(Name) (Professor) (Subject) (Date) Organ Selling David Holcberg is a Brazilian specialist at the Ayn Rand Center for Individual Rights and holds a degree in civil engineering. He is popular for his letters to the editor in the top newspapers in America including the Wall Street Journal, the New York Times, and USA Today…
In David Holcberg’s “Human Organs for Sale,” the effectiveness of persuasion is determined by the proper use of pathos and logos. In the quote, “A father, for example, may decide that one of his kidneys is worth selling to pay for the best medical treatment available for his child,” the author effectively uses pathos to draw out the emotion of love and care from the reader. Thus, parents and children are both struck hard by such a statement and are most likely persuaded that indeed organ selling is basically a matter of love. Logos or the use of reason is also another effective way to draw out support for the sensibility of organ selling. In the quote, “The fact, however, is that human beings (poor or rich) do have the capacity to reason, and should be free to exercise it,” the author is showing a basic fact and a reasonable stance on the issue. It is a fact that humans have the capacity for reason and thus a right to make decisions for themselves. Although Holcberg fails to consider the possibility of unsound and unhealthy decisions, he is illustrating a basic fact that is most likely to convince so many readers. Holcberg’s also has its share of unpersuasive and ineffective statements, and mostly these could be anything from exaggerations to fallacious statements. In the quote, “Of the 82,000 waiting for kidneys or livers, about 6,000 will die in the next twelve months,” the point of the author is not only exaggerating but also discouraging. This statement actually has the danger of convincing the readers not of the urgency of approving the legality of selling body organs but of the futility of the decision to do so. There is also the danger of shouting out statements that are by nature fallacious. The quote “If the law recognizes our right to give away an organ, it should also recognize our right to sell an organ” is an example of this. The law may actually only recognize the person’s right to give away something but definitely it cannot recognize the right to sell. The statement does not particularly strike the reader as something logical or reasonable. If one wants to give away old clothes as donation, it somehow does not follow that it is also right to sell these clothes and make money out of it. The conclusion of the statement, therefore, obviously does not follow from the premise. Joanna MacKay, in her “Organ Sales Will Save Lives,” is also as adamant as Holcberg in presenting her stance in favor of organ selling. She particularly capitalizes on logos and pathos which are both intricately combined. In the statement, “In the year 2000 alone, 2583 Americans died while waiting for a kidney transplant,” MacKay is trying to present a fact that has a particular effect on the emotion of the human reader. The fact that 2583 Americans died in 2000 alone because they were not able to have kidney transplants was a sad fact and something that could not be helped without the legalization of organ selling. Thus, with such an emotion, the readers are convinced that organ selling is the only way that can save people from dying. In the same way, the author uses a fact to elicit an emotion in the reader in the line “If legalized and regulated, the sale of human organs would save lives.” In this particular statement, the author is somehow making a sane statement that legalization and regulation of organ selling will be able to save lives. It is like defending it while not exaggerating the details. ...
Cite this document
(“Analysis of two reading assignment to their persuasiveness: their Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.net/english/106758-analysis-of-two-reading-assignment-to-their
(Analysis of Two Reading Assignment to Their Persuasiveness: Their Essay)
“Analysis of Two Reading Assignment to Their Persuasiveness: Their Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.net/english/106758-analysis-of-two-reading-assignment-to-their.
The importance of maintaining a fine line in every decision-making was then emphasized. This can benefit both the leader and the followers. There were many instances that the followers became the writer's rescuer. Second, the leader must learn how to cultivate his or her followers.
Likewise, when Anderson says, “Most studies find that males and females are equally affected, and that high and low aggressive individuals are equally affected” (Anderson cited in Ramage, Bean, and Johnson 447), not a single study has been cited for evidence.
Legalization of the sale of these organs has become the debate for many years and politicized severally. Many authors have written about the issue with examples of two samples covered in this essay. David Holcberg is one of the authors who have written several articles including case of organ sale.
Gun control measure are made stiff every time there is an event of irresponsible shooting that indicates that crime and deaths are facilitated by the right of individuals to own licensed guns. This has resulted to the gun control policies discussions to take two perspectives including legal and criminological (Lott 25).
Jones aims to persuade his audience, primarily parents who believe that violent media is bad for their children, that violent media per se is not bad. He assumes that rage is fundamental to human identity, but it can be harnessed
Effective language process ensures that there is enough time for learners to achieve competence in a certain acquired language as well as focus on students as the center of learning process. It is classified according to its
The nonverbal cues used in face to face communication cannot be used when communicating using Facebook. At the very least, this platform turns actual friends into virtual ones and does somewhat the opposite of what it is supposed to do. In short, although
The consumer has to be aware of it. This step is significant as it helps in grabbing the consumer’s attention. The above ad is very clear and to the point. The brand name, Estee Lauder, comes out clearly plus the uses of the product (Kelley, Sheehan, & Jugenheimer,
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
GOT A TRICKY QUESTION? RECEIVE AN ANSWER FROM STUDENTS LIKE YOU!
Let us find you another Essay on topic Analysis of two reading assignment to their persuasiveness: their effective and ineffective argument for FREE!