Name Sherlock Holmes, Hercule Poirot, and Samuel Spade Detectives have played a key role in crime novels for a long time in literature. Some popular literary detectives include Sherlock Holmes, Hercule Poirot, and Sam Spade, the characters created by Arthur Conan Doyle, Agatha Christie, and Dashiell Hammett respectively…
Hercule Poirot was a Belgian detective who appeared in Agatha Christie’s novel Murder on the Orient Express to investigate the murder of a gangster named Ratchet or Cassetti. The case seems to be very confusing as some obscure clues are found during the investigation. The victim, Cassetti had previously murdered three members of the Armstrong family and their worker. As the case progresses some shocking things reveal which seem to involve thirteen of the passengers including the conductor in the murder of Cassetti. Poirot however does not inform the police about those guilty as he feels that they are justified. Samuel Spade, more commonly known as Sam Spade, appeared in The Maltese Falcon by Dashiell Hammett who was consulted by Miss Wonderly to follow Floyd Thursby who is later murdered shortly after Sam Spade’s partner, Miles Archer. It is then revealed that Miss Wonderly lied to Sam Spade and is found to have been guilty for the murders along with other players who are trying to acquire the Maltese falcon. All the detectives differ in the style in which they approach the investigation and various cases however Sherlock Holmes of all seems to have a far more organized and scientific method of analyzing clues (Ginzburg and Davin, 6-7). Sherlock Holmes seems to have great observation and this is illustrated in A scandal in Bohemia when Holmes tells all the details about Dr. Watson when they meet (Doyle, A Scandal in Bohemia, 3). Holmes accurately identifies how Dr. Watson wanted to be a practicing doctor but could not due to the wound he got during his participation in the Afghan war. Also, that Dr. Watson got himself wet and that his servant girl does not do her work well. Holmes seems quite shocked as this true but he does not understand how Holmes was able to tell because he changed his clothes after the walk in the country (Doyle, A Scandal in Bohemia, 3). In The Red Headed League as well, Holmes demonstrates an excellent observation as he correctly identifies that Mr. Wilson was a laborer, takes tobacco, is a freemason, etc (Doyle, The Read Headed League, 3). He also deduces some important details from the hat in The Blue Carbuncle (Doyle, The Blue Carbuncle, 9). Holmes cleverly observed the minor details of cases so as to efficiently analyze clues to determine meaningful answers to the crimes. This method of noticing minor details was developed by Giovanni Morelli in art history (Ginzburg and Davin, 7). Hercule Poirot seems to be a very competent detective as he effectively speculates the clues so as to determine all the players in the murder of Cassetti. Poirot often has to interview the witnesses in order to gather information and does not rely much on observation of evidences and clues (Christie, 41). Sam Spade, on the other hand, does demonstrate critical thinking which helps him resolve the case regarding the murder of Archer and Thursby however he does not reflect superb observation skills in terms of clues (Hammett, 115). While every detective correctly investigated the cases which they are consulted to solve, there are some major differences in the style of investigation among the various detectives. Sherlock Homes presents a very effective method of information collection and evidence interpretation using an excellent observation. At many instances Dr. Watson seems to be surprised at Holmes’ ...
Cite this document
(“Sherlock hectives of holmes is a better detective then piorot and Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.net/english/111956-sherlock-hectives-of-holmes-is-a-better-detective
(Sherlock Hectives of Holmes Is a Better Detective Then Piorot and Essay)
“Sherlock Hectives of Holmes Is a Better Detective Then Piorot and Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.net/english/111956-sherlock-hectives-of-holmes-is-a-better-detective.
Sherlock Holmes- A Game of Shadows is a 2011action mystery movie starring Robert Downey Jr as the famous fictional detective Sherlock Holmes. There is no denying the fact that the original characters of Sherlock Holmes contrived by Arthur Conan Doyle known by his Meerschaum pipe, the deerstalker hat and the ever present tweed cape has certainly undergone some changes in the much successful cinematic version.
Sherlock Holmes is a fictional detective created by Scottish author Arthur Doyle and he is a famous and immensely successful fictional detective with many successful stories in his name. This detective story is considered to be amongst the greatest detective stories of the modern times and his abilities border great fantasies.
One of the most well-known detectives of all time is a man who never existed. In bringing to life the character of Sherlock Holmes through 60 original stories, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle introduced the scientific process to the process of solving crime. This paper references to two Sherlock Holmes stories (excluding "The Blue Carbuncle"), discusses the extent to which 'forensic' or 'scientific' methods are employed.
It is the age of change and social advances as well as the age of the strict social structure and a severe regard for the customs of the past. During the later period, science had been seen to bring about numerous significant changes in the way people lived their lives, not always to the betterment of society.
With particular interest in the adventures such as red headed league, speckled band, blue carbuncle, and the engineers thumb, Doyle, use three devices which include plot, narrative and character to help the reader understand
The adventures of Sherlock homes are a collection of short stories by a physician Arthur Conan Doyle. This essay is an assessment of the adventures of Sherlock Holmes with a special focus of the plot, the narrator Watson and the character Sherlock Holmes.
Sir Arthur Conan Doyle built Sherlock Holmes as a fictional detective. Sherlock Holmes is a consultant detective based in London. He is known for his intelligent logical reasoning. He also has an ability to adopt in any disguise and rely, on forensic science, to solve difficult cases.
In the book, the author has used various literary styles to bring about characterization. In this essay, the character chosen and analyzed for characterization in respect to the books provided is Doctor Watson.