StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Names are rigid designators so the description theory of names is wrong - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Names are rigid designators so the description theory of names is wrong

Some of the contributors to the development of this theory' is attributed to Kripke, Putnam and Wettstein.
According to Kripke, proper names and definite descriptions are designators. That is, in every possible world they designate the same object. Kripke distinguishes the meaning of a designator and the way its reference is determined. Then he puts forth his causal theory of naming: initially, the reference of a name is fixed by some operation such as description then the name is passed from link to link. A name is not identified by a set of unique properties satisfied by the referent: the speaker may have erroneous beliefs about those properties or they may not be unique. The name is passed to the speaker by tradition from link to link.
Kripke rejects the view that either proper or common nouns are associated with properties that serve to select what they are referring to. Both proper and common names have a referent. The property cannot determine the reference as the object might not have that property in all worlds. For example, gold might not be yellow in all worlds. Kripke's causal theory of names assumes that names are linked to their referents through a casual chain. A term applies directly to an object via a connection that was set in place by the initial naming of the object. A nonrigid designator is a term that changes its referent across possible worlds.
The Nature of Names

Consider, for example, a Biology class out on a field trip. Walking in the woods, the professor asks the students to identify the plants that they encounter. A student is asked to identify a plant. Seeing that the plant has thorns, has red flowers that are well known to be a symbol of love and lives in the wilderness, the student names the plant as a Wild Rose. Thus, the naming was based on descriptions that were learned and passed on to the student. Can we therefore say that naming, specifically proper names, are based on descriptions That is, is the Old Theory essentially correct
In this paper we, argue that naming is not essentially descriptive but is actually an exercise of designating rigidly. Nevertheless, in this paper, we also argue that naming does have some degree of descriptive being.

Naming Without Conceptualization

In this philosophical argument, we find that there is a need to use real world examples to do away with the abstractions and complications that a discussion such as this would entail.
The unifying string of this paper's argument is that a person could refer to an object by indicating its name without actually knowing the descriptions of the object that he doesn't have a concept of - no knowledge of any descriptions or whatsoever that may give the person naming an idea of the object/person being named. It would then follow that it is possible to name an object without substantial conceptualization. If it is possible to name objects without such conceptualization, then a theory of the meaning of names should not be secluded to such elements. Note that we use the word secluded. By conceptualization, ...Show more

Summary

During the 1970's, the so called New Theory of Reference became widespread and is still flourishing today. This theory forwards the notion that that many locutions such as proper names refer directly to items or are "rigid designators". In contrast to the New Theory of Reference, the "Old theory" implies that names and relevantly similar locutions express descriptive senses or are disguised descriptions…
Author : arunolfsdottir
Names are rigid designators so the description theory of names is wrong essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Names are rigid designators so the description theory of names is wrong"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Place-names (linguistics)
Historically speaking toponymy – the study of place-names – has focused on etymology as opposed to power discourse (Cameron 1996; Culpeper 2005; Diaz Vera 1996; Gelling 1995; Gelling 2007; Hough 1997; Kadmon 2004; Paisey & Paisey 2011; Scott 2003). However, in recent years, scholars have turned instead to the consideration of the power relationships implicit in the act of naming a geographic location (Radding & Western 2010; Rose-Redwood, Alderman, & Azaryahu 2010;).
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Describe a domain name, and provide examples of domain names
For example, the domain name ibm.com represents the web presence of the company IBM. Domain names are registered with relevant authorities called “domain name registrars” who help to maintain the uniqueness of the name (“ICANN-Accredited Registrars”, 2011).
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Explain why Wells avoids calling his characters by their names
The story is concerned with the relationship of these two future races, as the Time Traveler explores the future world that these creatures inhabit. The Time Traveler is special because he is the protagonist yet he has no name, as well as the other characters in the story.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Seven Names for Seven Dwarves
It was from my recollection of this version that I was able to recall the names of the dwarves: Doc, Grumpy, Dopey, Bashful, Sleepy, Happy, and Sneezy. The task seemed simple enough at first glance: write down on a sheet of paper the names of the Seven Dwarves.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Brand names as loan words
The phenomena has helped Marketing immensely, yet many nations of the world are not particularly happy to see English as a primary means of conversation and are hostile to even “loaning” English words in their branding strategies.
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
Confirmation Names vs. Carpathia
The central conflict is the direction of that characters lives and roles play in uniting the stories. The relation of the characters and the use of symbolism go hand in hand in both short stories. In Lippo's "confirmation" the choosing of names, represent a "confirmation" to live as committed Catholics.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Native American Names, Symbols, and Mascots
According to the works gathered by the Teaching Tolerance project (2008, pg. 1), "Since the Civil Rights era of the 1970s, when Indians began agitating to remove these stereotypical images, a dozen colleges have changed mascots. But five pro teams and hundreds of high school teams with no connection to Indians continue to portray their teams under Indian imagery.
9 pages (2250 words) Essay
Law of Trade Marks and Brand Names
The question of whether or not comparative advertising is justifiable has been brought to the attention of the Courts time and again. Currently, there are two schools of thoughts regarding the making of unfavourable comparisons in
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Different file names**
Medical advice is turned out to be the first and foremost treatment of hearing loss. Once this disease is diagnosed and it is proved that the hearing loss is occurred while performing the job at workplace, the
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
Hispanic Last Names
Majority of Hispanic people use their last two names. How can this be? How can one have two last names? Well in Spain the first name is called Nombre while the last name is called ‘Apellido’ which is referred to
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation