Critique - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample

Although adequate, some elaboration on the extent of the VRE and MRSA individual infections world-wide in Introduction and discussion would have achieved a better impact in the minds of the reader. Such an elaboration becomes essential taking into consideration that these kinds of publications are read not only by clinicians but also by researchers worldwide working in non-medical areas, as well.
In the aims of the study, patient-to-patient transmission, one of the major routes of nosocomial infections, was not included. This becomes vital taking into observation that some of the patients included in the study were transferred from another hospital to University of Maryland Medical Center (UMMC) [see table 1] and from UMMC to other hospitals and elsewhere. Without including this particular parameter, the authors suggest limiting of patient-to-patient transmission as a remedial measure.
In the laboratory methods, a reference to the mentioned method of culturing is missing. If the method adopted is novel, the same should have been mentioned at appropriate places. ...
Download paper


At the outset the authors claim that this particular study as per their knowledge is the first to assess independent risk factors in a co-colonization scenario. Hence a lenient approach is being adopted in this critique for the simple reason that only once we have more data/publications the world over in the same area of research, can there be a concrete establishment of the actual prevalence, risk factors and clinical outcomes of patients who are co-colonized by vancomycin-resistant enterococci (VRE) and methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA)…
Author : mparker

Related Essays

research methodology articles Critique
Coronary Artery Bypass Grafting surgery (CABG), while being careful that none of them had compromised ventricular function, the latter condition speculated by the authors’ as an interfering factor, which might have affected correct interpretation of the data aimed to be gathered during the study. Although the sex ratio was skewered due to predominantly male patient selection, it did not matter as end point measurements included standard cardiac parameters unlikely to be biased by sex of the patient. On all 35 patients, measurements were manually obtained by independent investigators, blinded...
16 pages (4016 words) Essay
Article Critique (Diagnostic Radiography)
In reviewing the title, the essential elements of research which provide complete details on the content of the research are easily apparent. The reader is able to immediately understand what the research topic and purpose is (Caldlaw, Henshaw, and Taylor, 2005). The title is also short enough to easily be readable and long enough to contain the essential titular elements. The authors of this paper have a credible academic background in the graduate and post-graduate fields of nursing. They are also affiliated with the academe and the clinical practice, and this quality has allowed them to...
8 pages (2008 words) Essay
A Cohort Study Critique
Keywords: incidence, cancer, HIV-infected persons, general population A Cohort Study Critique The study, entitled “Incidence of Types of Cancer among HIV-Infected Persons Compared with the General Population in the United States, 1992-2003”, conducted by Patel et al. (2008), aimed in identifying and comparing the incidence of cancer among persons with HIV and the general population during the period from 1992 to 2003. This paper endeavors to make a critique of the aforementioned cohort study article. Research Question The research question chosen by this study was very interesting and...
5 pages (1255 words) Essay
Critique Medicine Essay
Generally the paper will focus on the evaluation of the research processes used in the two articles, their overall strengths and weaknesses as well the potential application of the particular researches to medical health practice. The critique will be based on both qualitative and quantitative research frameworks. The major causes of HIV transmission risks between mothers and their children include the potential contact between the mother’s and fetus blood during the labor contractions, contact between the fetus and the infected body fluids of the mothers genital tract during birth and the...
7 pages (1757 words) Essay
Medical Reesearch Critique
Esmond et al., do a good job of comparing, evaluating, and presenting the relevant data as they establish the need for further research on the subject of whether it is more beneficial to allow adult cystic fibrosis patients to self-administer a regimen of i.v. antibiotics or to require them to obtain such treatment in a hospital.
10 pages (2510 words) Book Report/Review
Critique on nursing article
What are the probable sources of information utilized by nurses to inform practice' This is the question focused by Shannon M. Spenceley, Katherine, A. O'Leary, Lesa L.K. Chizawsky, and Amber J. Ross, Carole A. The authors present a consolidated review of the literature regarding sources of information that nurses use to inform practice.
4 pages (1004 words) Article
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!