StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Professional Negligence - Case Study Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Professional Negligence

2. Mr. David Johnson went to Eye Right Clinic on August 5, 2003 to enquire about the possibility of undergoing Lasik Eye Surgery to correct his nearsightedness. He was attended to by DI. He underwent to treatment to his right eye but was told that the operation was only partially unsuccessful. On August 12, he returned once more, but was again told that the operation was only partially successful. On August 19, he returned for treatment on his left eye, and this yielded completely satisfactory results. Additional treatment on his left eye was conducted on September 29. This operation was done both by DI and DB. It was during this visit that complications arose. Mr. David Johnson was informed that there was a problem as his cornea has been penetrated. In a subsequent examination by DI, he was told that his corneal flap had been damaged and that a corneal graft was probably necessary. He was referred to Dr. Singh (GS) at the Grafton Hospital in Oxford.
3. Mr. David Johnson has had several operations and procedures to correct the damage to the cornea, beginning with the stitching the damaged corneal flap on September 30, 2003 and culminating in a corneal graft on September 24, 2004. The sight on the right eye is still problematic. He is on the NHS waiting list to have a contact lens implant. After the operation at Eye Right, he experienced pain due to "dry" eye, reduced and disturbed sight and very poor night vision. Until the corneal graft, he could not drive. His vision was unbalanced as his left eye was normal. He became solely dependent on his family. He became prone to headaches and fatigue and was unable to work for 6 months, although he received sick leave pay. He has since returned to his job as librarian, earning 32,575 p.a. (net). He still requires constant application of eye lubricant to counteract the dry eye syndrome, I.e., one NHS prescription per month. He must wear special glasses costing 195.00 and dark glasses in the sun costing 105.00.

4. According to GS, an expert in the field of ophthalmology, during the September 29 operation, the laser perforated the cornea such that there was egress of fluid through the small hole in the central part of the cornea and it was impossible for the flap to be repositioned. The LASIK flap was found by him to be oedematous and floating free with a low intraocular pressure and a visual acuity of counting fingers. Further, GS said that after Mr. Thompson had resuturing of the LASIK flap, and this had a chance to settle down, it was found that the cornea was extremely thin and ectatic, bulging forwards and with a huge degree of astigmatism. The only way to correct this was to replace the cornea with a penetrating keratoplasty which was done on September 24, 2004. The corneal sutures were then removed on December 12, 2005 and he is due to be reviewed again in the future.

5. GS found that there were two possible reasons for the laser penetrating the cornea. The first is that the bed of the cornea was so thin (and had been made thinner by the initial treatment) that the very small amount of additional treatment to what was already a very thin cornea caused the perforation. The second ...Show more

Summary

1. I am asked to advise Mr. David Johnson in the matter of a claim for clinical negligence made against Eyes Right as well as Dr. Donald Ivy (DI) and Dr. Benjamin (DB). Mr. David Johnson sustained damage to his corneal flap as a result of a Lasik Eye Surgery performed by Drs…
Author : ankundingaurore
Professional Negligence essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the case study on your topic
"Professional Negligence"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Negligence and tort law in the healthcare field
Negligence and Tort Law in the Healthcare Field Tort Law deals with the cases of civil wrong which encompasses all the illegal activities. Negligence on the other hand is a violation from legal duty of accepting and paying the damage to the victim who is claiming it.
3 pages (750 words) Case Study
Business and law
This is because the written law that provides for the application of the principles of common law and equity in these the countries does not expressly state that these principles are in force. 1It however provides that the High Court or the Supreme Court, and the Magistrates Courts exercise their jurisdiction in accordance with these principles, but subject to such modifications as local circumstances render necessary.
14 pages (3500 words) Case Study
Medical negligence litigation
(Garfield, vii) The type of litigation is predominately damages for professional negligence. Consent to treatment is important, as there is a "legal presumption that every adult has the mental capacity to consent to treatment" (Garfield, 3), which means they have the ability to understand sufficiently the nature, purpose and effects of the treatment proposed and to "make and communicate a decision on the matter in question".
7 pages (1750 words) Case Study
Doctor Negligence
However, the man suffered heart attack the next morning. The doctor failed to check the man's blood and its behavior. Most probably, there was clotting of blood in and around the man's heart. The doctor did not check other probable causes of heart attacks.
2 pages (500 words) Case Study
Memorandum of Law
Rocky (the "doctor") for professional negligence; and (4) the hospital under the principle of vicarious liability. Driver's Duty of Care and Breach. In Nettleship v. Weston1, citing Glasgow Corporation v. Muir2 it was ruled that "if a driver goes off the road on to the pavement and injures a pedestrian, or damages property, he is prima facie liable.
8 pages (2000 words) Case Study
Medical Negligence
It has been held that to judge a person by his conduct in relation to another is guided by the conduct of a man on top of a Clapham omnibus. However, if a situation involves the employment of some special skill then the test to be used in judging that conduct is the standard of the ordinary skilled man exercising and professing to have that special skill.
8 pages (2000 words) Case Study
Medical Negligence and Malpractice
Contrary to the will of Benny, Douglas obtains consent from Benny's parents to allow him to remove Benny's gallstone. At the operating room, Douglas removed Benny's gallstone without his personal consent. According to Bhat (2001), marketplace professionalism is a major factor for the advent of malpractice litigation.
12 pages (3000 words) Case Study
Negligence
In investigating the incident you, as Mary's attorney, obtain the personnel file of ABC relative to the manager who raped Mary. In reviewing this file you find that ABC hired the manager Rob without any kind of background check being performed. In addition, from questioning a high level manager at ABC, you determine that ABC Properties, Inc.
3 pages (750 words) Case Study
Negligence and tort law in the healthcare field
Negligence on the other hand is a violation from legal duty of accepting and paying the damage to the victim who is claiming it. As the name indicates, negligence occurs due to unusual and ignorant behavior of
3 pages (750 words) Case Study
Business Law, Aunty Ems Catering School Ltd
According to the scenario provided, Emilia, in the preceding month, received three letters instituting legal actions against the company that have been elaborated in detail with the incorporation of varied lawful guidelines or
8 pages (2000 words) Case Study
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation