion, it can be said that there are a few utilitarian individuals who would disagree with the stance that Peter Singer has taken based on the fact that individuals and other bodies cannot be expected to give more than they able to. Despite comparing their generosity with other investments it should be noted that it is these same investments that are more likely to provide the financial stability for them to continue their generous donations. A change in the individual mindset will also take time to accomplish and thus cannot be expected to take effect overnight. References Singer Peter. “Famine, Affluence, and Morality” Philosophy and Public Affairs, vol. 1, no. 1, pp. 229-243 [revised edition], 1972. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Concept of Individuals Responsibility To other Members of Their Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1492060-the-concept-of-individuals-responsibility-to-other-members-of-their-community-by-peter-singer
(The Concept of Individuals Responsibility To Other Members of Their Essay)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1492060-the-concept-of-individuals-responsibility-to-other-members-of-their-community-by-peter-singer.
“The Concept of Individuals Responsibility To Other Members of Their Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1492060-the-concept-of-individuals-responsibility-to-other-members-of-their-community-by-peter-singer.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Concept of Individuals Responsibility To other Members of Their Community by Peter Singer

Singers Practical Ethics

nbsp;peter singer in his book “Practical Ethics” writes, “The utilitarian will judge bad in some circumstances and good in others, depending on its consequences”.... peter singer's concept of utilitarianism ensures the individual right and freedom to come to own conclusions, and he advises all not to be follow-the-leader type individuals....     peter singer is the strong supporter of animal rights.... peter singer is a compulsive controversy creator....
7 Pages (1750 words) Term Paper

Should Animals Have Their Own Rights

This paper will relate this failure to the historical views over the interrelations between humans, nature and other animals, which is still depicting wide disparities.... This paper will relate this failure to the historical views over the interrelations between humans, nature and other animals, which is still depicting wide disparities.... The report will start by characterizing speciesism, including a claim that many individuals are in support of rejecting it, irrespective of the fact that they never fail to sanction what is apparently the obvious effects of rejecting the issue....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Individual Rights and Common Good: Conflicting or Harmonious Relationship

For instance, some claim that the authority bestowed upon individuals by private property rights is very dangerous to the common good; criminologists claim that protecting the criminals' individual rights is endangering the common good by letting criminals walk; advocates who are focused on the overall moral environment of the society claim that protecting the rights of individuals to take unsafe drugs will certainly challenge public moral standards, whereas others, who are interested in the market's ethical standing, generally conveys displeasure with the right to freedom of trade and commerce, declaring that these sorts of freedom set free the forces of insatiability, greed, and materialism to the detriment of unity, peace, and civility....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Interdependence evaluation

It was also said that the availability of external financing is a crucial determinant of the amount of entrepreneurial activity in a community (Evans and Jovanovic 1989, Evans and Leighton 1989, Kihlstrom and Laffont 1979).... While businesses grew beyond national boundaries and aggressively penetrated into other continents and countries, business houses were compelled to focus on their core competence.... While productive resources are limited but individuals want unlimited goods and services from limited resources....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

An Analysis of the Animal Rights Debate from an Ethics Perspective

Drawing comparisons to the liberations movements of the sixties and the debate around the concept of equality among human beings, Singer emphasizes on the need to take animals too into consideration in such debates.... The equal rights theories also highlight the individual differences among human beings on which the concept of personal rights is based.... peter singer, who played a pioneering role in the founding of Animal Liberation Movement, posits strong argumentative tactics that vindicate his convictions in his… Angus Taylor, a faculty member of the Department of Philosophy in University of Victoria, uses instances from the general life of human beings and animals to theoretically persuade the cause of Animal Rights in the essay “Nasty, Brutish, and Roger Scruton's “The Moral Status of Animals” follows a similar line of argument that defends all life forms on the face of the earth and reveals his intense convictions in ideological and environmental thought....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Peter Singer - Famine Affluence, And Morality

Replies to this by claiming that it does not matter morally to the question, how many people could help out, what matters is the ability of individuals to take up the moral obligation responsibility.... All these arguments put forward by singer were to encourage most of the affluent countries to give more of their resources to the unfortunate that they are doing.... hellip; According to the paper, peter believes that affluent people who reside in the developed world who have at their disposal enormous wealth have a moral obligation to donate some of their enormous wealth and resources to numerous poor people living in the third world countries....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

Early or late industrialization

Such programs include but not limited to provision of free medical services, free education, offer of Capitalism on the other hand is the belief that the government does not utilize economic resources efficiently as private entities.... The basic argument in the debate concerning communism, and socialism is chiefly concerned on economic equality, and responsibility of the government.... Further, an economic system that does not motivate individuals and is inefficient cannot be said to be just or capable of producing much wealth....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Ethics Is Used to Define the Diverse Regulations and Conducts

The paper "Ethics Is Used to Define the Diverse Regulations and Conducts" states that the market shapes the private vices in the society into public virtues as it places society members into circumstances where they have to consistently concern themselves with the wellbeing and desires of others.... Individuals whose goal is to improve and attract more customers to their businesses act with concern for their customers, employees, and other society members knowing that their act of kindness would bring them more profits....
26 Pages (6500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us