Decision of the High Court of Australia in Dasreef Pty Ltd v Hawchar - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Decision of the High Court of Australia in Dasreef Pty Ltd v Hawchar

Sections76-80 of the Evidence Act 1995 NSW deal with opinion evidence (Evidence Act 1995). Section 79 provides for expert evidence as opinion based on specialised knowledge although there is no expression of the term ‘expert’ (Ying, 2005, p 76). Section 177 of the Act provides for an expert evidence to be given in the form of certificate with the expert’s name and address and his signature affirming that he possesses specialised knowledge acquired through study, training or experience as mentioned in the certificate.
The certificate should claim that his expert opinion contained therein is based on such knowledge through study, experience or training. This could serve as admissible evidence without the expert attending the court unless the opposing party requires him to tender evidence in person at the court and be subjected to cross-examination. If , after tendering of the evidence by the expert in person , the court feels that there was no need for his personal appearance to tender evidence, costs may be imposed on the party who made such a request for being awarded to the expert (Ying,2005,p78). In fact, the expert evidence is one of the exceptions to the opinion rule as evinced by the section 76. Evidence law does not allow opinion of a witness unless he/ she is an expert in the relevant field. Other witnesses may only testify to the facts as to their existence without being qualified by their opinion. ...
Download paper


The decision of the High Court of Australia in Dasareef Pty Ltd v Hawchar [2011] HCA 21 handed out on 22 June 2011 involves the admissibility of expert evidence of Dr Basden for the side of Hawchar in evidence of his having contracted silicosis during his employment with Dasareef Pty Ltd…
Author : hannah71

Related Essays

Architecture and Construction
There is a new bypass diverts a large portion of the peak hour traffic returning plot to the once humble town. Direct access to the nearby parklands makes for easy walking routes. Content & Quality Expectations The development will be an apartment that will have its own uninterrupted ocean views with access to the site. Each apartment will have 3 bedrooms, all with ensuites, a study, a theatre room, large open living with plenty of room for dining and also 2 spacious balconies. The main balcony will be facing northeast, and the second balcony will be northwest and will accessible via the main...
5 pages (1255 words) Essay
Quantity Surveyors Role in Construction Dispute Resolution
The system being young is in a phase of evolution, hence some of them are the there are several techniques that are devised for the execution of the approach. This paper will cover the most relevant and applied ones with respect to the construction industry of UK. In addition, I strongly believe that we discuss techniques which are being discussed and administered under Arbitration Act 1996. The techniques that are discussed in this paper would be as following, 1. Negotiation, 2. Arbitration, 3. Mini-trial , 4. Dispute Review Boards/ Dispute resolution boards, 5. Mediation 1. Negotiation One...
8 pages (2008 words) Assignment
Construction Health and Safety: "The Crossrail Project"
It is seen that the capacity will be freed at the current termini like Paddington and Liverpool, once Crossrail will have been completed in 2017. The project will also create up to 14,000 jobs at the peak of its construction in 2013/2015. Moreover, it will help create a further 7,000 jobs indirectly according to Great Britain: Parliament: Select Committee on the Crossrail Bill (2007 P. 1784-1789). New chances for interchanges with Overground services and TfL Underground would further help reduce congestions at the termini. This in turn, will enable central London stations in business and...
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Construction Health and Safety
Otherwise, any designer who may be engaged by a domestic client is obliged to comply with the rules. Construction works refer to construction alteration, upkeep, repair and maintenance, commissioning, renovation, decommissioning, redecoration, fitting-out, demolition or dismantling. It also includes site preparation, exploration and surveys. Failure to comply with the code is treated as evidence of breach of health and safety legislation by a court of law. The regulations cover the responsibilities of clients, the roles of principal contractors and sub-contractors, the roles of designers and...
7 pages (1757 words) Essay
health and safety in construction
Through this many industries will be able to prevent the occurrences of accidents in the workplace. The industries should also be ready to compensate anyone when he has been in involved in such accidents. This can lead to most people being able to be employed in this sector as most of the people are unemployed and also are not ready to work in construction companies. The health sector should also be checked because when people who are not fling well are not allowed to rest it may lead to accidents not only to him but to others. Some of the machinery used is not updated or old which may lose...
7 pages (1757 words) Essay
health and safety in construction
The introductory section of the discussion give general information concerning the application of occupational health and safety rules in the contemporary society. The discussion is extended in the second section which describes of the statute laws applicable in occupational health and safety, its key requirements as well as the strategies that were applied to gather the information. The third section of the discussion discusses a legislation that has been applied in the United States of America to guide issues of occupational health and safety; modes of information retrieval are also...
7 pages (1757 words) Essay
Construction procurement and legal framework for construction operations
It may be either small scale or large scale. For successful completion of the construction project, effective planning is crucial. There are various types of construction: 1. Residential building construction 2. Commercial building construction 3. Industrial building construction 4. Heavy civil construction. The type of construction is the chief determinant of the variety of approach to the procurement of construction services. Construction procurement is absolutely crucial to the delivery of a project on time, budget and high quality. Good procurement is synonymous with the success of the...
14 pages (3514 words) Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!