Political Dialogue between Hitler and Stalin - Essay Example

Thesis statement: The imaginary political dialogue between Adolf Hitler and Joseph Stalin prove that Nazi and communist worldviews on key political issues are theoretically correct but practically disastrous. The Nazi and Communist worldviews on key political issues The Nazi ideology was based upon racial purity, Aryan domination and hatred against the Jews. James Giblin “There are no memorials to Adolph Hitler in Germany, the country he ruled with an iron hand from 1933 to 1945” (1). At the same time, this ideology was deeply influenced by Friedrich Nietzsche’s philosophy.

On the other side, the Russian Communism was deeply influenced by Marxism which originated in Germany. At the same time the practical side of both these political ideologies (say, under dictators) proved to be disastrous. The imaginary political dialogue between Adolph Hitler and Joseph Stalin proves the same. A. On French Revolution Hitler: Good morning, Mr. Joseph Stalin, are you happy with your manipulation of Communist ideology and its degradation in USSR? Stalin: Morning, see Mr. Hitler, you know nothing about the will power of the working class people.

I represent the Communist Party in USSR, not dictatorship. If you know more about working class struggle, please tell me about French Revolution? Hitler: Ha, ha, ha. It was the most foolish attempt undertaken by the so called revolutionaries in France. Did they win anything? No. Were they able to overpower the world? Then why you people back up such a foolish act. I feel pity of you. Stalin: Your words prove your ignorance. See, French revolution deeply influenced the world history and it elevated the dignity and personal liberty of human beings in general.

But you people will not try to understand the same as a human attempt to regain dignity because you do not believe in human dignity. William Doyle states that “In political terms pre-revolutionary France was an absolute monarchy” (21). Hitler: Again talking nonsense. You consider yourself as the messiah of revolutionaries, and then what is your role in USSR? Why you wear the mask of a Communist? Stalin: You are beating around the bush, without pointing out any important matters regarding political issues like French Revolution and it’s after effects.

So, I feel better to conclude this matter. Thanks. Hitler: But you never reveal your real identity as a fake communist and a dictator. B. On American Revolution (1775–1783) Stalin: Mr. Hitler, what is the Nazi opinion on American Revolution (1775–1783)? Was it a revolutionary attempt undertaken by the Rebels in America? Hitler: Mr. Stalin, it was a lame attempt undertaken by anti-revolutionaries in America. Stalin: I was quite sure that Nazis will consider American Revolution as a lame attempt.

But did the American revolutionaries in thirteen colonies of North America defeat the Great Britain? Hitler: See, the French, Spanish and Dutch conspiracy defeated the British forces, not the revolutionaries. Stewart Ross points out that “However, America’s revolution was more than just a military triumph” (8). Stalin: Ok. Who did authorize the British Parliament to impose direct taxation or the Stamp Act of 1765 in American colonies? What was the consequence? Did it accelerate the American attempt to form a shadow government?

Hitler: See, your knowledge is not deep and the