StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Evidence - Book Report/Review Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Evidence

This book's first chapter covers the principles of criminal evidence, procedure, criminal justice and Human Rights. It brings out five foundational principles of criminal evidence, the rules and discretion. It connects the evidence to the Human Rights Act, constitutional criminal procedure etc. it is a critical commentary on regulating principles and admission rules in the context of broader criminal justice.
It is argued that the principles are not readily available to suit all the circumstances and situations. "Principles of the Law of Evidence are not ready-made and awaiting collection; rather, they have to be reconstructed from the relevant institutional materials," Roberts and Zuckerman (2004, p.5). Evidence is the legal fact-finding exercise and there are many determining facts in legal procedures. It is usually applicable to civil and criminal proceedings although it need not be so always.
In a civil litigation, it is confined to the parties' right to access the evidence. This does not mean that there is nothing in common between civil and criminal law procedures; but the theoretical and practical differences cannot be ignored.
Criminal procedure and criminal justice have unique requirements and evidence answers most of it. It is the work of the State to make offenders suffer for their crime, and the punishment should have its own message. "Any account of criminal punishment would be seriously incomplete without reference to the message of blame with penal hard treatment is meant to convey," (pp.12-13). Retributive punishment is considered to be more appropriate than other kinds and this issue resurrects the rectitude and integrity of the administration with proper legal rights given to the defendant. "Amongst the most prominent corrective mechanisms is the presumption of innocence, reinforced by the privilege against self-incrimination," (p.15). The public confidence that the administration of criminal justice invokes is very important for the state and people both and despite a public trial being extremely painful for the involved parties; it is preferred as there is no other authoritative validation of justice and rules of evidence too contribute to the public confidence. State's work is not only providing ample protection to the citizens, but also to punish the offenders, so 'effective conviction of the guilty and solicitous protection of the innocent' both are equally demanded from the State. It is not easy to forget that the criminals are usually another face of the society and reflect the society's rot.

The five principles of criminal evidence are:

1. A quest for accurate fact finding through evidence.
2. Pro-innocence bias.
3. Minimum intervention
4. Humane treatment
5. Upholding standards of propriety in criminal proceedings.

The rules, principles and discretions are stretched beyond limit in some modern cases today, as they are grounded in the modern society and it is difficult for the law to foresee all the circumstances. Hearsay evidence is, for example, considered to be inadmissible. But sometimes there are peculiar circumstances that might make it admissible, because peculiar circumstances might crop up later. It is the same again in admissibility of illegally obtained evidence. There could be confusion even in discretion. "To fully appreciate the role of discretionary standards in the ...Show more

Summary

Criminal evidence by Roberts and Zuckerman is regarded as an original and authoritative contribution to the law of evidence, covering presumption of innocence, privilege against self-incrimination, hearsay, character and corroboration1. This book shows how important evidence is in a criminal case and how eloquently the cases hinge on the evidence…
Author : lelah68
Evidence Book Report/Review essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the book report/review on your topic
"Evidence Book Report/Review"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Book review
She was also hospitalized several times at different locations around the city of New York. The reporter monitored Sylvia Frumkin for almost a year by speaking with her, attending upon her, monitoring her situation, consulting with her physicians and even observing her throughout her sleep in a mental hospital.
7 pages (1750 words) Book Report/Review
Summary Book Report/Review
Perhaps it is the unsurpassed drama and focus on such opinionated viewpoints and events that surround a presidential election that captures the interest of almost every American. The theory of the predictable campaign is discussed in Chapter 2. Presidential campaign courses are predictable, according to this chapter.
3 pages (750 words) Book Report/Review
Criminology Book Report/Review
There are mainly three types different theories proposed to explain crime and criminal behavior each have there own limitation and explanations. (1) The main theme of Demonic perspective is that crime was caused largely by demonic influence. Although the "devil made me do it" is certainly an explanation of criminal behavior, it is not a scientific theory.
3 pages (750 words) Book Report/Review
Marketing Book Report/Review
The second strategy is an unconscious one in which a decision is reached very quickly and usually without any awareness that a decision was even made. The second type are more popularly referred to as either gut decisions or hunches and it is the expansion and dependability of them that Malcolm Gladwell addresses in his book Blink.
10 pages (2500 words) Book Report/Review
Global Warming Book Report/Review
Climate change is increasingly framed as an issue where the threats are severe, increasingly imminent and potentially catastrophic. If the worst predictions of scientists prove to be accurate, then no one will be able to escape the consequences of climate change.
125 pages (31250 words) Book Report/Review
HISTORY College Book Report/Review
appears to illumine the darkest side of American politics. Recent glimpses into the outrageous lying of the bureaucratic upper echelons makes it clear that abusing power and deluding the public have become the order in most recent administrations. Albuquerque Tribune reporter Eileen Welsome, who won the Pulitzer Prize for national reporting on April 12, 1994, uncovered most of what the public knows about the plutonium experiments.
4 pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review
Counterterrorism Book Report/Review
What implications for counterterrorism are contained in that training manual If you were to develop a counterterrorism strategy, what might a piece (or pieces) of that strategy be in light of the manual The discovery of the 180 pages long Al Qaeda manual which was seized from the Manchester ,England home of a bin Laden disciple, was a shocking moment for Britain and new dilemma for the counterterrorism forces and think tanks of Britain.
5 pages (1250 words) Book Report/Review
Ethnography Book Report/Review
It is typically used in the study of small communities, gangs, total institutions, informal groups and other small scale settings. The research techniques employed include informal interviewing of participants and of informants (selected individuals who provide detailed interpretations of the setting being observed), participation of the researcher in the activities being studied, and observation of key events in the life of the collectivity.
10 pages (2500 words) Book Report/Review
BOOK REVIEW
Within the Jewish apocalyptcism responses moved in tandem with the prevailing religious and political conditions. The aim of the book, according to the author, is not to join issues with any other studied and researched work published before.
5 pages (1250 words) Book Report/Review
Book report
It may be a compilation of essays, but it reads congruently and flows comprehensively from one to another and targets more of an adult and political readership than an academic one. The book examines president George
2 pages (500 words) Book Report/Review
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation