StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Systems of Power - Essay Example

Nobody downloaded yet

Extract of sample
Systems of Power

The opening scene of the movie provides a case study for one extreme form of listening – that in the operating room, which has definite needs and interesting power imbalances which stem from several distinct sources of responsibility and power which operate in the rom. A close examination of the opening scene of The Doctor can demonstrate an extreme setting and system of listening, which creates a significant power imbalance and could be rectified through small changes in environment and participation. One of the most commonly analyzed listening environments is the listener-focused on. This kind of listening environment focuses heavily on the listener’s perspective and opinion of the interaction (Brownell 40). This kind of environment features such things as school presentations, speeches, business presentations or marriage proposals. The opening scene of The Doctor features the polar opposite of this listening environment – rather than focusing on what the listener hears, this scene nearly entirely concentrates on what the speaker says significantly discounting other voices or perceptions. The opening scene takes place in an operating room, where there is essentially only one speaker who completely dominates the speaking and listening environment. The main surgeon controls everything about the environment – frequently changing what kind of ambient noise is occurring (telling others to turn music on and off, for instance) and communicating based solely on his own perceptions of need. The listeners in this environment are supposed to be completely passive in terms of communication, and simply react silently to orders barked by the main surgeon – in the only instance when someone tries to make him the listener, by telling him that he has a time limit, the doctor fails to respond, or acknowledge that he has heard what is being said. This pattern continues in doctor-everyone else relations throughout the entire course of the movie, and one of the most interesting aspects of the film is the shift the main character, Jack MacKee, experiences the shift from being solely a doctor to also being a patient with cancer. He experiences the degree to which doctors control all speaking and listening dynamics, often cutting him off, only listening to the amount that they think is necessary, and not taking his experience as a listener into account. The doctor’s insistence on creating such a speaker-focused listening environment has significant consequences to the power dynamics that occur in the operating room. He alternates between barking orders that will presumably save someone’s life and giving unwanted advances to one of the nurses, Nancy, who must, because of the power dynamic in the room, and the seriousness of the system, listen to each with equal weight, but respond to neither verbally. The surgeon’s choice to control the ambient noise level in the room creates an even more stark power dynamic. Though he is not expected to be able to hear or listen above the noise, being the only person in the room who is not a listener, he sets the ambient noise level which controls the amount of focus that the listeners have to use in order to do their job properly. This creates an uncomfortable ...Show more

Summary

Systems of Power, Expertise and Their Relation to Listening in The 1991 Film The Doctor As described in Listening: Attitudes, Principles and Skills by Judi Brownell, there are many forms and methods of listening, and the expectations of both the speaker and the listener are vastly different depending upon systemic elements that influence the course of the speaking and the listening…
Author : oleta81
Systems of Power Essay essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Systems of Power Essay"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Historical Systems of Power, Governance, and Authority
Most recently it got freedom from the clutches of colonial rule of British Empire. Officially British Empire started ruling on India from 1857 and the rule came to an end in 1947. British ruled gave English language, modern Science, Industry, Railway, Political Parties and Voting system to India.
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Role of Internation Systems, Particularly the Balance of Power during the Cold War
Balancing of power has been proposed to be one of the driving factors in the patterns of war and peace that have occurred worldwide throughout history1. The established international system considers the world to consist of independent nation states, each of which has the power to enforce rules and policies within its own borders.
12 pages (3000 words) Essay
Power of Media Essay
By allowing our society to partake more and more in various activities that allow us to participate in what were formerly individualized tasks, we are reshaping the way we think and express ourselves as a society. The modern social networking sites such as Twitter and Facebook, photo sharing sites like Picasa and photobucket, even blogs such as Wordpress and Tumblr are all examples of how the power of media has developed into a convergence culture that allows individual actions to converge or join together at a certain point in order to create a unified thought or expression for the individual or group of people These websites that allow us to practice our freedom of expression publicly and
5 pages (1250 words) Essay
Legal systems Essay
Secular laws on the other hand are made by the people in effect and regards to the changing world order, views and accepted ideologies. Religious laws define the faith of the people telling them what to believe as well as how to behave so that our actions do not violate the fundamental beliefs legislated by the religious laws whereas secular laws deals with individuals' external actions as they effect others.
12 pages (3000 words) Essay
Power and Politics Essay
In Michael's situation he depends upon the remarks upon him. The so-called "over-believing" to his self or the "confidence" that he can be the one who qualifies to take Lucien's position in the company. Michael's colleagues demonstrate an illegitimate political behavior.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Managing Information Systems Essay
These environmental changes have placed demands on there IS departments to support product innovation, new production techniques and changing organizational designs and to provide timely, high-quality information. Identifying and handling key issues in the management of IS is essential for executives to support and run their organizations efficiently and effectively.
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Write an essay in which you analyze the ways in which dominant systems of power manifest themselves in one or two texts from the book Dogeaters, how characters manage to reject their normalizing impulses and carve out non-normative safe spaces
If the imperialist patriarchy vindicated its colonizing attempts by expounding the conquered as the dissimilar, mediocre and alien other, jingoism engages a
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Us history-Historical systems of power, goverance, and authority & Revolutionary change
g this period, the African continent faced an enormous European imperialist aggression, diplomatic strains, military assaults, and the eventual takeover and colonization. During the same period, the African societies had to put up various forms of struggle against the attempt to
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Electrical Power Systems
Impedance is seen to increase in a linearly when we generate a graph of impedance versus frequency. The impedance at very low voltage access points
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Essay on Power
Among the sources of power in accordance with the theory is dialogue, building on understanding, experience and reception of cognitive learning. In accordance with transformational learning theory, the focus of power is on an
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation