Tort Coursework Resit - Case Study Example

Only on StudentShare

Extract of sample
Tort Coursework Resit

Derek dismissed them. The Court of Appeal the decisions and reasons for the same were upheld. The court did not disturb the findings of fact as the same were admitted. The importance of the decision lies in the court's statement of principle may be stated as the coastguards were under no enforceable private law duty of care to respond to an emergency call and under no duty of care.
Although the issue is expressed in this general way, the specific right in question in these appeals, is whether an action for breach of legal duty to take care while performing duties by coastguard can be brought against the Secretary who is responsible for Coastguard.
law as to what is the duty to take care. Professor Sir Percy Winfield (1933) (1) defined a tort as 'the breach of a duty primarily fixed by the law, where the duty is one towards persons generally and its breach is redressible by an action for damages.' This necessarily implies that to succeed in an action the plaintiff must prove that
In the absence of such legal duty negligence has no legal consequence. In Brett M.R. in Heaven v. Pender (2) it was established that under certain circumstances, one man may owe a duty to another, even though there is no privity of contract between them. Dicta of Brett M.R. in Heaven v. Pender as considered in 1932 by Lord Atkins J. in Donoghue v. Stevenson (3) laid down a very important principle of determining a duty. He held that
"The liability for negligence, whet ...
Download paper


Facts of the case are that the plaintiff had summoned the services of the rescue operations of the coastguards while stuck in rough weathers. He was rescued by the coastguards but due to delay in rescue operations, he suffered hypothermia, frostbite and shock…
Author : alanschmeler

Related Essays

Tort Law
In essence, tort law is applicable in circumstances where an individual’s or a group’s negligence, carelessness, and/or failure to take precautionary actions results in other parties’ to incurring pain, losses, discomfort, harm, incapacitation and/or death3. Although they may cause losses and pain to their victims and their loved ones, it should be clear from the onset that not all tort cases are criminal acts. It is therefore imperative that the victim of another’s negligence or carelessness seeks compensation for the loss or pain suffered. In case a victim dies, his/her loved ones or...
8 pages (2008 words) Essay
With the introduction of retiring age, employers are now refrained from discriminating on the grounds of age, even at the time of recruitment, training, redundancy and other policies that deals with the employer and the employee’s relationship (Harris, et al 56). Harassment There is no specific law, which deals with the issue of harassment at workplace. However, an affected person can knock at the door of competent court of law to get his or her grievances redressed under the criminal law known as "Protection from Harassment Act”. In refined term, harassment in the workplace can be...
12 pages (3012 words) Essay
Tort Law
However, in the two cases, the complainant (the person harmed) has entitlement to compensation by the offender (accused). In the later, the acts that lead to such an injury or loss are not intentional or expected. Nevertheless, there are some torts, which involve accidents that would have been prevented with care and as such does not constitute torts of negligence. Normally negligence torts involve parties that share four elements including, where one party had the responsibility of protecting the other(S) and or the party fails to exercise such care as expected. Moreover, there exists a...
10 pages (2510 words) Essay
Normally, a tort may occur as a result of unintentional or intentional negligence by the defendant. The law provides a remedy for a civil wrong committed against the plaintiff whereby, the defendant may be required to pay legal damages in form of monetary compensation to the plaintiff. In some situations, the court may issue restrictive orders to the defendant to act as a punitive punishment for his/her tortious acts (Ashley, 2004). In the case of Robert Courtney, various aspects of a tort can be observed. For example, Hunter, a doctor at Kansas City who used to order Chemotherapy drugs from...
3 pages (753 words) Assignment
Tort Liabilities
Negligence is an example of unintentional torts. Most contemporary tort theory focuses on the legal consequences of accidents, where the relevant forms of liability are negligence and strict liability. (Theories of Tort, 2003)....
13 pages (3263 words) Case Study
Law And Contract Resit
In this case four issues arise and these are noise and vibrations disturbing Pub's customer, Bloggs & Co Builders used the student car park to the jib of a crane, construction vehicles are constantly blocking the entrance of Public house owner and they work continues on site Saturday and Sunday mornings as a result the pub manager was disturbed.Winfield and Jolowicz defence private nuisance as an unlawful interference with a person's use or enjoyment of land, or some right over, or in connection, with it. This principle is neatly encapsulated in the words of Lord Wright in Sedleigh-Denfield v...
5 pages (1255 words) Case Study
Got a tricky question? Receive an answer from students like you! Try us!