Same Sex Marriage - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Same Sex Marriage

In an attempt to show the positive aspects of gay marriage, he has ended up disclosing the negative and harmful practices that gay marriage can potentially inculcate in adults.
The first point that is disagreeable in Sullivan’s essay is his comparison of heterosexual people with gays. The point he makes is that gays are asking for the equal status similar to that of the heterosexuals asked for during 1970’s. By this, he means that gays should be included in society without any hesitation and should be treated equally. However, what he fails to understand is that when heterosexuals were asking for equal status, they were asking for equal status ‘and’ respect for the ‘opposite’ and ‘unique’ responsibilities that women were carrying out in their married life. Females were never given importance and respect for their role in the development and growth of their families. Hence, they were asking to be given ‘equal’ status to men. However, in gay marriages there is no such friction as gays cannot fulfill the role of female no matter how feminine a partner is. Hence, comparing gay people’s demand for equal status to the demand of equal status by heterosexuals is absurd.
Secondly, Sullivan talks about the psychological wounds that gay men suffer due to heterosexual marriages they are forced into. However, Sullivan fails to look into the future of same-sex marriage. The same-sex marriage can cause immense psychological problems and deeper wounds on children as child needs both, a father and a mother, for healthy emotional and psychological growth.
Third point that is unacceptable in Sullivan’s argument is his idea of sexual freedom that gays enjoy. Sullivan is saying that sexual freedom is in having sex with anyone and anytime you want to. According to him, more partners mean more freedom. It is difficult to understand how he has come to ...
Download paper

Summary

In his essay “The case against same-sex marriage crumbles,” Andrew Sullivan has put forth the argument in favor of same-sex marriage, and has proposed that same-sex marriages should be made legal. To prove his point, he has used the so called disadvantages and problems of…
Author : hettingerbessie

Related Essays

The Fight for and Evolution of Same Sex Marriage in America
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Reasons Why Same Sex Marriage Should Be Legalized
5 pages (1255 words) Essay
Same-sex marriage
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
same sex mariage
4 pages (1004 words) Research Paper
Ethics, Gender and Family - Legalising Same-sex marriage for the benefit of children
8 pages (2008 words) Research Paper
Same sex marriage
3 pages (753 words) Essay
Should same sex marriage remain legal in the United Kingdom?
4 pages (1004 words) Research Paper
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!