StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Utilitarianism and biomedical ethics - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
This patient is 71 years old and has metastatic lung cancer. She has been very happy, lives by herself and volunteers at a senior center. She has had three years in which she treated her cancer and allowed chemotherapy, radiation, and surgery, after which she became dependent on night time oxygen…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.4% of users find it useful
Utilitarianism and biomedical ethics
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Utilitarianism and biomedical ethics"

Ethical Dilemma Utilitarianism and a Decision Ethical Decision This patient is 71 years old and has metastatic lung cancer. She has been very happy, lives by herself and volunteers at a senior center. She has had three years in which she treated her cancer and allowed chemotherapy, radiation, and surgery, after which she became dependent on night time oxygen. Her cancer continues to progress. Her physician wants her to try an experimental chemotherapy that has a 15% chance of putting this cancer in remission.

She decides not to do this. She feels she would rather die than go through another treatment, one that will remove her from her home and put her in the hospital for treatment. This paper will discuss this patients decision in light of the utilitarian theory of biomedical ethics. "Utilitarianism holds that the best option is the one that does the most expected good (Beauchamp &Childress, 2005). Stuart Mill defines utilitarian ethical philosophy as that which defines a good action as the one that maximizes pleasure and minimizes pain to as many people as possible (Feldman, 2006).

In other words, the consequences of the decision should be better than any of the other possible decisions. In this case, by utilitarian rules, there are other people to consider such as children and grandchildren. The need to prolong life to its maximum accompanies our success with medicine and society's need for a long and healthy life. It used to be that people watched while loved ones suffered toward their deaths with a critical illness. This has been replaced with the philosophy that death should be stalled by using every advanced technology available (Trnobranski, 1996).

This then creates a moral issue for many kinds including the understanding of what prolonging life means and what terminal illness means. The need for healthcare professionals to feel they have intervened in the life of a case has promoted the need to have an ethical professional code. The primary duty of all healthcare professionals is "not to inflict harm." There too, of course is the argument of omission versus actually giving a lethal injection. The view that does seem to be supported by all of the resources review is this.

Quality of life determines whether a treatment is ordinary or extraordinary is unimportant. What is important is whether the effectiveness of the treatment in questions will provide or destroy the quality of life (Trnobranski, 1996). This patient has done, already everything that her healthcare team thought would work. She has had extra time with her family and has led a happy life. In the utilitarian point of view, the best thing for the most people is to let her make the decision not to be admitted to the hospital and have the new chemotherapy regime.

The reasons are that her family would be better off to have her a short time in reasonable condition to spend time with them and certainly it is her point of view that her quality of life would be better. Quality does not mean length but what is best for everyone. The new chemo only gives a possible 15% chance of remission which is poor at best and that alone provides her with incentive to enjoy what time she can. Healthcare believes that suicide is bad, so does religion. Remember that Stuart Mills tells us that when there is little space between bad and good, it has to be determined that there is no moral dilemma.

The goal then is to expand the place between bad and good allowing for understanding of the moral part of the dilemma to become apparent. In the case of this patient, the place between bad and good is expanded when we allow the patient to make her own choice and the moral dilemma is then solved. . In conclusion, the utilitarian point of view is controversial. Some say it could be used to limit healthcare based on the need to curtail costs and use limited resources. However, in this case, it makes the decision much easier than had any other approach been used.

Best is defined by all of us differently and only this patient can determine best for her but certainly best for all is not to damage the quality of the life she has left. References Almagor, R. (2002). A critique of Callahan's utilitarian approach to resource allocation in health care. Issues in Law & Medicine 17(3). Beauchamp, T. & Childress, J. (2005). Principles of Biomedical Ethics. 6th ed. Cragger, N. (1993). Universal prescriptivism: traditional moral decision-making theory revisited.

Journal of Advanced Nursing 20(3). 538-543. Feldman, D. (2005). Can suicide be ethical A utilitarian perspective on the appropriateness of choosing to die. Death Studies. 30. 529-538. Nord, E. (2006). Utilitarian decision analysis of informed consent. Norwegian Institute of Public Health. 6(3). Strong, C. (2006). The limited utility of utilitarian analysis. University of Tennessee College of Medicine. 6 (3). Trnobranski, P. (1995). The decision to prolong life: ethical perspectives of a clinical dilemma.

Journal of Clinical Nursing 5 233-240.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Utilitarianism and biomedical ethics Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1520657-utilitarianism-and-biomedical-ethics
(Utilitarianism and Biomedical Ethics Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1520657-utilitarianism-and-biomedical-ethics.
“Utilitarianism and Biomedical Ethics Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1520657-utilitarianism-and-biomedical-ethics.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Utilitarianism and biomedical ethics

Ethics of the Sale of Body Parts

The Position of a Biomedical Products Engineer on the Sale of Body Parts, Using Two Ethical Theories (utilitarianism and the Golden Rule) The two ethical theories that were selected were utilitarianism and the Golden Rule.... ethics ethics of the Sale of Body Parts ?... Five Ethical Issues Associated With the Sale of Body Parts Five ethical issues with regard to the sale of body parts—outside of the biomedical ethical standpoint—is that such a practice would be morally wrong, it would take away the human dignity of the sellers, it would take away the human dignity of the person whose body part would be taken, it would take away from the dignity of the doctors, and also create greed within the buyers....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Professional Values, Ethics and Law

The two pioneer ethical theories include Teleologic theory or Consequentialism/utilitarianism and Deontologic or formalist theory.... PROFESSIONAL VALUES, ethics AND LAW Introduction The aim of this essay is to explore the ethical, legal and professional issues pertaining to case study 2.... hellip; ethics is defined by most dictionaries as “dealing with what is good or bad, right or wrong” (Barker, 2011).... In context to the health care profession, ethics refers to the principles that must guide the behaviour of a professional in a particular situation (Barker, 2011)....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Variety of Legal Perspectives on Euthanasia

In the realm of medical ethics one of the prominent ethical approaches is that of natural law.... Euthanasia is recognized as the act of voluntarily taking one's life.... While in pure technical terms the act of euthanasia is a form of suicide, in practice it is generally associated with individuals facing end of life issues that choose euthanasia as a means of escaping pain and suffering associated with their condition....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Summary response paper

Student's Full Name: Professor's Name: PHIL 130 (A response paper to a biomedical ethics issue) 24 October 2012 (estimated word count = 1,009) Introduction The scientific studies conducted on animals to obtain crucial data has always raised important and critical moral issues.... Moral ethics has been around for quite some time; the issues related to it had been discussed in great detail by the ancient Greek philosophers.... ethics today has entered into many areas of human endeavors, such as its increasing adoption by global businesses in the form of corporate social responsibility that has tempered the search for profits under capitalist free markets....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Singers Practical Ethics

The paper "Singer's Practical ethics" tells us about utilitarianism principles.... nbsp;Peter Singer in his book “Practical ethics” writes, “The utilitarian will judge bad in some circumstances and good in others, depending on its consequences”.... Ethical considerations demand that such animals need to be excluded from biomedical research.... Peter Singer's concept of utilitarianism ensures the individual right and freedom to come to own conclusions, and he advises all not to be follow-the-leader type individuals....
7 Pages (1750 words) Term Paper

The Society of Homeopaths Code of Ethics and Practice

These are the Society of Homeopaths Code of ethics and Practice and this paper will provide an assessment of its value within the profession (Owen 2007 p.... Two of the parameters which have been used to decide whether or not the guidelines are ethical or unethical are the principles of moral relativism and utilitarianism.... This brings us to the second philosophical tenant known as utilitarianism....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Health, its Determinants and Ethics

This assignment "Health, its Determinants, and ethics" discusses determinants of health include social, physical, and individual factors.... The World Health Organization (WHO) came up with their definition to cover the gap that exists in the biomedical definition.... Researchers argue that this definition is superior to the biomedical meaning because it considers the physical, social, and mental conditions of human beings (Gedge, & Waluchow, 2012)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Theory of Justice

The paper "Theory of Justice" supposes philosophers come up with different principles to define justices.... They all agree on the need to have justice in society.... With justice, there would be cohesion in society.... Society would thrive under just systems and individuals would achieve their well-being....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us