StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

United Kingdom's Tribunal System Reforms - Essay Example

Nobody downloaded yet

Extract of sample
United Kingdom's Tribunal System Reforms

The government’s White Paper 2004 implemented these reviews’ recommendations gave birth to the Administrative Justice and Tribunals Council that replaced the old body, Council of tribunal (White Paper 2004, p.8). In 2005, the government established the Tribunal’s service as an executive agency of the Department for Constitutional Affairs (DCA). Its function would be to accommodate the chief government run tribunals (Buck 2005, p.6). Following the appointment of Lord Justice Carwath as the first Senior President-designate of Tribunals, there was a publication of a Draft Bill in 2006. In November the same year, the House of Lords received the Tribunals, courts and Enforcement Bill (Buck 2006, pp 458-484) .
There were a number of reasons for the reforms. First and foremost was in relation to the availability of reported decisions. The tribunal users experienced a lot of delays before they received responses to their applications and appeals. For this reason, the House of Commons made an inquiry into the Social Security and Child Support Commissioners (2000, pp 6-15). Some jurisdictions lacked hard copy reports while others had poor electronic media submission of reports. Secondly, the method of selection of cases varied amongst the jurisdictions. Rather than depend on rational thinking to select cases, tribunals depended on their historical development and procedural rules. Third, tribunals developed a common law system instead of a case-law system. This reduced their flexibility in determining case. Moreover, it watered down the role of a tribunal which is to avoid a formal doctrine that would result in binding precedents (Farmer 1974, p.21). The tribunal system experienced real change after the creation of the Councils of Tribunals. In 2008, the Upper Tribunal and the First-tier Tribunal were created. These two tribunals replaced the abundance of tribunals that were there before. In addition to that, there was a harmonization of procedures. Consequently, this reduced cases of separate jurisdictions each with their own procedure and system. A total of 107 tribunals were transferred into these two. However, the Employment Tribunal and the Employment Appeal Tribunal maintained their jurisdictions (Industrial Law Journal 2009, p. 418). The tribunals are divided into chambers. Each chamber takes up a general title dealing with issues that relate to the title. In light of the above discussion, tribunals deal with a range of issues. One of the issues at hand is the government’s proposal to give tribunals the power to oversee euthanasia or assisted suicide. Regulation of euthanasia under criminal law remains to be a contentious issue in medical law. According to Smith, England’s law makers have remained adamant in charting a clear way to handle this issue (1996, p.335). As it stands right now, England’s courts and legislators are not willing to remove the objection to the practice of euthanasia. Criminal law considers any wrongful act that leads to the loss of life as homicide. The most common of such acts is murder which earns one life imprisonment. A deliberate act of ending a life is murder. Therefore, even if a doctor ends a life upon the patient’s request, the law classifies his act as that of murder. There are cases where doctors have been charged with murder where they performed euthanasia. Dr. John Bodkin Adams, administered painkillers (The Times 1981, p. 1, 12). However, the ...Show more


United Kingdom’s Tribunal System Reforms
Contemplation about tribunal reform in the United Kingdom began in 2006. Several legislations were prepared to contribute to the reform. Among these were the Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Bill 2007…
Author : shieldsrhiannon
United Kingdoms Tribunal System Reforms essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"United Kingdom's Tribunal System Reforms"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Check these samples - they also fit your topic

Reforms in the International Finance System
The article takes a deeper look at the financial crisis or great recession as probably the worst financial catastrophe after the Great Depression in the 1930s. The global financial crises typically led to the subsiding of many financial institutions all around the world, crumpling of stock and financial markets globally and bailouts of financial institutions by governments.
17 pages (4250 words) Essay
Employment tribunal
The establishment of the tribunals was aimed at offering accessible and cheap processes for resolving employment disputes with minimal legalistic constraints (Edge, 2008). Since the tribunals were established, however, there have been debates on how effective they have been in resolving employment disputes (Dickens and Neal, 2006).
2 pages (500 words) Essay
During the tenure of the Labour Party from 1997-2010, many constitutional reforms were introduced in UK. One criticism that has been bought against the Labour party’s reform agenda is that it was not well-synchronized and there were no definite set of guiding principles behind it but it is already clear, going by the impact of this change over the last decade that the British democracy has changed for good.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
United Kingdom Reforms
United Kingdom Reforms The act is relevant to contracts where ownership of goods transferred or agreed to be transferred has been paid. The queen enacted the 1995 Act after consent from the House of Commons, to fill gaping loopholes in the Sales of Goods Act 1979, which failed to protect buyers in a situation where a supplier was bankrupt.
14 pages (3500 words) Essay
Healthcare Reforms in the United States
As of the latest healthcare reform in 2010, the US healthcare policy makers were able to successfully pass the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act by lobbying within the House of Representatives to approve a series of healthcare bills. The discussion outcomes of the Democrats and Republicans became the basis of the Senate’s healthcare.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
How much of the United Kingdom's energy needs could be covered by renewable energy sources in 25 years
UK import oil, gas and coal from overseas, which creates vulnerability incase of fluctuations in global prices, as well as issues with cross-border supply because of too much reliance on the import. As a result, the focus is moving towards increasing renewable energy reserves and limiting reliance on fossil fuels.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
United States tax system
The government will always try to justify the tax collection process with several types of benefits to the society or its population in general on in individual basis.At one point or another,the question whether or not this process is necessary as it is or its size needs to be reduced,in other words,is there a need of a tax cut,and what are their benefits,if any
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
United Kingdoms Welfare System
However, unlike any other European Union nations, the United Kingdom is said to be different in such a way that Margaret Thatcher and the Conservative Party after 1979 had left a considerable imprint on the British welfare system. Thatcher and the Conservative Party had made a tremendous impact in the political party in the United Kingdom making it more unique than the other UE nations.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Compare the U.S. Criminal Justice System to United Kingdom's (Britain) Criminal Justice System
Also included will be some basic comparisons between the elements of crimes in both jurisdictions. In the end, however, the systems are very similar, and the differences between the systems of each country are subtle.
9 pages (2250 words) Research Paper
The Khmer Rouge Tribunal
Even though the Khmer Rouge incident occurred in the 1970s, the criminals are being presented with charges now. The main reason it took so long for the perpetrators to be brought to trial was that the country, even after the Khmer Rouge prosecutors fled the country, was facing internal political issues.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Hire a pro to write
a paper under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
Contact Us