Analysis of the news coverage of the Summers controversy. - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Analysis of the news coverage of the Summers controversy.

Summers emphasized that this evidential difference between men and women in sciences could not be overlooked. The media blew Summers’ remarks out of proportion in the ensuing controversy, reporting that the academic was a chauvinist, who upheld the notion that women are naturally inferior to men. In my opinion, the media framed and perpetuated the controversy, missing out on the fact that he was hypothesizing on the significant gap between men and women, while trying to provoke further research into the issue. Summers was wrong to state that women are inherently inferior to men, since he did not have any scientific evidence to prove this; further, his tendency to understate the role of gender and socialization in the same, lowers the credibility of his hypotheses.
Summers controversial remarks were first published in the Boston Globe newspaper. The paper primarily focused on the Harvard president’s second suggestion on the potential cause for fewer female representatives in sciences. This statement quoted Summers stating that males attain higher test scores in science and math than females. He continued to say that although nobody could explain this occurrence, studies in behavioral genetics shows that aspects usually attributed to conditioning or socialization could actually be based on biology. The Boston Globe reported that conference participants said that in making this point, Larry Summers was implying that women do not possess the same scientific and mathematical ability as men. The newspaper failed to report Summers’ remarks within the context he had applied. For instance, there was no emphasis of the fact that the Harvard president had mentioned other underrepresented groups. The paper was also not emphatic on Summers’ first point, which suggested that women were not adequately represented in higher echelons of academia because ...
Download paper


The former president of Harvard University, Larry Summers attended a conference on minorities and women in engineering and science in 2005, where he unwittingly sparked contention about representation of women in the disciplines of science and mathematics. In the conference that…
Author : josefinaparker

Related Essays

The role of news media, if any, on dictating/setting the political agenda in the caribbean
8 pages (2008 words) Research Proposal
News Story - Emirates vs Canada
4 pages (1004 words) Article
Economic100 Article Analysis
5 pages (1255 words) Article
Economic100 Article Analysis
5 pages (1255 words) Article
Controversy over gay & lesbian couples raising children as opposed to straight couples
2 pages (502 words) Research Paper
Film Analysis
3 pages (753 words) Essay
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!