A review of the Quashing Convictions Report - Book Report/Review Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
A review of the Quashing Convictions Report

The idea that the Justice System should be skewed towards the law-abiding public rather than towards the criminals, or that it should be balanced between the two ignores the basic reason for rules of procedure and evidence being in place. The State takes on an awesome (and easily abused) power when it takes away the liberty of a man or woman. Imprisonment takes time away from a person’s life that can never be restored. Thus the scales of justice should provide every possible safeguard for the accused because the stakes are so high and mistakes are so consequential for him if he is found guilty. If, as the government appears to be doing, the rules of evidence are being “rewritten” or simply ignored to enable the state to imprison people it “knows” to be guilty, then the UK is on a slippery slope indeed. ...
Download paper


This review will argue that neither premise is in fact tenable, and further, that the Report exhibits an overall dangerous tendency through suggesting that the Criminal Justice System “should” be balanced in favor of either side. The scales of justice should be equal and balanced…
Author : turcotteamerico

Related Essays

Criminal Justice Management and Administration
The intention of this study is criminal justice management as the supervision and oversight of the system that is mandated to serve justice to criminal cases. The criminal justice system includes line officers, court officials, investigation officers, parole officials, investigators and administrators. In the administration, the criminal justice system is also designed in unique managerial positions. These positions range from a police chiefs to national intelligence bodies. It is structured in such a manner that information flow is facilitated to move freely and with a definite course of...
13 pages (3263 words) Research Paper
Criminal justice system
This paper describes the criminal justice system and its importance. The paper concludes with a brief summary of the main content as well as the perception of the author in respect to the topic. Undeniably, the criminal justice system is a broad area. The following is a discussion of importance of studying criminal justice system as well as the comparison between United States of America’s criminal justice system and the international criminal justice system.
3 pages (753 words) Research Paper
Criminal Justice System
This research will begin with the explanation of what the crime is. Crime is the violation of laws or rules set by a governing authority through legal systems. Ultimately, such an action might amount to conviction. Crime might also culminate at penalties (financial or corporeal), caution, expulsion, extradition, isolation, or community services and rehabilitation. However, different countries would define crime differently at the local, provincial, federal, and/or international levels. Crime is dealt with under the sphere of criminology, which is in principle a non-normative, empirical, and...
3 pages (753 words) Essay
Criminal Justice System
The criminal justice system in America is comprised of different components that work together to maintain justice in the society. The main aim is to provide justice to criminals, victims of crimes and to bring law violators in a fair trial through upright and legitimate system (U.S Government, 1967). U.S criminal justice system is unique in its own way. According to this system, a person under trail remains innocent till the time he is proven guilty. As a result, criminals or offenders hold the right to defend themselves under fair and regular trial. U.S criminal justice system ensures that...
5 pages (1255 words) Research Paper
The Legal Framework for Criminal Investigations and the Relationship with the Criminal Justice System
This speaks itself about the importance of tough criminal investigation procedures. In order to collect reliable and secure evidence, the investigators must put in concrete efforts so that the person found guilty should be punished in accordance with law. Therefore, for a criminal prosecution to become successful, it is extremely important that the Crown Prosecution Services should provide solid and reliable evidence to the court of law to punish the culprits. “In a number of countries where democratic set up exists and where rule of law succeed, the burden of proof lies on the shoulder of...
6 pages (1506 words) Essay
Unfair Treatment of Minorities in the Criminal Justice System
Unfair Treatment of Minorities in the Criminal Justice System
10 pages (2510 words) Essay
Law report case review
Judge Gordon J sites from Adam v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2003) 46 ACSR 68, that Mr. Schwartz needs to show sufficient evidence that he can honestly perform the duties as the director of the corporation with regards to the publics best interest. From the evidence presented to the Judge, his decision was that Mr. Schwartz did not present evidence as to who Babybelle deals with and why Mr. Schwartz was the only person able to serve in the director position. It is the recommendation of Judge Gordon that Mr. Schwartz’s application be dismissed. The Judge also concluded...
1 pages (251 words) Case Study
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!