StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Construction law - Essay Example

Free

Extract of sample
Construction law

It must be emphasized that the loss or injury suffered by the claimant must be of consequential nature. In other words, the loss must be the result of the damaged or defective nature of the property and not the damage to the property itself. When a party has acted negligently which results in a defective property, there is only pure economic loss which is not actionable under tort laws. They may only sue based on contractual rights and obligations. But when such damaged property has caused actual injuries to persons or damages to other properties, then it is now a consequential loss which gives rise to liabilities for negligence under the English law on tort. English jurisprudence has wavered on this issue starting from the landmark case of Donoghue v Stevenson ([1932] All ER Rep 1; [1932] AC 562) where the House of Lords established the proximity rule in defining the existence of duty of care and the concomitant liability for negligence. ...
Donoghue did not buy the drink herself; it was her companion who ordered and paid for the fateful drink. The Anns v Merton London Borough Coucil ([1977] 2 All ER 90) case is an epitome of the dynamic character of UK common law. The short-lived Anns test was used as basis for the determination of liabilities for negligence until it was totally abandoned in the case of Murphy v Brentwood District Council. The Anns doctrine requires a case to pass its two-stage test, namely, (1) whether or not the proximity or neighbourhood between the claimant and the

Related Essays

Construction Law
This represents contractual relationships under a standard building procurement. The employer enters into separate contracts with the designer and the contractor. When the designer completes the design, the contractor will carry it out. The employer has direct control over the design, cost and quality elements; however, the process of designing becomes more time-consuming.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Construction Law
Inferior materials used on the exterior of the building 2. Wrong materials used in the reception area floor 3. Defective doors discovered by Innocent's architects and 4. Dampness in the ceiling discovered during the rectification period This section will examine these issues in three main parts.
14 pages (3500 words) Essay
Construction law - standard form contracts
The latest version of NEC came to be known as NEC 3 and that of JCT was JCT 2005. At this juncture, the present essay attempts to evaluate some of the important provisions of the two contracts. The essay takes a comparative approach wherein an attempt is made to compare and contrast the important provisions found in both contracts.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Construction Law
tated that it should have been designed as a formal protocol rather than as a guidance tool.1 Since the provisions of the protocol are intended to be a guidance tool, they end up creating more confusion on some aspects rather than resolving them. Construction projects cannot be
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Construction Law
According to Yates and Epstein, delays in construction projects for example, may be initiated right at the commencement stage itself due to poor management within the supply chain.1 The question of creation of risk arises from the supply side, since it is
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Construction law essay and legal problem case
tious and it is common in the construction industry for negotiating parties to rely on letters of intent to address long term delivery requirements and materials purchase orders2. However, ambiguity as to the contractual status of such letters of intent lends itself to dispute
14 pages (3500 words) Essay
Construction law
Again value creation creates high expected satisfaction levels for customers, who later translate into high levels of profits and growth for construction
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Construction law
The definitions of terms that commonly arise in construction contract is provided in the Appendix. In the case of complex construction agreements, it may be noted that there are several parties involved in the contract. i.e, the main
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
defendant is sufficient to establish a duty of care between the parties; and (2) if a duty of care is thus established, whether or not there exist circumstances which would limit the scope, if not totally negate the liability of the defendant. In 1990, the House of Lords admitted its mistake in deciding the Anns v Merton London Borough Coucil case and resolved to reverse it in the case of Murphy v Brentwood District Council (3 All ER 90). In the words of Lord Mackay of Clashfern, the Anns test is abandoned “in so far as it affirmed a private law duty of care to avoid damage to property which causes present or imminent danger to the health and safety of owners, or occupiers, resting upon local authorities in relation to their function of supervising compliance with building byelaws or regulations.” Lord Keith of Kinkel went further and explained that, “Liability under the Anns decision is postulated upon the existence of a present or imminent danger to health or safety. But considering that the loss involved in incurring expenditure to avert the danger is pure economic loss, there would seem to be no logic in confining the remedy to cases where such danger exists.” In essence, the Murphy decision

Summary

On the present UK tort law, it is said that, “Generally, the damage necessary to sustain a claim in negligence must be actual physical injury to person or property other than the property which is the product of the negligence itself.” (Keating, 1995)  It may seem absurd why the law requires damaged and defective properties to actually cause injuries and further damages before allowing a claim for negligence…
Author : pdietrich
Construction law essay essay example
Read Text Preview
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation