StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Shia Political Islam and Its Sunni Counterpart - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
In the given circumstances, the current paper "Shia Political Islam and Its Sunni counterpart" is primarily purposed to provide both similarities and differences between Shia and Sunni and their attitude to foreign aid are the criteria for comparison. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97% of users find it useful
Shia Political Islam and Its Sunni Counterpart
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Shia Political Islam and Its Sunni Counterpart"

and Sur and Sur Number the paper Differences between Shia political Islam and its Sunni counterpart intheoretical and practical dimensions Traditionally, Muslim communities are divided on several groups, with Sunni and Shia as the prominent minorities among them. Even though it is a religious difference, it also has a key role for social relations. By being different branches within theoretic Islam, political features of Shia and Sunni turn to be practically important for the existence of Islamic states. In fact, different rulers of Muslim countries clearly articulate their religious views and use certain kind of understanding the Quran while governing the country. In other words, each new leader is clearly sympathetic to either Shia or Sunni, which results in predictability of conflicts in certain public spheres. In addition, Muslim countries (like Pakistan and Iran) have a striking majority of one religious branch supporters among their populations. In the given circumstances, this paper provides both similarities and differences in the pair of two above-mentioned political Islam branches. In particular, both internal differences between Shia and Sunni and their attitude to foreign aid are the criteria for comparison. On the one hand, throughout the history writers of Shia and Sunni revealed different approaches to reading Quran and understanding what exactly a good society is. Even though both sects agree on three fundamental Islamic principles (monotheism, Day of Judgement, and parenthood), they use these prerequisites differently in explaining ordinary events that appeared after Mohammed’s life (Ameli and Malaei 32). As Ja’fari explains the term ‘Shi’a’, the essence of it refers to “followers, party, group, associates, partisans, or in rather looser sense, ‘supporters’” (6). In this situation, the word ‘mawla’ the Shia understand as leader and patron (Ja’fari 23). Hence, the Shia believe that Imam Ali is a successor of Muhammed they should worship as an authority (Ameli and Malaei 23). On the contrary, the definition of ‘Sunna’ refers to nobility and high moral qualities (Ja’fari 9). For them, ‘mawla’ is a friend, or the nearest kin (Ja’fari 23). Thus, they think Muslims had selected the leader after Muhammed, Abu-Bakr, among themselves, which underlines his equal status with other Muslims (Ameli and Malaei 23). This preposition leads to higher level of tolerance and acknowledgement. For example, Sunni commentators of religious texts tend to include the wives of Prophet while referring to his relatives (Ja’fari 18). In fact, this different attention to the details signalizes of different degree of patriarchy within families. In this situation, such generally unequal understanding of the balance of power should lead to contradiction between two branches not only in religious but also in social terms. In this context, Ja’fari highlights the preliminary role of “Spirit” in comparing Shia and Sunni that refers to fundamentally different approaches of Quran reading and is “working behind these rather minor differences” (268). At the same time, contemporary circumstances of religious states reveal differences in the level of radicalization rather between several schools within both Shia and Sunni than between these two sects. In fact, it means that implementation of both teachings is not clear even for their supporters. Moreover, the fact that Shia and hardline Sunni have an image of “dangerous and insidious temptations” (The Economist) represents the blurring differences between these two branches in the eyes of observers as well. Thus, the clear division between two schools of Islam is evident in considering the role of Mohammed’s successor and the unequal attention to the details of past events. Concerning modern reality, the differences between Shia and Sunni are not that clear. On another hand, conflict between fundamentalist and democratic forces in global context strengthened the above-mentioned internal differences between Shia and Sunni. As the international context shows, most of Muslims worldwide are Sunnis (roundly 80%) and most of the rest are Shia. In this proportion, most Muslim states are Sunni and Iran turns into “Shia bastion” (The Economist). Because of this national clarity, the opposition between two sects goes beyond separate societies and enters both regional and international arenas. In this context, the issues of foreign sponsorship and enlarged area of open conflicts between these sects make difference (Shah 452). In other words, division between Shia and Sunni is mostly a political conflict between the government and opposition, which they support by religious differences. In this perspective, Shi-Sunni conflicts result in tremendous amount of murders of intellectuals and politicians (Shah 446). At the same time, Western leaders tend to support rather Sunni leaders (The Economist), which sharpens the conflict between branches with either support or rejection of foreign democratic involvement. For example, cases like firebombing of Belgium’s biggest Shia mosque (The Economist) harms Western image in Muslim countries, especially among Shia religious group. In addition, the facts of Muslims’ discrimination supplements their radicalization and non-acceptance of Western involvement in Arabic countries (Ameli and Malaei 32). Even though religious Islam grounds on peace and non-violence, political appearance of Muslim countries via Western media have gained an international image of cruelty and non-tolerance (Shah 456). In the given circumstances, religious interpretations harmed political reality, especially in the states established “in the name of religious ideology” (Shah 445). Thus, it is relevant to state that political reality and international tension is the real driver of difference between Sunni and Shia. In sum, the analysis showed that the key differences between Shia and Sunni groups hide in considering the role of Mohammed’s successor, assessing the past events in Muslim history, and revealing the attitude towards international support for Islam countries. In the given circumstances, the common prerequisites of Islam appears to be a more sustainable similarity than numerous above-mentioned differences. In support of this preposition, currently Shia and Sunni ordinary people search for their similarities to create effective intercultural communication (Ameli and Malaei 38). Therefore, differences between Shia and Sunni are rather exaggerated by politicians and foreign observers than being conflicting overviews on social reality. Works Cited Ameli, S. and H. Molaei. “Religious Affiliation and Intercultural Sensitivity: Interculturality between Shia and Sunni Muslims in Iran.” International Journal of Intercultural Relations, 36 (2012): 31-40. Print. Ja’fari, S. The Origins and Early Development of Shia Islam. Qum: Ansariyan Publications, 2014. Print. Shah, M. “Evolution of Sectarianism in Pakistan: A Threat to the State and Society.” A Research Journal of South Asian Studies, 29.2 (2014): 441-459. Print. The Economist. “The Sword and the Word.” The Economist. 12 May 2012. Web. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Shia Political Islam and Its Sunni Counterpart Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1700899-shia-political-islam-and-its-sunni-counterpart
(Shia Political Islam and Its Sunni Counterpart Essay)
https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1700899-shia-political-islam-and-its-sunni-counterpart.
“Shia Political Islam and Its Sunni Counterpart Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1700899-shia-political-islam-and-its-sunni-counterpart.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Shia Political Islam and Its Sunni Counterpart

Harmful Effects of Anti-Shia Discrimination

Discrimination against the Shi'a has led to their inability to practice their religion, which has caused resentment towards their sunni counterparts, as they are denied their right to worship.... For example, Chehab in sunni vs.... This was part of sunni Muslims,' particularly the Wahhabi sect's, aim to “purify Islam of any innovations or practices that deviate from the seventh-century teachings of the Prophet Muhammad and his companions” (Giritlioglu 1)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Sunni Islam and Shia Islam

Over the past two years, both the media and politicians have highlighted the differences between Sunni islam and Shia islam and conflicts between Shia and Sunni Muslims.... Over the past two years, both the media and politicians have highlighted the differences between Sunni islam and Shia islam and conflicts between Shia and Sunni Muslims.... As a Shi'ite Muslim, I had never given the question much thought and, indeed, in my gatherings with other Muslims, some of whom are sunni, never really noticed a difference....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Political Islam, World Politics and Europe by Bassam Tibi

The role of Iran has been specifically discussed with reference to the attempt to export the Iranian revolutionary ideas about the Global islam and its position in the world.... Writtenfrom a larger perspective of viewing islam and it is roots into Europe, author begins with an assessment of the overall politicization of Islam on global politics generally and with specific reference to Europe.... The author analyzes "political islam, World Politics and Europe" book which is a very vivid introduction of the impact of political islam on Europe....
2 Pages (500 words) Term Paper

Muslims in America

The sunni Muslims in the USA are in the majority, while the Shia Community is in the minority.... The Wall Street Journal in its report had claimed that the American Muslims had been projected as role models for the Muslims.... Although there were some doubts in the early part of the 20th century, all these doubts were erased when the Blacks living in the USA started converting to islam, as the religion provided the best possible means to live a life which was devoid of any discrimination as opposed to Christianity....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

ISLAM. Shi'i and Sunni Muslims

Majority of the Muslims in Islam are the sunni followers these days.... According to the etymology of the word sunni, it is a very broad terms which has been derived from the word Sunnah, which means a ‘normal practice' or ‘habit'.... The formation of sunni sect was the outcome of the election of Abu Bakar as the first successor of the Holy Prophet (PBUH).... Those, who accepted and respected the legality and authority of Abu Bakar's caliphate composed the majority of Muslims, were later called as “sunni,” which means the “followers of [the Prophet's] customs [sunna]....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Shiism and Sunnism Comparative Analysis

The sunni caliphs, according to the sunni doctrine, are elected by consensus of community called ijma, in the light of which the first caliph Abu Bakr was elected; whereas the Shiite claim that the imams are appointed from Almighty Lord and explicit designation made by his predecessor through the statutes of holy sayings or statements called nass from the House of the Prophet; it is therefore Hazrat Ummey Salma was not included under the mantle, and only the progeny of Ali and Fatima was entitled to be the members of the House of the Holy Prophet (AP/HUMA 297)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Sunni-Shia Split

AQI viewed Shia as individuals who have rejected islam and declared war on them7.... The sunni Arabs were considered to reap better benefits during the Sadam regime as… This changed after Hussein's fall and the Shia Arabs dominating the government3.... It is a civil war due to the tension and killings existing due to the theological and political differences with each group calling for The sunni-Shia Split The sunni-Shia Split The sunni-Shia split should be considered a civil war in Iraq....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Islam and Jihad: Prejudice Versus Reality

As one can easily see, Shia islam and Sunni Islam feature two completely different positions with regard to structuring the social environment: the former is more authoritative while the latter is far more flexible.... Nevertheless, the part of the Muslim world that is currently known as sunni suggests that in spite of the fact that there are may be some explicit statements made by the Prophet, the actual succession was in favour of Abu Bakr, the person who was one of the most active companions of Muhammad....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us