StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

The spectacle of detention centres is the same as the spectacle of torture - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The spectacle of detention centres is the same as the spectacle of torture Although torture constitutes a barbaric act it remains prevalent in the modern world. As society has gained greater understanding in terms of psychology, methods of oppression, violence, and detention, it should be no surprise that the nature of torture has expanded…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96% of users find it useful
The spectacle of detention centres is the same as the spectacle of torture
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The spectacle of detention centres is the same as the spectacle of torture"

Download file to see previous pages

One of the major concerns when considering the relation between the spectacle of detention centres and the spectacle of torture is the relative nature of the detention situation. In the case of asylum seekers it’s understood that the question of human rights becomes a question of the state. As rights constitute individuals as human subjects rather than as simply humans the question of detention as cruelty or torture becomes readily apparent. While such torture within the detention complex is complex, Zizek and Foucault consider how such an environment actually constitutes violence for the subject.

For Zizek the detention center constitutes systematic, invisible, and indirect patterns of violence. Ultimately, the pervading notion is that torture is not simply a single dehumanizing act, but constitutes a wide range of violence towards the human subject. Another prominent concern is the nature of the spectacle torture as linked to the spectacle of detention in the modern world. For Foucault the nature of detention as torture, through his notion of panopticism, can be argued to be an essential aspect of social organization.

One also considers Foucault’s notion of torture as spectacle in this context of understanding. In these regards, state actions against the human subject are not simply punitive or reform motivated, but structured in such a way as demonstrate the state’s power through a spectacle; in the modern state this spectacle show of power finds incarnation in detention centres. Lenta extends this discussion noting, “The possibility I want to consider is that something analogous might oc- cur nowadays if the power of a sovereign state is challenged, perhaps through attack, such that the state is rendered vulnerable or fragile” (Lenta 2006, pg. 54). This understanding sharpens and direct Foucault’s notion of the spectacle of torture.

One considers the act of terrorism as a major act against the state through which the spectacle of detention is the response. Perhaps the most pronounced understanding of detention as torture emerges in a consideration of the architecture of the detention centre. In these regards, it’s been understood that the very nature of the detention centre is designed in a way as to exemplify a sinister darkness. One of the prominent concerns in these regards is the nature of the barbed wire surrounding modern detention centres.

While the wire ostensibly constitutes the functional purpose of limiting prison escapes, it more accurately is implemented for the symbolic separating of the prisoner from the citizen. In these regards, the architecture of the detention center is constructed in such a way that dehumanizes the human subject. This is a form of violence that is comparable to an act of torture. A number of counter-objections have been raised against the notion that detention is unethical. In this context of understanding, one considers the ASIO act passed recently by the Australian parliament that allows governmental agencies to detain suspects for interrogation up to seven days.

The argument that while the government may be violating human rights, these actions are ethically necessary as a means of preserving human lives. Although such an argument is sound, one still notes that even if the act of torture is undertaken for ethical reasons it remains a torturous act. In these

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The spectacle of detention centres is the same as the spectacle of Essay”, n.d.)
The spectacle of detention centres is the same as the spectacle of Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1436434-the-spectacle-of-detention-centres-is-the-same-as
(The Spectacle of Detention Centres Is the Same As the Spectacle of Essay)
The Spectacle of Detention Centres Is the Same As the Spectacle of Essay. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1436434-the-spectacle-of-detention-centres-is-the-same-as.
“The Spectacle of Detention Centres Is the Same As the Spectacle of Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1436434-the-spectacle-of-detention-centres-is-the-same-as.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The spectacle of detention centres is the same as the spectacle of torture

Evaluation of the Proposal for an Original TV Drama

At the same time, they want that experience to be far placed in time and space, so as to facilitate the required intellectual distance to reflect on the... Thus the viewers will conclusively respond in an embracing manner to the exceptionally assuring aspirations, nature and temperament of Darlene revealed in an environment marred by a more then bearable physical and mental torture and abuse....
4 Pages (1000 words) Movie Review

Applying Foucaults Panopticism

One of the well-known principles that are laid out in his works is the panoptic principle, the idea that constant surveillance, or more appropriately the constant… Foucault takes Jeremy Bentham's model prison that uses the Panopticon, and extends it to the idea that modern society operates in pretty much the same way.... factories, schools, barracks, and hospitals, all function in essentially the same way as the modern prison....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Discipline and Punish: a History of the Emergence of Generalised Regime of Disciplinary Regulation

Foucault claims that progress from a humanist perspective in relation to Modern discipline and punishment would not be accurate but, progress in being able to perform punishment with the same intensity of the Classical Age and not get the negative reaction that people had… These ‘general politics' and ‘regimes of truth' are the result of scientific discourse and institutions, and are reinforced (and redefined) constantly through the education system, the media, and the flux of political 5....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

An Uncertain Relationship to the Instant of their Cultural Production

In today's films, it is almost impossible to view the whole film without witnessing violence at least as a side spectacle.... Violence in cinema is one of the most popular themes that make films more interesting and captivating to the audience or the viewer.... They have special effects and with… It does not seem to be enough that people are often exposed to war, accidents and disasters in the daily news that they watch, furthermore, they have made it their immediate The essay will be about Michael Haneke's Representation of Violence in his films, who is a former literary and film critic....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Visual analysis of Mahatma Gandhis portrait

The chosen object is a portrait which shows the image of Mahatma Gandhi.... Mahatma Gandhi was an Indian leader who inspired generations from across the world.... He was instrumental during the independence of India when he led movements for Civil rights and freedoms.... His approach of activisms was non-violent and this trait has attracted admiration from across the globe....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

How Far Does the Description of Totalitarianism in Nineteen Eighty-Four Fit Reality

The "How Far Does the Description of Totalitarianism in Nineteen Eighty-Four Fit Reality " paper describes what is “disciplinary” society, M.... Foucault's “panopticism” principle and its application to G.... Orwell's “1984” and modern society, and examines the political system of the modern societies....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

The Body of the Condemned by Michael Foucault

Foucault remarks that these two examples “do not punish the same crimes or the same type of delinquent.... rdquo; Foucault points out that modern forms of punishment are, thankfully, not carried out in the same spirit or with the same purpose.... This work "The Body of the Condemned by Michael Foucault" describes the atmosphere of the mid-eighteenth century public torture and execution of a convicted criminal in France....
6 Pages (1500 words) Book Report/Review

Exodus - Gods and Kings - Parts Contributing to Composition Unity

Light draws attention to principle areas within the frame of the film while the creative control of the same light has been used to produce shadows that conceal details and enforce moods while suggesting realism and guiding the viewer's eye to points of emphasis.... Numerous color sequences have been used creatively, to give a distinctive dramatic emphasis to the film, which enhances the “larger-than-life” atmosphere of the film's spectacle (Lemire)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Movie Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us