The Government Should Enact Laws to Regulate Cloning - Essay Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
The Government Should Enact Laws to Regulate Cloning

John Stuart Mill, the nineteenth-century English utilitarian, believed that laws and social policies should be devised to prevent harm to innocent third parties. His starting point was that people ought to be left free to do whatever they like, as long as they do not harm others by their actions. If competent individuals want to hurt themselves, or agree to be hurt by others, their actions should not be restricted in the name of 'their own best interest', or in the name of 'rationality', or 'morality.' If they do not harm others, their liberty should not be interfered with. (Mill p. 13) Mill recognized that people could be harmed psychologically as well as physically, and indirectly as well as directly, but for legal purposes, he argued for a narrow understanding of harm. Since people can be irrationally offended by other people's doings, and since it is difficult to assess the long-term consequences of our actions, he thought that only the concrete and relatively immediate infliction of harm should be publicly regulated. (Mill pp. 14-15) The Millian view on liberty and harm gives rise to three norms as regards human reproductive cloning:
Other 'outcome-oriented' ethicists have, however, thought that Mill's ...
Download paper


There are many ethically interesting forms of human cloning, and not all of them are reproductive. These include: 1) the splitting of early human embryos for pre-implantation genetic tests (this is not usually thought of as cloning at all). 2) The production (that is, the isolation and in vitro multiplication) of human stem cells, which may have the ability to develop into full-fledged human beings (this is sometimes but not always associated with cloning in other senses)…
Author : alexisblanda

Related Essays

Imaginary Laws
Attempts by the government to change the provisions and practicality of the Trail Jury Amendment Act 1985, saw the adoption of the Amendment Act 2011. This Act became effective through approval and voting by 55% of the majority of the House of Commons. In seeking approval by the House of Lords, the Amendments Act 2011 only received a majority vote to the tune of 52%. From the above analysis, I will advise Berne to pursue with the purpose of disputing and questioning the validity of Amendment Act 2011 in determining the case. The grounds for this kind of advice shall base on the fact that this…
5 pages (1255 words) Essay
to regulate or not to regulate the Internet
Many politicians and businesses have also embraced the internet in order to sell a better image of themselves to the public. Politicians use the internet for their campaigns because it has many users and these will be able to access the message easily, which the politicians are trying to pass across. Businesses on the other hand are using the internet not only for advertising their products but also for transactions between them and their customers. However, despite the good that the internet has brought, there are also some very malicious activities that go on within it, which have raised a…
5 pages (1255 words) Research Paper
The United States government should ban gun control laws
Watson (2005) argue that the gun politics have become a significant issue whereby many political leaders have come up with ideologies relating to possessing guns through illegal and non-illegal use. They address this issue basing on the safety of the state, but the gun politics deals with the issue of regulations, personal possessing of firearms and restriction of using guns. The issues of gun control have become the foremost debate in the United States. This is because the proponents argue that owning guns will contribute to widespread danger whereas the opponents argue that it is one of the…
5 pages (1255 words) Research Paper
Labour Laws
This is certainly the case with Key Lime Printing. There is a feeling on the part of the workers that they are at best getting a very bad deal from a company that has already been in business for a relatively long time and should be able to do better. As a lawyer, there are a few issues that I shall seek to reinforce. I shall seek to inform the client, Joe Blow, that there is little legal recourse once the matter gets to this point. After all, the Notice of Certification from the labor relations board has already been received. There are three main issues that seem to underline the…
4 pages (1004 words) Essay
Majority opinion: Cloning case
Smith can challenge the constitutionality of the laws, since they contravene basic constitutional provisions as well as fundamental human rights. To begin with, the law unduly interferes with the right to scientific inquiry. Although this right is not expressly provided under the constitution, it draws support from personal liberty rights under the Fourteenth Amendment as well as the right to free speech captured in the First Amendment. Scientific inquiry has been an enduring value in the American society. In Meyer v Nebraska 262 (1923) U.S. 390 the court stated that the right to liberty…
3 pages (753 words) Essay
Sports Laws
The question of whether a club is or is not private is usually left for courts to decide. The courts analyze elements like 'history of club' to check if the club was designed to be selective in membership. Usually the key points that courts take into consideration is 'exclusiveness of club in the selection of new members' and 'the use of club facilities by non members. However, according to a recent report, Golf clubs and other private members' establishments will no longer be able to ban women members from their bars or discriminate in any other way on gender grounds. Equality bill is all set…
4 pages (1004 words) Case Study
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!