Comparative Legal Systems

Masters
Essay
Law
Pages 12 (3012 words)
Download 0
All systems of justice are adversarial in nature. To what extent they are fair or just simply depend on the players, the judges and the set up of legal principles applied. There are opposing sides to any judicial proceeding which requires an overseer to maintain fair play in the process…

Introduction

In some cases the opponents in a case are allowed the opportunity to present their case to a jury. In other instances the opposing parties must rely on a judge only to decide the truthfulness of each side.
To understand the adversarial system of justice, one must notice the distinctions between the types of judicial systems in practice today. "Let us start with the classical distinction between adversarial and inquisitorial systems of criminal justice. The usual way of describing the former is as a contest between two equal parties, seeking to resolve a dispute before a passive and impartial judge, with a jury ('the people') pronouncing one version of events to be the truth." (Fennell, Harding, Jorg & Swart, 1995). Where there are two parties interested in the truthfulness of an issue, fairness may be compromised when the interests of either party are at stake. The adversarial process incorporates just that. "But this places inordinate faith in the notion that partisan manipulation of evidentiary materials, even under equality of arms, can put an independent judge in a position to determine truth--an assumption at best unproven, and at worst highly implausible. ...
Download paper
Not exactly what you need?

Related papers

Comparative Legal System Coursework
This came to be known as the Nuremberg Tribunal Prior to these, the concept of crimes against humanity was unheard-of, though it was perhaps the only apt way of describing the wholesale, systematic and systemic annihilation of Jews during the time of the Holoc.

You may also like:
English Coursework
COMPARATIVE LEGAL SYSTEMS( Coursework)
By adopting the French and Italian model, Guatemala has successfully designed its judicial system. The judicial reform has brought about segmentation as because often the civil laws in Guatemala have different interpretations. The fact that, the laws are based on different legal philosophies, account for this problem. On the whole, adoption of new reform has proved to be effective for controlling…
Comparative Legal System
During the early centuries, the judges and justices were responsible for adapting the Writ system to meet everyday needs, and the application of a mixture of common sense and precedent in order to create a body of internally consistent law. For example, the Law Merchant began in the Pie-Powder Courts (a corruption of the French "pieds-poudr's" or "dusty feet", meaning ad hoc marketplace courts).…
Legal systems Essay
In a religious legal system all the religious laws converge to one ultimate concept and that is religion. However in a secular legal system, by contrast, changes and amendments forms a necessary part of the process as the concept of the system is to continuously improve formal law and practices, and their influence on the tradition of life. People and state-welfare is given due importance and the…
UK Legal Methods and Legal Systems
h sides is it due to the nature of human conduct is it due to the ambiguity of virtual and responsibility is it due to flexibility of interpretation Is every deed somehow intrinsically subject to morally polar interpretations or is it due to the content of ours laws is it due to the ways that deeds, interpretations and interactConsquently what the thought experiment proves is that at least our…
Comparative Legal Systems
In some cases the opponents in a case are allowed the opportunity to present their case to a jury. In other instances the opposing parties must rely on a judge only to decide the truthfulness of each side.…
Legal Systems
On March 22, 2005 six men were acquitted from a fraud case costing 60 million. Considered to be one of Britain's longest and costliest fraud trials, it just collapsed after twenty-one months of court proceedings at London's Old Bailey.2…