StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu
  • Home
  • Subjects
  • Education
  • Compares and contrasts formative, summative, and confirmative evaluation in the instructional design process

Compares and contrasts formative, summative, and confirmative evaluation in the instructional design process - Research Paper Example

Nobody downloaded yet

Extract of sample
Compares and contrasts formative, summative, and confirmative evaluation in the instructional design process

Here, the clarity, impact and feasibility of the message and the instruction are determined. In the small group evaluation, the entire group is handed similar feedback based on grouped outcome of the successes or difficulties. This effectively addresses the instruction rather than the learners. In the field trial evaluation, the instructor uses the design and course materials already modified twice to present a full-scale instructional session. Challenges with formative evaluation are often found in feasibility matters. Students’ capabilities, instructional environment and medium greatly impact the outcome of the stage. The motivation, independence and maturity of individual students will determine the required time to complete the stage (Smaldino, Rusell & Heinrich, 2005). Summative evaluation is beneficial because it is possible to develop consistent, standardized sets of information on each learner. It also creates a justification for wide-scale decision making in education programs. Summative evaluation uses two phases to assess the worth or merit of a program. The inclusion of external evaluators is beneficial because it adds value to the evaluation and design of the learning process and materials. In the expert judgment phase, feasibility, content, design and congruence analysis are examined. In the field trial phase, outcome and management analysis are examined. It further looks at the impact on the students, job and organization. Essentially, the performance of the group in relation to the set objective is analyzed by the instructional designer in various ways (Gagne, Wager & Keller, 2005). Organizational resources and needs are aligned with the program through congruence analysis; goals are identified through content analysis; sufficiency of modules of instructional strategies is evaluated through design analysis; and feasibility analysis is in relation to the materials’ utility. Summative evaluation is challenged when it comes to balancing process and product measures and preventing backwards implication; anticipating the scope of positive and negative consequences of using results of summative assessment; attending to both non-cognitive and affective features of flourishing academic programs; and the information’s timeliness (Gagne, Wager & Keller, 2005). In confirmative evaluation, there is a follow up of the students after they are out of the program. It is beneficial because instructors get to know their competitive levels and how well they are making use of the knowledge and information they gain from their programs. This is a marriage of the other evaluations and programs in continuous improvement. Unlike the other kinds used at the designing and learning levels, confirmative evaluation comes months after implementation of the program (Morrison, Ross & Kemp, 2004). Endurance of outcomes, efficiency and return on investments are tested. However, the challenge is that the evaluators and students are forced to commit themselves to the full scope of evaluation. Identifying and including all the stakeholders, especially decision makers and activity planners, is also a problem. Question Two Formative assessment is an ongoing measurement in educational preparation aiming at the improvement of student learning. It provides information crucial in the monitoring of an individual’ ...Show more


Instructional Design Process Name: Institution: Instructional Design Process Question One The benefit of formative evaluation in the instructional design is that experts in subject matter are a key element to the process (Paas, Renkl & Sweller, 2004). They identify inconsistencies in tasks and performances while providing guidelines on the detection, assessment and looping back of supportive feedback…
Author : oconnerxzavier
Compares and contrasts formative, summative, and confirmative evaluation in the instructional design process essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the research paper on your topic
"Compares and contrasts formative, summative, and confirmative evaluation in the instructional design process"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Formative assessment
This adjustment helps the student to meet targeted standards and goals within a set period. According to center for education research and innovation, formative assessment is an interactive assessment of the student where the teacher identifies learning needs and shapes the teaching.
3 pages (750 words) Research Paper
Evaluating Instructional Design
The basis for instructional design is in behavioral psychology, where learning is defined through paradigms in which expected behaviors are part of how the design of the instruction is put into place. In the video “Merrill on Instructional Design”, the topic of instructional design is discussed.
8 pages (2000 words) Research Paper
Applying the Principles of Instructional Design in E-Learning
With the development of information and technology, the education method also changes from simple instructional materials such as chart, books, boards, and chalks to PowerPoint presentation and online learning. E-learning has been the trend in today’s era due to the proliferation of wireless technology.
8 pages (2000 words) Research Paper
Instructional Design Outline
But as people increase their understanding of human intelligence as well as behavior, they are in a better position of knowing how they can learn more effectively. The last decade has witnessed a tremendous improvement in educational standard where the quality of teachers at all level gets better (Brighouse & Woods 1999).
8 pages (2000 words) Research Paper
Evaluation of Process
A purposive sample is described as an ideal approach of gathering data from individuals who are likely to provide accurate and sufficient information on the area being investigated (Singh, 2009). In addition, a purposive sample allows investigation to be more objective (Kothari, 2010).
3 pages (750 words) Research Paper
Comprehensive performance evaluation process
The major facets of a comprehensive performance evaluation procedure typically encompass setting effective goals for professional advancement, establishing new application fields wherein the tools associated with performance evaluation would play an imperative role along with discussing the expectations as well as the accomplishments of conducting the process in various areas (Guerra-Lopez, 2012).
4 pages (1000 words) Research Paper
Process and site design techniques
The positive and negative aspects of the first and second generation websites have been observed and described.This report seeks to evaluate the design and construction of two websites based on conventional principles used in the designing of websites.
3 pages (750 words) Research Paper
Evaluating Instructional Design
In the video “Merrill on Instructional Design”, the topic of instructional design is discussed. The three basic outlines for how to approach instruction are defined and
8 pages (2000 words) Research Paper
Design Process - Satellite hinge
The principle behind functionality of the hinge is an arrangement of joints that have been selected and are aimed at providing a quasi-center-pin guiding
3 pages (750 words) Research Paper
Design Process Tchnical
Data transfer using Bluetooth may be within fixed and mobile devices and computers. This technology is critical in the elimination of the cable data transfer, and eliminates synchronization challenges; hence it may connect several devices simultaneously,
3 pages (750 words) Research Paper
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment