StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Transmission of AIDS from Mother to Child - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Transmission of AIDS from Mother to Child" discusses that generally, the critics of Dr. Angell stress the fact that they had informed the subjects of the truth and obtained their consent, therefore they defend themselves on Kantian grounds. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92% of users find it useful
Transmission of AIDS from Mother to Child
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Transmission of AIDS from Mother to Child"

Dr. Marcia Angell’s views regarding medical research are very straight forwards and she speaks for millions of people who also believe that even though medical research is extremely important for the betterment of human beings and in making progress against the various forms of diseases, yet Dr. Angell holds that the objectives of the research cannot supersede the well being of the subjects of the research. No matter how important research might be, the lives of the participants must not be put at risk under any circumstances, whether they belong to the control group or vice versa. Dr, Angell supports her point of view by quoting the Declaration of the Helsinki of the World Health Organization which clearly states that methods used to treat the research subjects must be medically and therapeutically the best (Angell, 847).

Dr. Angell’s concerns regarding the ethical legitimacy of the research conducted on third world subjects to get a clearer picture regarding the vertical transmission of the Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) from a pregnant mother to her unborn child. Dr. Angell characterizes this research as unethical due to the presence of placebo-treated control groups. Dr. Angell validates her argument by pointing out that it was not like the researchers were clueless about any sort of preventative treatment for the disease. Zidovudine has been recommended by doctors in the USA to all pregnant women infected with HIV so as to reduce/ eliminate the rate of vertical transmission of the virus to the unborn child. Consequently, Dr. Angell believes that merely getting the informed consent forms signed is not enough to term research as ethical, rather it is criminal to deny a group of patients the proper treatment just so that the objectives of the research are met.

As a justification, the researchers stated that the subjects of the research belonged to poor third world families and in any case would not have had access to the specified treatment, therefore they (the researchers) were only observing what would naturally have happened to these patients. In another research that tested the effectiveness of prophylaxis against tuberculosis in HIV-infected patients, placebo-treated control groups existed. However, that research could have been justified on the basis that the medical effectiveness of prophylaxis was yet unknown, but this was not the case with Zidovudine (Angell 847-848).
The critics of Dr. Angell’s approach stated that the cost of administering Zidovudine to the subjects of the study in Africa was too high and that a lot of expertise is required to administer Zidovudine to patients which are just not available in a third world country like Africa.

Moreover, the critics state that the researches are just an effort to be able to develop cheap, effective and more affordable medicines available to people of third-world countries. Critics argue that the purpose of this research was not to come up with a medicine for the first world countries rather the purpose was to come up with a solution to the problem of HIV AIDS prevalent in Africa, therefore the motives of the researchers were not selfish. Moreover, the critics argue that the subjects who were given the placebo would normally not have undergone any treatment simply because they would not have been able to afford it. Therefore, the researchers only tried to work in the best interest of the Africans so that in the future their generations were able to have access to a cure for the vertical transmission of HIV AIDS (Niekerk 156 - 160).

Immanuel Kant believed that human beings must not be used as a rather they must be used as a means to an end. In conducting this research, the purpose of the researchers was not to treat the subjects as ends rather with the informed consent of the participants, the researchers wanted to use them as a means to an end by developing an affordable solution to a disease so common in Africa. Adding to this is the fact that Kant emphasized the fact that anything done with deception as its foundation is wrong, which was not the case over here. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Examine the debate between Dr. Marcia Angells (and others) criticism Essay”, n.d.)
Examine the debate between Dr. Marcia Angells (and others) criticism Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1579987-examine-the-debate-between-dr-marcia-angells-and-others-criticism-of-the-american-research-study-concerning-of-the-transmission-of-the-aids-from-mother-to-child-in-africa-and-those-defending-the-study-explain-how-critics-are-using-a-kantian-viewpoi
(Examine the Debate Between Dr. Marcia Angells (and Others) Criticism Essay)
Examine the Debate Between Dr. Marcia Angells (and Others) Criticism Essay. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1579987-examine-the-debate-between-dr-marcia-angells-and-others-criticism-of-the-american-research-study-concerning-of-the-transmission-of-the-aids-from-mother-to-child-in-africa-and-those-defending-the-study-explain-how-critics-are-using-a-kantian-viewpoi.
“Examine the Debate Between Dr. Marcia Angells (and Others) Criticism Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1579987-examine-the-debate-between-dr-marcia-angells-and-others-criticism-of-the-american-research-study-concerning-of-the-transmission-of-the-aids-from-mother-to-child-in-africa-and-those-defending-the-study-explain-how-critics-are-using-a-kantian-viewpoi.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Transmission of AIDS from Mother to Child

Fighting HIV and AIDS

The campaigns seek to educate each individual on the modes of transmission of HIV, and possible prevention methods, and people from all lifestyles are encouraged to know their status through voluntary testing.... Even after the spread of HIV to heterosexuals, there was stigmatization against anyone suffering from the disease (Parker and Ellison, 2003).... The paper "Fighting HIV and aids" tells that aids has caused devastating effects in society....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

HIV/AIDS in South Africa and China

The essay "HIV/AIDS in South Africa and China" demonstrates the situation in South Africa and China that are seriously struggled from HIV/AIDS.... China falls under this region and is recording increased rates of infection from heterosexual ways (Joseph et.... The focus is on the soaring cases of new infections, which are resulting from the generically unpopular sources of new transmissions.... It is stated that the HIV/aids epidemic first came to the lime light in the early 1980s and has ever since puzzled scientists and researchers around the world....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

A Comparison of HIV in the USA and Africa

HIV transmission is possible in three ways, mother to child transmission, which takes place during labor, during birth and by breastfeeding.... If a pregnant mother is positive, then the unborn child is prone to have the... HIV and aids is categorized or listed among many perilous diseases globally thus responsible for many deaths.... In the US, for instance, over a million individuals have HIV and half of that number die when the disease develops to aids....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

HIV Transmission Risks Between Mothers and Children

This paper critically analyzes two articles that were published on mother to child HIV transmission and the potential risks that may increase the likelihood of such transmissions.... Consequently, many types of research have over the past few years, increasingly sought to propose and discuss various ways of minimizing and preventing the risks of mother to child transmission of HIV, particularly during the delivery.... The three authors carried out fairly descriptive research in a rural district in Malawi in their attempt to explore the various views regarding the prevention of mother to child HIV transmission....
7 Pages (1750 words) Literature review

Impact of Poverty on Mother-Child HIV Transmission

For a pregnant mother to be able to use ARVs, the person goes through several phases with screening for pregnancy is the first stage.... The paper "Impact of Poverty on Mother-child HIV Transmission" supposes that the raise in poverty level has been increasing mother-to-child HIV transmission in South Africa, poverty levels in South Africa have made the intervention program for mother-child HIV transmission to be ineffective, etc....
12 Pages (3000 words) Thesis

Efficacy of Antiretroviral Drugs in Reducing Mother-to-Child Transmission of HIV-AID

This essay "Efficacy of Antiretroviral Drugs in Reducing Mother-to-Child Transmission of HIV-AID" presents Antiretroviral drugs (ARVs) that have been regarded as efficacious in the promotion of Prevention of mother to child Transmission (PMTCT) of HIV.... The proposed review will be used in estimating the effectiveness of ARVs in reducing the prevalence of Mother-Child transmission of HIV in Zambia.... transmission of 4-6 weeks postpartum will be chosen to reflect the combined antepartum and intrapartum transmission....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

HIV Positive Women Should Not Become Pregnant

According to Centre for Disease Control and Prevention (2014), perinatal transmission is HIV transmission from mother to child during pregnancy, labor and delivery.... n developed countries, the mother to child transmission (MTCT) of HIV has been almost eliminated due to effective prevention programs.... There are significant challenges facing prevention mother to child transmission (PMTCT) programs in developing countries therefore causing significant gaps in reducing the rates of MTCT....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Biology of Aids and Stds

According to the Review article by Kourtis, et al, pediatric HIV-1 is still a major pandemic, despite the reductions in transmission from mother to child that have been achieved.... mother to child transmission can take place during pregnancy, labor, delivery and postpartum through breastfeeding.... The estimated transmission rates during the different stages of pre-, during, and post-delivery: The results of several studies taken together support the notion that the risk for mother to child HIV-1 transmission increases rapidly as the pregnancy reaches its later stages....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us