StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Comparing Two Arguments - Essay Example

Nobody downloaded yet

Extract of sample
Comparing Two Arguments

He defends the use of animals in scientific experiments. Roger Caras is a well-known photographer and writer. He is known best for being a wildlife preservationist and as a president of the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals. Obviously, Caras is on the other side of the fence, defending animals as subjects in scientific experiments. Karpati believes that the use of animals in scientific experiments is a necessary means to discover and understand the different principles, such as biological processes. He agrees that computer simulation may help but it will not be enough to imitate the different processes happening within one’s live body. Thus, it is important to have live subjects to replicate the same processes. He argues that if the use of animals in experimentation is restricted, the scientific research will be greatly impacted. Medicines, surgical techniques and other great innovations may not be discovered for years, even decades. Karpati says he does not advocate a cruel treatment to animals, rather he wants the public, and the animal rights movement, to ponder on whether to choose using animals to discover treatments for the illness of a child or to let a sick child die without attempting to treat him. Caras, on the other hand, argues that animals have rights and we don’t have the right to inflict pain and suffering on them. We should not be treating animals as properties that we can do anything we want to. Caras believes that there is a pressing need to find alternatives to animals when doing scientific research. His argument focuses on the quest to discover other means on how scientific research can effectively simulate the needed information gathered from live bodies. Different with other animal rights advocate, he attempts to direct the public in resolving the conflict by looking for alternatives rather than by just arguing not to use animals or to continue using them as live subjects. While Karpati defends his point of view, Caras points the reader to a different direction. Caras wants the reader to look for solutions rather than just argue about the issue. Karpati wants the reader to understand that the restriction of animal use might as well be a call to limit scientific research. He does this by enumerating the many effects of limiting the use of animals in research. He says that “the terrifying effects of the effort to restrict the use of animals in medical research is that the impact will not be felt for years and decades” (Karpati). He continues that drugs, surgical techniques, and fundamental biological processes may not be discovered and understood until years later, and even more that these delays may mean the cost of many lives. Karpati defends himself by saying he does not advocate animal cruelty. In fact, he believes that the animal rights movement has made a significant contribution in making the scientific community search harder for suitable alternatives for animal experiments. But Caras believes that there is little effort in doing so as it has only recently become an imperative for the scientific community (Caras). Caras points out that even if the scientific community is looking for alternatives, they are not looking hard enough or their efforts are delayed. Caras and Karpati both declares that the scientific co ...Show more


Our belief in the different methods that science and technology use varies from one person to another. We don’t always see eye to eye. And even those within the field itself, they differ in their perspectives. Even more, individuals from outside of the field would either be against, for or apathetic to the scientific issues that are faced by the field of science and technology…
Author : jacintopagac
Comparing Two Arguments essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Comparing Two Arguments"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Comparing two poems
The universal truth of death is one of the most reluctantly acknowledged facts that are never accepted until death has occurred. Indeed, all emotions and apprehensions associated with death, assume a gigantic and metaphysical aspect because people have to succumb to its cruel intentions when the time arrives.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Comparing Two Pathways to Tolerance and World Peace
To worship my country as a god is to bring a curse upon it.”  According to me, this statement forms a reflection of Tagore’s intention to create the Santiniketan community that promoted the ideals of cosmopolitanism that worked against the ethnic forces of Hindu Nationalism.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Comparing two arguments
He also lectures at Harvard School of Public Health in the Department of Society, Human development, and Health. He was the head of Harvard School of Public Health College Alcohol study that conducted studies on causes and effects of binge drinking among college students.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
In the present age of technological enlightenment, these thinkers have their own arguments towards the roots and basis of religion. In fact, frequent discoveries of new planets and scientific inventions have branded different religions as dogma, based on ethical dilemma.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Two Types Of Arguments
The key feature of the argument system is to understand the topic and then give points with examples, definitions, and words from other credible sources as well as other thinkers, writers, scientists or notables who have considered the topic in depth. The
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Comparing Two Similar Businesses
cally compare two similar companies, namely and Borders Books, in terms of their business approach, management tactics, and marketing strategies. is a multinational electronic commerce company headquartered at Seattle in the United States. The company was
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Comparing two scenes
At this point, the film takes us back to the early colonial periods in Cameroon during the times when France was growing up. The film therefore captures the interracial tensions
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Comparing two electroinics
In this case, a device with around 2gb RAM, 120gb Hard drive is satisfactory to my concerns. After visiting the electronic shop, I found only two devices that meet my requirements including
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Comparing Two Dissertations about Accountancy and Finance
This study is going to follow a theoretical framework that will present to the reader clear and concise points of arguments. Therefore, this paper will start by providing a summary of each dissertation project and outlining a thorough discussion of the aims and methods used in the project as well as analyzing the results and findings provided at the end of each project.
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Comparing between two country
The two nations have experienced a lengthy history of building their political, economic and social structures that share a lot in common and have remarkable differences (Grawert 68). However, with an actively renewed East African Community, a regional
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
Contact Us