StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Defining Law - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Defining Law

Undoubtedly, to be of use, most rules or systems of rules require a method of enforcement, whether the method be remedial in nature, such as a civil judgment, or a penal sanction imposed in a criminal matter. John Austin, a proponent of the social fact thesis of legal positivism, contends that the primary distinguishing feature of a legal system is whether its rules can be enforced (1995). Austin argues that a rule of law in society is legally valid if and only if that rule is commanded by the society's sovereign and is backed up with the threat of sanction, or enforcement (1995). As such, it is Austin's position that the essential element of a law is whether someone has the ability to sanction its noncompliance.
Austin's position seems tenable. Indeed, without enforcement, laws have no effect. To ensure compliance, and in the absence of any moral obligation to obey a law, an absence which we must presume, a law must impose a consequence for a violation. Even the rules that govern the application of law, such as rules of procedure, require some sort of sanction for a breach. A prominent philosopher of law, H.L.A. Hart, has suggested that Austin's position on enforcement is clear when applied to those laws that restrict our behavior, but is inapplicable to the set of rules that grant us the power to create rights and obligations, such as contracts and wills (1994). Even those rules, however, are "enforced" through sanction, to wit, the threat of litigation and the possibility of voiding, for example, a created document should it contain a flaw.
And the essence of such litigation, indeed the very root of its existence, is that law is subject to interpretation. Ronald Dworkin, a pillar of modern legal philosophy, believes that adjudication is and should be interpretive (1982). According to Dworkin, judges should look to the "political structure of their community" when deciding hard cases by, first, ensuring that their interpretation is in accordance with the community's existing legal practices, and, second, that the interpretation is presented in the best moral light (1982). As such, Dworkin posits that a law is specifically characterized by its language, the facts to which the law must be applied, and the best moral application of that law given the social practices of a particular community.
The idea that law is a set of rules subject to interpretation was also recognized by the legal realist movement. Inspired by John Chipman Gray and Oliver Wendall Holmes, and reaching its analytical peak in the 1920s and 1930s, legal realism contradicted legal formalism by asserting that judicial decision making is guided far more frequently by the political and moral insights of the judge rather than by legal rules (Himma, 2006). Legal formalism embraced the concept that a judge's decision, or holding, would always logically follow from the legal rule being applied to a particular set of facts, leaving little or no room for interpretation (Himma, 2006). The realist model asserts the opposite extreme, claiming that (1) any matters worth litigating are thereby divisive enough to require interpretation of the applicable rules, (2) judges make new law in exercising discretion when deciding legal disputes, and (3) when deciding ...Show more

Summary

The Oxford English Dictionary defines "law" as "a rule or system of rules recognized by a country or community as governing the actions of its members" (2001). Indeed, for centuries philosophers have attempted to define, prioritize and characterize the essential elements of law and functional legal systems, discussing such conceptualities as the nature of law and the relationship, if any, between law and morality…
Author : kennawillms
Defining Law essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Defining Law"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Defining terrorism
Some academicians and scientists underline that it is impossible to justify the essence of terrorism. In the very essence terrorism is unjust and illegitimate. Nevertheless, this assumption is rather emotional and it is relevant to consider this phenomenon from moral perspective. Thus, there is no moral background for the governments to sponsor terrorists, but they really do that.
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
Essay on Defining Abnormality
“Abnormality is conceived of as a cluster of behaviours” and role cultural social factors remain a significant issue in defining abnormality (Essau, & Petermann, 1997, p.448). Studies have underlined that abnormality or madness has some historical backdrops and it may be as old as mankind.
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
Current law defining land creates 'a world of pure ideas from which everything physical or
The Professor applies this concept to the property of land. It should be mentioned that a conceptualization of property is a complex and challenging process. There are many fragile concepts, which are often misinterpreted in terms of property ideas. Further on in this paper we will try to identify the concept of "property", relate it to land ownership and consider these issues in the existent legal paradigm of Britain and America.
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Defining Marriage
Certain nations as well as states of certain nations have made same gender marriages legal. Same sex marriages are not only a political, economic or religious issue, it is mainly an ethical issue which can be solved with ethical decision making tool of utilitarianism.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Defining Leadership
This however does not imply that the available definitions of leadership are either right or wrong, but rather each of the definitions attempts to expose a different facet on the meaning of leadership and how different leaders express their leadership traits.
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Defining Social work
The role of the social worker should be to help an individual move forward with their lives with dignity. According to the Department of Health, social workers: "…form partnerships with people: helping them to assess and interpret the
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Defining African Religion and Insiders and Outsiders
Most of the religious activities are defined by the use of rituals and celebrations. Rituals are an essential part of the lives of Africans in general. Most of the rights involve observing practices that are out of the extraordinary. The
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Current law defining land creates a world of pure ideas from which everything physical or
The Professor applies this concept to the property of land. It should be mentioned that a conceptualization of property is a complex and challenging process. There are many fragile concepts,
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
Defining and Assessing Modern CSR
Entities, especially Oil Sands Development Corporation, must comply with Canada’s prescribed corporate social responsibility requirements. Corporate social responsibility can be defined in several ways. The responsibility can be defined as how the
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Defining concept of design thinking
Simon’s 1969 publication The Sciences of Application and the 1973 publication Experiences in Visual Thinking by Robert McKim. This paper will explore the concept and definition of design thinking. Design Thinking is regarded as a multidisciplinary,
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation