StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Should lethal injection be considered cruel and unusual punishment - Research Paper Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Should lethal injection be considered cruel and unusual punishment

Lethal injection is problematic in that there are bound to be problems that might cause infliction of pain, torture and lingering death. One of the reasons for this is that the procedure was invented by an individual, Fred Leuchter, who had no medical training, and invented the method by reviewing literature on the effects that the protocol had on pigs and estimated accordingly. Although these recommendations have been discredited, they still form the basis for the protocol in “the overwhelmingly majority of states that use the death penalty” a development that caused Debra Denno, author of the most comprehensive report on death penalty protocols in the United States to state “it is not clear how or why this chemical combination has persisted” (Wong, 2006, p. 269). Another of the reasons why lethal injection may be considered to be cruel and unusual punishment is because of the way that it is carried out. Lethal injections are often botched, as there have been over 30 cases of such botched executions since the death penalty was reinstated by Gregg v. Georgia (Wong, 2006, p. 264). Specifically, medical personnel, personnel that would be trained to carry out lethal injection in such a way that it would be complication-free and painless, typically does not want to carry out the punishment. Approximately 19% of medical personnel do go ahead and do this, yet these individuals are met with opposition from medical societies (Denno, 2002, p. 2). After all, they take a Hippocratical Oath that states that they are not to do any harm, and administering lethal injection would be a direct contradiction to this basic oath. Therefore,...
As a consequence of the fact that medical personnel by and large are not able to participate in lethal injection protocols, there is a chance that the official who is administering the protocol will put the intravenous line into the muscle, as opposed to a vein, or the needle may become clogged. This would cause the inmate to experience extreme pain. For example, when James Autry was put to death in Texas in 1984, it took him 10 minutes to die, while he moved around and complained of pain. Moreover, because the technicians performing the protocol are inexperienced, it is sometimes difficult to find a good vein, and this is compounded when the inmate was an intravenous drug user. Such was the case with Steven Morin in Texas, who was a former heroin user, which caused the technician to have to stick Morin’s arms with needles 41 times.
Crucially, lethal injection consists of three different procedures – the first is the anesthetic; the second induces paralysis; the third causes death. The first of these procedures that is the most important is the administering of the anesthetic, for this is what causes the procedure to be pain-free. If a medical personnel is not administering the anesthetic, then it stands to reason that the anesthetic might not be administered properly, which means that the prisoner may feel excruciating pain in dying. Konarias et al. sought protocol information from Texas and Virginia, as these two states constituted 45% of all death penalty cases carried out in the United States. ...Show more

Summary

This author of this paper aims to analyze whether the method of lethal injection should be considered to be cruel and unusual punishment, considering various arguments and researching historical facts about lethal injection punishment practice…
Author : lemuel17
Should lethal injection be considered cruel and unusual punishment essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the research paper on your topic
"Should lethal injection be considered cruel and unusual punishment"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

The Constitutional question of cruel and unusual punishment and the Death Penalty
THE DEATH PENALTY THE CONSTITUTIONAL QUESTION OF “CRUEL AND UNUSUAL PUNISHMENT” In the international sphere, the death penalty is losing its ground in a substantial number of countries, especially first world countries, which have outlawed it. In the US, however, this primeval way of punishing criminals is still alive and kicking what with the majority of the states having retained the measure.
32 pages (8000 words) Research Paper
Capital Punishment
Considering the diversified nature of such punishment; some of them are deserved to be mentioned. In ancient and medieval ages crushing by elephants was considered to be one of the most practiced forms of capital punishment. Among the countries who had restored to this practice India might be the most infamous one.
15 pages (3750 words) Research Paper
The Death Penalty Should Be Abolished in the United States
Now imagine that, after your deflated vein has finally been fixed with the line, and chemicals start pouring into your body. You should be unconscious by this time, but somehow, due to the inexperience and ignorance of the personnel involved, you are simply paralyzed, not unconscious as actually intended.
7 pages (1750 words) Research Paper
Eight Amendment of the U.S. Constitution - Freedom from Cruel and unusual Punishment
The research focuses on the 8th amendment of the United States constitution. Specifically, the research delves into the cruel and unusual punishment provisions of the amendments. The research includes relevant case laws and statutes to back up the statements.
12 pages (3000 words) Research Paper
The Constitutional question of cruel and unusual punishment and the Death Penalty
In the US, however, this primeval way of punishing criminals is still alive and kicking what with the majority of the states having retained the measure. Often, death penalty cases find their way into the halls of the US Supreme Court by invoking unconstitutionality as a ground, particularly the “cruel and unusual” punishment clause of the 8th Amendment.
30 pages (7500 words) Research Paper
Death Penalty II
The United States and the Arabic world have preserved the practice through their constitutions to give justice for the heinous crimes committed. While Sharia laws bring more religious related reasons for the death penalty like apostasy and sexual crimes, the bible has often been quoted to permit death penalty in the sense that one’s blood would be shed by man for shedding another’s blood.
3 pages (750 words) Research Paper
Physicians Ethics and Lethal Injection
121). "The California Medical Association, the American Medical Association (AMA), and the American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) immediately and loudly opposed such physician participation as a clear violation of medical ethics codes. Physicians are healers, not executioners," (Gawande, 2006, para 1).
11 pages (2750 words) Research Paper
Is the Texas Prison System cruel and unusual
In the book, he states that the numerous ill behaviors that have occurred under the purview of Texas Prison system leads a person to agree to the question rose. The following
4 pages (1000 words) Research Paper
The change in Eighth Amendment cruel and unusual punishment standards in death penalty cases since Furman v. Georgia (1972)
The impact of the Due Process Clause on the 14th amendment, has made the application of the 8th amendment against the federal government and those of states. The eighth amendment
4 pages (1000 words) Research Paper
8th amendment
The impact of the Due Process Clause of the 14th amendment has made the application of the 8th amendment against the federal government and those of states. The eighth amendment provides that a
2 pages (500 words) Research Paper
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation