StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu
  • Home
  • Subjects
  • History
  • Consider Minow's dilemma: The central premise of individual responsibility portrays defendants as separate people capable of autonomous choice- when the phenomena of mass atrocities render that assumption at best problematic (Minow, 1998:

Consider Minow's dilemma: The central premise of individual responsibility portrays defendants as separate people capable of autonomous choice- when the phenomena of mass atrocities render that assumption at best problematic (Minow, 1998: - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Consider Minow's dilemma: The central premise of individual responsibility portrays defendants as separate people capable of autonomous choice- when the phenomena of mass atrocities render that assumption at best problematic (Minow, 1998:

Perhaps most importantly, its aim is to give the victims a forum through which their story may be told before it becomes obscured by a society unwilling to confront its unpleasant and inconvenient truths. While forgetting may seem an alluring option for some, unwilling as they are to face the disquietude brought about by rousing old skeletons, there is a greater ethical and moral imperative to exhume the past if only to serve as lessons for the future.
In her important book entitled “Between Vengeance and Forgiveness: Facing History After Genocide and Mass Violence”, Martha Minow looks at the range of institutional responses that have been crafted with the end in view of seeking justice for the victims of mass atrocities and demanding accountability from the perpetrators. The ethical imperative of incorporating justice into efforts towards peace in a post-conflict context is at the heart of the transitional justice project. Its premise is that war and conflict have brought about a slew of human rights and international humanitarian law violations which demand accountability from its perpetrators and reparation for its victims. Minow uses this framework in her book as she problematizes the difficulties of navigating the complex road to justice, in the complex terrain and conditions of a post-conflict situation.
Minow, however, presented a crucial dilemma when she stated that "The central premise of individual responsibility portrays defendants as separate people capable of autonomous choice- when the phenomena of mass atrocities render that assumption at best problematic" (1998: 46). This is a dilemma because it articulates a conflict between the desire to prosecute individual perpetrators for war crimes and crimes against humanity, and the realization that the mass atrocities were taking place amid extraordinary conditions and assigning individual criminal responsibility to the perpetrators – ...Show more

Summary

Consider Minows dilemma: "The central premise of individual responsibility portrays defendants as separate people capable of autonomous choice- when the phenomena of mass atrocities render that assumption at best problematic" (Minow, 1998: 46)
The recognition of the…
Author : tevinaufderhar
Consider Minows dilemma: The central premise of individual responsibility portrays defendants as separate people capable of autonomous choice- when the phenomena of mass atrocities render that assumption at best problematic (Minow, 1998: essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Consider Minow's dilemma: The central premise of individual responsibility portrays defendants as separate people capable of autonomous choice- when the phenomena of mass atrocities render that assumption at best problematic (Minow, 1998:"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Does the assumption and implementation of corporate social responsibility makes businesses more successful
Does the assumption and implementation of corporate social responsibility makes businesses more successful? Introduction and Background Corporate responsibility in the most comprehensive form is how companies manage their businesses to form a more positive impact on the society.
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Consider the proposition that success can be as problematic for organisations as failure, with reference to groupthink (Janis 19
This is because success is envisaged in a totally different way and has repercussions which range on a wholly varied level. Organizational success embodies the basis of understanding that it has done something concrete for the sake of its stakeholders, and has been able to manifest its truest basis time and time again.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
The central dilemma of macro-economic policy is not the choice between using monetary or fiscal policy but whether to intervene
However, it does not deal with the question whether these policies are desirable. On the contrary, normative analysis looks into the question whether the policy should be used. Therefore, there are various disagreements within economists based on personal beliefs and value judgments (Abel & Bernnanke, pp.21, 2005).
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Minow's dilemma critical evaluation
A fairly recent innovation, it was developed with the end in view of sweeping off the dust that has settled over past atrocities and demanding that its perpetrators face accounting in history. Perhaps most importantly, its aim is to give the victims a forum through which their story may be told before it becomes obscured by a society unwilling to confront its unpleasant and inconvenient truths.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Rights of Homeless People and the Balance Between Individual Rights and a Community's Responsibility
Other people offered help by giving money, food and clothes but in every actions these people did, particular questions arise “What are the rights of this man?” or “What are my responsibilities towards this man?”. The most basic human right is the opportunity to use a safe and secure housing.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Key issues to consider when designing for people with disabilities
The paradigm of the societal perception has been that unintentionally, they have denied the basic human dignity of self respect and financial independence to a core sector that needs to come out of
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
The causes of crime are ultimately matters of individual responsibility and choice. Critically discuss
During this time, an injurer would offer a payment to his victim a certain amount of money which they negotiated in order for the victim to avoid revenging. Every civilisation and country has had to recognize and define crime within their own value
16 pages (4000 words) Essay
Theories of national cultures fail to consider the impact of both individual difference and organisational choice Critically assess this statement and consider the ways organisations might become more, or less, similar to each other
Theories of national cultures although helpful are often criticized because they over generalize characteristics of culture and ignore individual differences
11 pages (2750 words) Essay
Voting: Why do people vote Assess the public choice approach to this issue and consider its implications for collective choice
Essentially Muller explains three ways inculcated in the voters paradox. They include redefining a rational or coherent voter’s calculus, relaxing rationality assumption and relaxing self-interest assumption. In
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Premise
In Canada, over two hundred thousand patients acquire infections in hospitals. Eight thousand of those who acquire infections in hospital die because of the
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation