StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Analysis of ethical dilemma that has been addressed by a professional journalist - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Analysis of ethical dilemma that has been addressed by a professional journalist

Why? c. What was the effect of the decision on the individuals involved and on the community in general? What would have been the effect of a different choice in addressing this ethical decision? d. Are there any relevant laws that influenced the journalist’s decision? If so, what does the law state, and how did it affect the decision? Are there any legal implications to the decision? Ethical Dilemma Addressed by a Professional Journalist Chosen Report The report chosen to be analyzed for this paper is entitled “The boy with a broker heart: special problems with juveniles are newsmakers” written by Richard Paxson (2011). Case facts revealed the story of a 14 year old boy, Jody Collins, who accidentally caused the death of a schoolmate when punched at the back. Apparently, the schoolmate, named Justin Charlie, was reported to have had a “plastic valve sewn into his heart a month before to fix a birth defect. When Jody hit Charlie, the blow ripped out stitches holding the valve in the aorta, according to the autopsy report. Charlie’s heart stopped beating” (Paxson, 2011, par. 3). Reporter Nick Lamberto investigated the facts behind the incident by pursuing Jody at his home and interviewing him without seeking prior consent from an adult. Subsequent news reports have identified Jody when he was charged with involuntary manslaughter and assault. Adding insult to injury, Jody, who was previously identified as a victim to a sexual abuse and testified in court during the uncle’s (perpetuator’s) trial, was concurrently reported and sensationalized. a. What is the ethical issue or dilemma? The ethical issue presented in the article encompassed violations of privacy, giving informed consent, competencies of children, environmental and social context, among others. Privacy issues have been clearly defined by the reporter’s lawyers, especially in cases involving juveniles who have allegedly committed some criminal offense but has not been charged as of the date of scheduled report. In addition, there were policies against naming sexual abuse victims to protect the identity and absolve them from social stigma. The ethical issue of getting consent from adults, not from the children, was likewise violated by the reported. The subject of seeking consent proves to be controversial in terms of who the journalists should seek consent from in addition to the children themselves, the subject of competence is more debatable due to the age by which competence in children is agreed on. In this case, despite the apparent intent of Jody to seek the presence and consent from his stepfather, the reported disregarded the ethical obligation to seek consent from the adult and proceeded on interviewing Jody alone. Competence was clearly depicted by Alderson (1995) as having 3 characteristics: understanding, wisdom, and freedom. At the age of 14, Jody is still considered a juvenile and as such, competence is still compromised. Ethical issues of the environment and society were eminent through the pressures and actions manifested by neighbors, to wit: “eggs already had been tossed at his home and at a van he was riding in” (Paxson, 2011, par. 17). Also comments from Jody’s neighbors have supposedly attested to the boy’s violent and aggressive behavior; seemingly rationalizing and justifying the reporter’s intention to publish his identity. What choices did the journalist have when reporting on the issue, and why did he or she decide the way he or she did? ...Show more

Summary

Ethical Dilemma Addressed by a Professional Journalist Date Abstract The paper aims to analyze an ethical dilemma that has been addressed by a professional journalist. A report to be analyzed should be selected from the Indiana University School of Journalism website…
Author : wklein
Analysis of ethical dilemma that has been addressed by a professional journalist essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Analysis of ethical dilemma that has been addressed by a professional journalist"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Do Ethical Theories Help Journalists do Their Job
As such, ethical theories become more relevant especially in this age when things that society values seem to contradict each other. For example, society clamours for truthful information but truthful information may be harmful to peace and order (Gilbert, 1992, p.
12 pages (3000 words) Essay
Analysis of an Ethical Dilemma
The paper will seek to find out the best way for the group and its management to solve the dilemma issues, and plan for future occurrence. This paper will also analyze specific dilemmas in virgin group, the forces behind the dilemma and the group code of conduct.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Ethical dilemma

The researcher states that ethical dilemma requires us to weigh our responsibilities, responsibilities to parents, children, our colleagues. The professional knowledge has a vital role in resolving an ethical dilemma.  It is very important that we, as educators understand that the Code of Ethics is only useful if it is part of our every practice.

7 pages (750 words) Essay
Analysis of an Ethical Dilemma
The midwife who had already examined her and was satisfied with her overall health condition, immediately offered her services for a sweep and told her how expert she was at doing this procedure. Since the client was not willing to undergo IOL, the option of a sweep appeared attractive.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Analysis of an ethical dilemma
Several sectors clamored and demanded for immediate punishment like contract termination even before the court verdict is released. The companies or organizations holding the contracts are putting off the
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Ethical Dilemma Analysis- Capstone Project
The field being studied is nursing. One of this author’s neighbors is an elderly woman living in squalor by herself. Her house is dank, full of cobwebs and garbage. Additionally, this woman has to crawl out of the house because she cannot get out of it any other way;
3 pages (750 words) Essay
A written analysis of the ethical dilemma
urse of life so diverse that it has really become tough, both at scholarly and individual level, to determine a proper guideline for what is moral or ethical and what is against such approaches. Reflection of this dilemma is also largely reflected in professional arena,
12 pages (3000 words) Essay
Analysis of an Ethical Dilemma
This paper will also analyze specific dilemmas in virgin group, the forces behind the dilemma and the group code of conduct. It will further establish the
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Analysis of an Ethical Dilemma (Part Two)
Mary Gonzalez, who works in a non profit making organization as a social security person thinks that there is no moral justification, whether in
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Analysis of an Ethical dilemma part #3
However, the dilemma is the extent that a patient can practice autonomy, and whether nurses are obligated to assist in suicide. The American Nurses Association (2013) puts it clear that assisted euthanasia is against the nursing code of practice. As such,
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation