StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

How to Criticize Up and Down Your Organization and Make It Pay Off - Essay Example

Nobody downloaded yet

Extract of sample
How to Criticize Up and Down Your Organization and Make It Pay Off

That said, Weisinger points out that criticism is necessary for growth. For instance, Weisinger (1989) states that the Romantic period in philosophy, politics and the arts came about because the individuals involved with the Romantic period criticized the neoclassical period, and because criticism of the neoclassical followers had their criticism suppressed. Weisinger (1989) further point out that Louis the XIV suppressed criticism, and the response to this was the American and French revolutions. In other words, when criticism is stifled a cataclysm might develop which changes the status quo. Moreover, Weisinger states that criticism from the likes of Galileo, Darwin and Freud changes societies in general. Criticism is necessary for growth, and criticism cannot be suppressed without consequences. Therefore, according to Weisinger (1989), criticism, being necessary for growth and change, and being necessary to influence, motivate and change behavior, must be expressed in a positive way so that the criticism can be accepted and useful, as opposed to simply negative and demoralizing. Weisinger further states that there are barriers to individuals accepting criticism and applying the criticism to their lives to makes themselves, and the organization, better. There are psychological hurdles which must be overcome. Weisinger talks in terms of cognitive appraisal, which means that individuals have a mental framework with which they receive information like criticism, and this framework dictates how the criticism will be processed. The framework is built through classical conditioning – criticism in the past has produced a negative response, so present criticism, even if tactfully presented, will also present the negative response. Moreover, since criticism is often portrayed in the media as negative – such as headlines which link criticism to failure – the mind links the two concepts together. Criticism equals failure. Modeling is another psychological force at work, and this means that how one’s family criticized one another is what is known to the individual. If one’s parents responds to criticism by yelling, making retaliatory comments, or leaving the room, the individual is likely to do the same. The modeling focuses upon how one criticizes, as well as how one reacts to criticism. Operant learning is also a force at work, and this is when an individual does X, he gets the result of Y. A worker responds to criticism with anger, so the supervisor backs off. This reinforces the angry response, so that the worker continues to use this response when criticized. Since criticism is obviously necessary, because there can be no growth and change without it, and individuals are hard-wired either to not accept criticism gracefully or to give criticism in a counter-productive manner, what can be done? This question is the focus of Heidringer’s book and and analysis. The bulk of the analysis is that criticism must be redefined in a manner that it is not seen as tearing somebody down, but, rather, giving them information which they can use to improve. This is an important message to myself and my future career growth, not just because it is inevitable that I will be criticized, so I need to know how to handle this criticism and apply it so that it is not negative but positive, but also because it will help me learn how to criticize so that any team that I ...Show more


Introduction The major thrust of the book The Critical Edge is how organizations can make criticism useful and work for them, as opposed to against them. As Weisinger (1989) states in the first chapter, the reactions to criticism is typically negative – it wounds people, it ends up with hurt feelings and the criticized person ends up feeling lonely…
Author : reingermarquise
How to Criticize Up and Down Your Organization and Make It Pay Off essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"How to Criticize Up and Down Your Organization and Make It Pay Off"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Consider a particular real organization of your choice which has an international profile. Discuss how the organization is adopt
Correspondingly, The Ford Motor Company is regarded as one of the leading and renowned automobile companies in the world. The company is based in Michigan, US and operates in excess of 200 nations across the world. The company also employs 370000 personnel in diverse locations of its operations spread globally.
12 pages (3000 words) Essay
Consider a particular real organization of your choice which has an international profile. Discuss how the organization is adopt
The company is recognised to be a multinational corporation (MNC) operating on a global context. It is a renowned automobile manufacturer, producing millions of vehicles for worldwide customers. The company, operating in worldwide business market segments is based on different activities that include ‘research & development’ (R&D), sales, manufacturing and exports.
12 pages (3000 words) Essay
Choose any organisation of your choice and as external observer of the organization undertake critical analysis of the following functions and make recommendations for improvement
Human resource strategy will majorly involve the creation and maintenance of a productive workforce that is motivated and satisfied in terms of rewards for
16 pages (4000 words) Essay
How control systems and quality management relate to motivation in your own organization
Quality control and quality management systems in the healthcare company ensure quality of products and services. They involve a planned and organized approach
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Make up your own topic
The aim of the essay therefore it to evaluate how well the author presented the arguments in terms of analyzing the article with a keen and critical eye and gauge its
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Security within Your Organization
CIA (Confidentiality, Integrity, and Availability) Triangle is a renowned and respected Information Security benchmark that is widely adapted by
3 pages (750 words) Essay
How does Flaubert criticize the society with Madam Bovary
Charles Bovary, a doctor and husband to Emma is depicted as being ignorant about Emma’s relationships with other men, which results in failure of their marriage and eventual
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Make by your self
The calculation was that in three analyses, participants could have an improved bring to mind of normative information. Conformity is a kind of social
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
How To Make Resume
C. A resume is one of the most important documents in the process of employment hence the need to analyze it (Youth Central n.p).
3 pages (750 words) Essay
How To Make Resume
burial through mummification, especially in the period between 2,600 BC to around 300 AD, were very high and economically draining to the people, to say the very least. C. Critical in the history of Egypt is mummification and mummies, and so we will endeavor to delve into the
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
Contact Us