StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Engineering Ethics - Essay Example

Nobody downloaded yet
The whistle-blowing is kept within the organization. External whistle-blowing happens when the employee reports any act of wrongdoing by the organization to higher authorities outside the organization. This could be newspapers or any law-enforcement authority. Just like whistle-blowing in a football match, this act is termed as disloyal. The act of whistle-blowing could be anonymous when it is done by an employee who does not want to be identified or acknowledged when the whistle-blower reveals him or herself. Whistle-blowing may lead to distrust, disharmony and conflict among employees. Whistle-blowing should be attempted when the following four conditions are fully met; the need, proximity, capability and as a last resort (Fleddermann 108). Case Study: Vandivier the Whistle-Blower B.F. Goodrich Corporation was in-charge of producing breaks and wheels for military craft and became a major contractor to the Air Force. The design for the product was to be tested and the need for its performance mandatory so that the corporation could be awarded the contract. Materials that could work perfectly from the design were not available, hence the design failed to meet the required specifications. Nevertheless, Kermit Vandivier, a technical writer for the corporation wrote a report on the new A7-D brakes that was integral for decision-making process by the Air Force. Vandivier knew that some of the test results had been rigged and raised an alarm but the management thwarted him. His concern was on the safety of the brakes and his legal responsibility. He further contacted his attorney and later the FBI who investigated the matter. Vandivier left the firm later and blew the whistle again to Daily News and the matter was handled by Senator William Proxmire. From the GAO report, the discrepancies were noted but no official action was taken (Fleddermann 115,116). Did Vandivier meet the criteria set out in the previous section for whistle blowing? In other words, was there a need for the whistle to be blown? YES. The conditions set for whistle blowing are; the need, proximity, capability, and last resort. The brakes offered safety for the Air Force staff when their airplanes take off or land or during emergencies. The harm that could be created was clear and important, hence there was need to blow the whistle (Fleddermann 109). Did he have proximity? He also had first hand information about the brakes since he was the one responsible for writing a credible report that would lead to acceptance or disqualification of the product. This made him qualify the second condition of proximity (Fleddermann 109). Was he capable? Although he internally blew the whistle, he was not in a capable position to stop the vice. The management thwarted his efforts and this risked his career and financial security. He left the job and got employment in other firms, yet the issue was not resolved (Fleddermann 109). Was it a last resort? The forth condition to consider before whistle-blowing is that it must be a last resort after focusing on other alternative options, and other available options within the organization do not bear fruit. Vandivier followed this condition. His first attempt was to report to the management about the malpractice. After the management thwarted his efforts, he reported the matter to the U.S Attorney who advised him to ...Show more


Name: Class: Instructor: Engineering Ethics Whistle-Blowing One of the duties of engineers is to protect the health and safety of the public. This is outlined in the code of ethics of professional engineering societies. This code of ethics grants engineers authority to blow the whistle on acts or projects that pose great harm to the public…
Author : kbeatty
Engineering Ethics essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Engineering Ethics"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Engineering Ethics
The essential engineer must persuade his fellow engineers to change the world and not limit themselves to only studying how to construct bridge, roads, skyscrapers and other infrastructures by focusing by including getting the necessary budget for the purchase and construction of the suicide prevention devices.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Engineering Ethics
The author claims that engineering ethics has intimate connection with the ethos and culture of the country to which the manufacturer belongs. The question of engineering ethics acquires a special dimension as any decision to keep silent might harm customers while there will be considerable economic loss if all faulty units are recalled.
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Engineering Ethics
To the best of my knowledge, no one has stolen French nuclear fuel to make a weapon, no one has mounted a successful terrorist attack on a French nuclear plant, France is a leader in technology that actually recycles some nuclear waste, and most French citizens have a favorable or at least neutral view of nuclear power.
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Engineering Ethics Essay
Suicide is becoming one of the most disastrous social threats faced by human beings today and thus it is a professional obligation on engineers to find solutions to this ever increasing social evil. This paper is concerned with the answers to the most common questions about engineers’ role in suicide prevention and control.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Engineering Ethics
From the case, we realize the fact that the experience of the former student engineer is in question. Despite serving as an engineer at a local engineering firm, he still searches for guidance in interpreting an engineering report from a more qualified engineer than himself.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Engineering Ethics
In short, the definition for this Engineering ethics is the rules and standards that are being observed while governing the professional conduct of engineers (Fleddermann), Summing everything, the actual need in the current technology infested world is that of professionals who consider mindful, critical stance while applying themselves to their work.
12 pages (3000 words) Essay
Engineering Ethics
As the professional code of ethics puts a professional binding on engineers to work for the welfare of mankind and utilize their knowledge and resources available to them for the development and augmentation of human beings, therefore, solving the social issues is also one of the various responsibilities of an engineer.
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
Engineering Ethics
Therefore, the engineering profession involves public commitment to operating with honesty and integrity. This is essential in development of an immense level of confidence and trust, and a positive perception of the
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Engineering Ethics
Alternatively, Tim can order for the supply to be provided to the machine that is experiencing short supply at the time to see whether he can beat the time and give the products (Graham, 2008). On the second question Tim is faced with a problem
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Engineering Ethics
The workers in that company would also be involved since they would have played a part on pollution of the environment. Technology is of more benefit but at the same time it has many implications. Ethics considers the positive dimensions of engineering and
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
Let us find you another Essay on topic Engineering Ethics for FREE!
Contact us:
Contact Us Now
  • About StudentShare

  • Testimonials

  • FAQ

  • Blog

  • Free Essays
  • New Essays
  • Essays

  • The Newest Essay Topics
Join us:
Contact Us