Subsidiarity and EU Law - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Subsidiarity and EU Law

The role of the judiciary and the future of the ECJ were not given prominence in the workings of the European Convention. This is further borne out by the fact that in outlining the responses of the Constitutional Convention to the Laeken declaration, the preface to Parts I and II of the draft Constitution states that the Constitution "establishes the necessary measures to improve the structure and enhance the role of each of the Union's three institutions, taking account, in particular, of the consequences of enlargement". The reason for this omission of any reference to the ECJ is that the Laeken declaration identified themes and challenges which were mainly political in nature and, consequently the focus was on the political institutions of the EU. In addition, the workings of the ECJ and the future of its judicial architecture had been extensively considered in the Treaty of Nice. Hence, it was thought to be unnecessary to consider these issues once again.
Jurisdictionally, the ECJ's role is limited to providing clarification to EU Law, referred to it by the National Courts. ...
Download paper


Article 1-11(1) of the UK Constitution establishes the principles of subsidiarity or the principle that the EU will interfere on the failure of a Member State to achieve the intended objective and the principle of proportionality of the principle that limits the content and form of the EU's action to what is essential to achieve the Commission's objectives…
Author : lroob



Related Essays

EU Law
It was held in Marshall v Southampton and South West Hampshire Health Authority that an anti-discrimination Directive that had not been implemented by the UK despite the expiration of time for doing so, could not be used against private parties. The ECJ’s decision was based on the rationale that Article 249 of the EC Treaty specifically stated that Directives were binding on the states to which they were addressed.3 The only real possibility for pursuing claims against private parties in cases where damages are sustained and claim would have arisen under an unimplemented directive is in...
10 pages (2510 words) Coursework
Direct effect in the EU Law
This paper shall discuss the development of the doctrine of direct effect, the issues arising therefrom, and how the European Court of Justice resolved them. Moreover, it shall examine the dynamics in the relationship between the EU and the member-states and their individual citizens. Finally, it shall look into how the courts settle issues with regard to conflict arising from the implementation or non-implementation of EU laws and directives.
10 pages (2510 words) Essay
European Law essay
It is agreeable that legal cooperation and integration is the most important premise for political and economic integration. There should be horizontal and vertical legal cooperation and integration; that is, among member states themselves, as well as between the Union and its member states. This means that such integration should be in such a way that, despite the fusion of legal processes, each state do not lose their individual legal characteristics.1 It is in the light of this that a question arises of how supreme law can be established while each state still maintains their inherent laws....
8 pages (2008 words) Essay
EU LAW /Free Movement of Goods
member state. This paper examines rights of the IP holders and buyers trading in the EU and various principles involved in the light of IPR protection a holder is entitled to as a reward for dedication of his resources and efforts towards development of his product with quality. Internal market Article 14 of the EC treaty seeks to create an Internal Market without internal borders so as to facilitate free movement of goods, persons, service and capital known as “four freedoms:. The European Court of Justice (ECJ) has been consistently nullifying all national laws and practices of member...
8 pages (2008 words) Assignment
This implies that there was the evolution of certain relevant legal principles from a national level to conform with European Union laws and systems.
6 pages (1506 words) Term Paper
Subsidiarity in the EU and Federalism
tem of governance with substate/s autonomously operating in a decentralized manner and yet still connected to central government in a collaborative governance. From the historical vantage, the principle of subsidiarity was first introduced by the Treaty of Maastricht, also known as Treaty of European Union (TEU) signed at Maastricht town in 1991, with its elaborate applications explicated through the protocol stipulated in the Treaty of Amsterdam (Eurofound, 2010a). This was perceived to be the turning point of EU integration (Eurofound, 2010a). This paper aims to discuss the theory of...
10 pages (2510 words) Thesis
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!