Instructor Date Even though both Chris Abani’s and Shirley Jackson’s story appear to bear certain distinct similarities especially in view of the fact that they used “Lottery” in the titles, it is worth noting that they wrote about radically different social backgrounds and time settings…
This paper will critically examine the underlying similarities and differences between the two short stories both entitled the lottery paying attention to the thematic stylistic and contextual elements of both. The society about which Abani writes is motivated by economic and political instability which results to the development of a culture of violence and suspicion owing to the historical injustices and persecution of the people by organs of the state. In Jackson’s case, her work is a social commentary is directed towards morality as opposed to real political or social events. Furthermore, her story is a commentary about the societal failures and collective folly and community sanctioned injustice which often results in the destruction of lives families and societies at large; as such purely allegorical. She particularly satirizes the intensity with which the community believes in the importance of the lottery their contempt for those who have discontinued it evident when the “Old Man Warner snorted.” Pack of crazy fools," he said. "Listening to the young folks, nothing's good enough for them” (Jackson 4). ...
Both writers have symbolically used the juxtaposition between the title and the context creating and element of anti-climax since from reading the title; the “lottery” one will expect the story to involve an element of the convectional lottery. Normally, individuals win money/prizes or in the least that the lottery should imply something good for the “winner” owing to the universal positivity attributed to the word. Abani’s lottery is marginally more removed from the convectional context in that his story is focused on a victim of mob justice who does not in any way, to the best of the narrators, automatically the reader’s knowledge play a part in the game except as the victim. Before one reaches the climax of the story, Jackson’s lottery appears to be a convectional lottery until the winner is announced and the prize is revealed and it turns out to be just a gruesome masquerade of a lottery as was the case in the previous story. Both stories also exemplify a culture of immorality and savagery since the characters kill their own for no discernible reasons yet deign to justify the murders to an extent that they are elevated to the status of sacrifice for communal wellbeing or didactic experiences, for children. This is evident when it is stated, “Bring the children forward so they can learn” (Abani 3). The suspect is killed by the community and this reflects the dysfunction within it, since from no perspective, be it legal or moral did he deserve such a brutal death. In Jackson’s lottery, the villagers have to select an individual family and then from it an individual would be selected and killed in what Abani would describe as mob justice. ...
Cite this document
(“Compare and contrast essay between Lives The Lottery by Chris Abani”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.net/english/107830-compare-and-contrast-essay-between-lives-the
(Compare and Contrast Essay Between Lives The Lottery by Chris Abani)
“Compare and Contrast Essay Between Lives The Lottery by Chris Abani”, n.d. https://studentshare.net/english/107830-compare-and-contrast-essay-between-lives-the.
Shirley Jackson has been a powerful author, and her work has received great attention from literally critics in the past years. The author uses exciting atmosphere that brings the readers into society that is totally different from their own.
Introduction Good writers are known by the level of impact their stories make to readers. Whether stories are told of visibly evident events or based on fiction, a writer must be able to win the heart of writers at the end of the day. For Jackson, writing The Lottery was a test of her calling as a writer.
This lottery is not an ordinary one and it results in the death of one villager every year. It is basically a tradition that is followed in the village since years and this lottery does not serve to provide for cash prizes but rather the winner of this lottery is stoned to death.
Both stories give us haunting examinations of the outcomes for individuals when society's expectations force unquestioned loyalty and obedience. We also get a glimpse at the morbid decisions people can make in trying to fulfill unrealistic expectations of themselves to become what they believe society rewards.
The sheer barbarity of the act leaves the reader horrified. An apparently incomplex plot, the story derives its power from its conclusion, which catches the reader unaware. The purpose of this paper is to demonstrate how skillfully the author amalgamates various literary elements to produce tremendous shock at the end and dupe the reader all along by its deadpan narrative tone.
In writing her story, the author has used several stylistic devices like dialogue to make the reader understand the annual social event, which seems to make every town person jovial leaving the reader in a
It raises emotional arousal in its readers again and again till that arousal is almost at its breaking point, then unleashes it in an incredible torrent of emotion. The title, the symbolism, and the characters all heighten the growing sense of suspense within the story,
The appetite for King Louis XV for beauty and vivaciousness set the pace for the Rococo art style. The Rococo art stile finally resulted from France’s turning away from imperial aspirations. This paved way for artwork practices in France. This research paper compares the Baroque and Rococo art styles in the renaissance periods.
The aim of the charity is in line with our team vision which entails, initiating programs that address the needs of individuals with disabilities. The needs analysis measures the gaps that exist between the society presently, and the desired situation
I barely even noticed I was reading a story because of how well she wrote and made me believe in the story.
Because of all the news today about black people being killed by police officers, this story really gave me the chills. Although of course in this story what is
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
GOT A TRICKY QUESTION? RECEIVE AN ANSWER FROM STUDENTS LIKE YOU!
Let us find you another Essay on topic Compare and contrast essay between Lives The Lottery by Chris Abani and The Lottery (1948) by Shirley Jackson for FREE!