Comparing oedipus and antigone as tragic heroes - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Comparing oedipus and antigone as tragic heroes

It wasn't until Shakespeare's day, in fact, a tragic hero was expected to die at the end. Today, the character's death is almost the only aspect that makes him tragic. An example of how completely the idea of a tragic hero has devolved can be made by pointing to the example of the character Jack in the movie Titanic, who has been unofficially declared a tragic hero by the millions of fans of that particular film. A comparison of the qualities of that character with any of the classic definitions of a tragic hero clearly shows the divide that has been wrought over the years. That divide had, of course, been widening since long before the film was made, but nonetheless the question raised is whether a true classic tragic hero could be realized in drama in the 20th century and into the new millennium. Aristotle lists Sophocles' Oedipus Rex as an example of perfection in creating a tragedy, and indeed the character of Oedipus himself is almost synonymous with tragedy. Oedipus lives in a cosmological universe governed by a force that knows the route of his fate but has no control over it; Antigone lives in a universe governed by a force that controls her fate but doesn't know the route it will take. ...
Download paper


The conception of tragic heroes has changed significantly since Aristotle first laid down the rules for defining tragedy in his Poetics. In its origins in ancient Greek drama, a tragic hero could only be a member of royalty and almost always male. By Shakespeare's day the gender mattered slightly less, though bloodlines still retained a high level of import…
Author : jschulist

Related Essays

Compare and Contrast Essay based on Frank O'connor's "My Oedipus Complex", and Graham Greene's "A Shocking Accident"
The boy (and young man later) was afraid of people's laugh because of it. He became very happy when a girl he married did not laugh when she has heard the story about his father's death....
2 pages (502 words) Essay
How much responsibility for the tragic results in Romeo and Juliet should be attributed to the friar and the nurse and fate
She agreed to carry Juliet's message to Romeo when he was in Mantua. So, she was the directing hand of fate - her actions were partially resulted in the tragic outcome. She even persuaded Juliet to choose Paris saying that "I think you are as happy in this second match,/ For it excels your first: or if it did not,/ Your first is dead; or 'twere as good he were" (III. 5.). The Nurse loved Juliet like her real daughter and wished her to be happy, but her attitude to love was different from that of Juliet. From the very moment of Romeo and Juliet acquaintance the tragic outcome was predetermined....
2 pages (502 words) Essay
Oedipus and the Tragedy of a Common Man
Well before the play begins, a shepherd takes pity on a baby and instead of letting him die delivers him to safety in another kingdom. Rather than any tragic flaw that can be attributed to Oedipus, the tragic consequences that take place within the play—including Oedipus’ killing of his father, marrying his mother and bringing a plague upon Thebes—are directly attributable to the decision made by the shepherd to not allow Oedipus to die as a baby. ...
3 pages (753 words) Essay
(Kirkwood, 1967)...
8 pages (2008 words) Book Report/Review
King Oedipus
Father, who inflicted ever-lasting injury on the infant and sent him to his death, strangely did not murder him. "He (Laius) chose exposure rather than outright murder for the same reason the Creon has Antigone entombed alive: so that he would avoid the pollution" (Gould, 1970, p.93)....
6 pages (1506 words) Book Report/Review
Oedipus the King
The simple geography of the land is the most obvious part of any setting and in this play that common element contributes to the tragic consequences that befall Oedipus. Oedipus meets Laius at a crossroads that is not only metaphorical, but geographical as well. Had Oedipus not been traveling upon that particular path at the particular moment, he could perhaps have physically avoided the confrontation that leads to murder. Indeed, even had this not been avoided, had Oedipus lived in a geographical area that was different, perhaps he could have jumped aboard a ship and traveled farther away...
2 pages (502 words) Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!