How does the Case of the 'Guildford Four' Illustrate the Weaknesses of Utilitarianism when used as the Moral Guide of the State?

How does the Case of the
High school
Coursework
Finance & Accounting
Pages 9 (2259 words)
Download 0
In this report, utilitarianism as proposed by Bentham will first be defined followed by discussing the reasons why “scape goat” objection is considered as a weakness similar to the Guilford Four. As proposed by Mill, the role of utilitarianism in our society will be tackled in relation to how it can provide as a better solution as compared to utilitarianism as proposed by Bentham. …

Introduction

Specifically the case of the 'Guildford Four' illustrates the weaknesses of utilitarianism when used as the moral guide of the state. In judging whether or not human action is intrinsically right (good) or wrong (evil), the role of the public policymakers comes in. As stated by Sir William Blackstone, “It is better to let ten guilty men go free than to wrongly incarcerate one innocent man”. Because of the increasing number of wrongful conviction in UK, developing a set of political rules in the form of law will not always lead to actions that are morally good. One way or the other, developing a set of political rules the the form of creating a legal system may only serve as a scapegoating tactics in the case of the true criminals. As compared to the theory of utilitarianism, the concept of deontology is totally different in the sense that deontology remains focus on judging an action by observing the righteousness or wrongness of an action regardless of whether the end result of the action is good or evil (Nishukan 2007). Instead of taking into consideration the end-result of an action, Immanuel Kant suggest the use of deontology more than the classical utilitarianism since deontology judges moral issues by carefully examining the type of actions being committed by a person
...
Download paper
Not exactly what you need?

Related papers

how does the democratic leadership style affect the work environment in school
In a school, democratic leadership has a vital role to play and it is important that the people closest to the students, get the opportunity to make decisions on school curriculum and instructions. Coalition principles state that the school itself "should model democratic practices that involve all who are directly affected by the school" In a democratic setup, students, teachers and parents could…
Management Accounting
Accounting may be defined as “the art of recording, classifying, and summarizing . transactions and events and interpreting the results thereof” (Introduction to managerial accounting, n. d, p.2). Two types of accounting are usually taking place in organizations; financial accounting and management accounting. Financial accounting and managerial accounting are entirely different things even…
How does depreciation accounting help the firm manage equipment investment costs and taxes?
” More so, the question which contains a series of sub-questions will be answered in the order in which these sub-questions have been asked. Current Liabilities usually form a sub-section of the Balance sheet. Typical Current Liabilities of known amounts may include accounts payable, short-term loans, outstanding salaries or other operating expenses that are still outstanding. Accounts payable…
How can Economic Value Added (EVA) statements be used to improve financial statement reporting, results, and success? What are s
By deducting the cost of capital and capital itself from the profit made by a business enterprise, the shareholders are able to know the value created by the capital (and includes debts) they put in the company. It is a given that all business operates under the principle of profit motive, which intends to generate revenue. The practice of Economic Value Added (EVA) however helps the financial…
How does the western model of Internet Banking apply to Russia?
This chapter of the study will therefore spell out the most important aspects of tasks that the researcher put in place as part of data collection. As much as area of the research such as the literature review holds a prospect for answering most of the research questions and by extension achieve some of the research objectives, undertaking primary data collection remains a very useful way of…
To what extent does strategic management accounting contribute to global competitiveness? Illustrate your answer through an anal
As a result they provide incomplete set of measures (Bowhill, 2008). The traditional management accountant fails to cover the assessment related to relative cost situation of its competitors. It is due to this reason that strategic management report is considered to be one of the most important forms of management accounting in the present days. The strategic management accountant emphasizes on…
How does globalization affect financial markets.
This is because globalization has created a wide-ranging affects in the financial markets of various economies. This essay will focus on the quantitative and qualitative analysis of globalization of the financial sector. The essay will use descriptive statistics to conduct the quantitative analysis. The paper will explain the impact of globalization in the capital, investment and the exchange rate…