StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

How compelling do you find Ball,s argument in this 2011 article - Essay Example

Nobody downloaded yet

Extract of sample
How compelling do you find Ball,s argument in this 2011 article

In terms of the catalyst for the educational change, Ball indicates that the primary contributing factor is the new types of education sponsors and providers. In considering the text, one recognizes that while Ball provides a varying amount of supporting information, the article lacks grounded empirical support for many of its contentions. Additionally, there is the recognition that the researcher does not directly involve themselves in the research. Because of these aforementioned elements, there is the potential that Ball’s insights are ideologically motivated. Still, there are also a number supporting elements. Fletcher-Campbell & Brill (2008; Action 1.9) indicated that it is important to consider the changing nature of education in socio-historical contexts. The recent global recession, as well as the emergence of for-profit instructional institutions, have concomitantly presented necessity and motivation for the shifting structures Ball refers to. A further recognition is presented by Edwards, Sebba & Rickinson (2007; Action 1.4) who indicate the importance of a multiplicity of perspectives to expand the range of interpretations. Ball’s insights then operate within these frames of reference. As one considers the particular arguments of the text, it becomes clear that they include a variety of notable points. Ball begins in discussing leadership. One of the important distinctions in this section is his consideration of new leadership frameworks. Ball (2011, p. 50) states, “there is the rhetoric and sensibilities of business into state schooling and the production of various forms of ‘entrepreneurial headship.’’’ Ball seems to be indicating that the shifting sponsorship and control of schools has resulted in a new form of leadership influenced by entrepreneurial values. One recognizes that the very language Ball implements in this section, namely ‘entrepreneurialism’ of educational environments, is a mode of considering the subject from multi-disciplinary perspectives. This is an approach supported by Mary James (Action 1.5) in encouraging learning across professional communities. On a larger conceptual scale, one considers the linkage between the workplace and the educational environment. A thematic current throughout the article is that Ball is increasingly referring to the hybridization of the work and school environment. There is the recognition that a similar dichotomy is explored in Action 1.6. While Ball’s argument continues to be rooted in the context of the classroom, there is a clear parallel to Action 1.6’s expanded contextual investigation to the workplace. In both instances, there is an increasing exploration of learning as intrinsically linked with working. Even while Ball may be ideologically opposed to the intrusion business on education, it appears that this is an inevitable new direction in education reform. Ball’s own contention that the ownership of these institutions have increasingly refrained from sharing process information, while outwardly a detriment to progress, in actuality it may hold significant potential for educational research. Edwards, Sebba & Rickinson (2007; Action 1.4) indicate that a multitude of stakeholders is actually beneficial for refining ideas. While the lack of proprietary sharing may be a slight drawback, the diversity of stakeholders is ...Show more


TMA 1 Part I: How Compelling Do you Find Ball’s Argument? Stephen Ball’s article ‘A new research agenda for educational research and policy’ (2011) examines a number of shifting trends in education. Ball divides this research into three main categories: leadership, values and interest, and ownership…
Author : walkerbode
How compelling do you find Ball,s argument in this 2011 article essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"How compelling do you find Ball,s argument in this 2011 article"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

How convincing do you find Stuart Hall's approach to 'race'
Among other things, Stuart Hall developed an outstanding approach to the explanation of the nature and dynamics of race and racism. This approach sufficiently addressed the issue of race with perfect ideas and clarification on how a race and attributed qualities which tend to be relative to other races are recognised by people.
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
Discuss the differences between Hamilton's and Jefferson's views on politics, society and economics. Were there any areas of agreement between the two Which view(s) do you find most compelling Explain
They differ vehemently in many areas of politics and economics. Their views pertain foreign and domestic debts, matters pertaining to economy and military, banking, constitutional dispensation, political reforms and human rights, just to
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Topic: Education (Choose an argument or article in the section relating to how we learn) and write a well-crafted essay in which you prove some point
In recent years, one of the most notable considerations in terms of natural selection has been the extent that human culture actively plays a part in evolution, with scientists
2 pages (500 words) Essay
You throw the ball straight up in the air. The instant after leaving your hand the ball’s speed is 30 m/s. Ignoring the effects of air resistance, predict how fast the ball is traveling 2 seconds
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Summarize the article, the authors argument, and how he or she supports that argument
Laura Mulvey, a British feminist film theorist, has said that women are used as nothing but commodities in movies (Mulvey 8). According to Mulvey, women are used in art or entertainment only to fulfill the
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Find this article and answer the following questions: A process of decision making by caregivers of family members with heart failure. Research & Theory for Nursing Practice, 25(1), 55-70 by Sanford, J., Horigan, A.,&Hall, P. (2011)
However, some of the care givers may have little preparation for this role. Besides, patients sometimes change their wishes regarding care during various stages of the
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Gould 's argument for evolution
The author thinks that the contradiction of creation science is caused by vernacular misunderstandings between evolutionists and scientists. For instance, he believes
2 pages (500 words) Essay
What do you see as Maryland s biggest transportation issue and how would you solve it
Statistics from the U.S Census Bureau in 2000 revealed that 85% of Marylands population lives in the states congested urban areas such as Baltimore and Philadelphia metropolitans (Cox, 2009). The remaining population lives in the rural
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Find a peer reviewed journal article on a topic of your choosing that highlights the scientific method or scientific process. Summarize the article and explain how you use the scientific procession your life
The study examines the structure of the water molecule and the manner in which the molecules combine to form ice and water. The article evaluates the structural changes that occur when
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Can you follow the reasoning of the Fine Tuning Argument Are you convinced by it's reasoning and it's response to many universes hypotheses Why or why not
Fine tuning discusses the view of the philosophers, theologians and scientists. I do not agree with the argument because I strongly think that Gods nature is far more
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
Contact Us