Appeal to the Portfolio Committee - Reflective - Essay Example

Each essay would be further discussed in the following paragraphs. Moreover, this appeal shall justify how the three essays achieved the goals set for this portfolio. “A Response” The “A Response” essay discussed the comic “AD: New Orleans After The Deluge” which was written by Josh Neufeld. This essay focused on summarizing and identifying the writer’s strategies and analyzing the work specifically its format, topic, context, distinctions and questions.

In addition, the response essay elaborated on how the arrangement of pictures and texts affected the understanding of the readers. The following paragraphs shall prove how the essay was able to critically analyze the work by Neufeld. In a scene from the comic, the writer was able to clearly portray the significant difference between the policemen and the ordinary people. On page 135, two images show how well the policemen were dressed, which indicated their high status in the society (Neufeld 135).

However, the ordinary people appear unwell, hungry and thirsty. An outstanding theme is shown in the comic as shown by the writing attitude and layout of the author. It appears that the government was not giving much attention to providing its citizens with the basic needs for mere survival (Neufeld 135). In fact, thugs were the ones helping the people after the deluge rather than the government’s operatives. The people affected by the deluge appeared to have an overall mood of sadness and hopelessness.

Men were not even able to shave their beards or clean up the trash. Towards the scene where the people realized they were meant to be left to die, their sweaty appearance indicated how nervous and uneasy the people were. Moreover, the sweaty lady who was smoking also indicated anxiety and showed how uncomfortable the situation is, both physically and psychologically (Neufeld 143). Even worse, the same lady was a well-educated guidance counselor. However, her actions, specifically cursing and smoking, showed how intolerable the situation is for her.

As the story ends, it appears that nothing was actually accomplished for the welfare of the people (Neufeld 153). The people were left to die, which in itself raises the question “Why would the government leave the people to die?” It appears that the story aims to show that the government only cares for the rich and not the poor who are in greater need of help. The rich were able to help themselves escape the deluge through cars and planes, while the poor were left in the scene to suffer and cope up with the situation and environment.

Furthermore, the government did not really do anything to aid the poor; instead, they were left to die. Clearly, this essay was able to analyze the work by Josh Neufeld in detail. First, a brief summary was provided in the opening paragraph. The developing paragraphs were able to discuss indirect meanings that were hidden in the way the author wrote and arranged the texts. In addition, the essay also elaborated on the format, context, strategies, and questions. “The Solution” “The Solution” essay elaborated on the article written by Peter Singer entitled “What Should a Billionaire Give - and What Should You”.

Similar to the earlier essay, a brief summary was also provided in the opening paragraph of “