StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Debate notes - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Debate notes

Under a business oriented pay-for-play system in which performance is not only expected, but required for payment, such practices would undoubtedly cease. Student-athletes would also be forced to deal with the overwhelming business concerns that come with a professional system. Student-athletes may be placed in a bargaining situation that they could not possibly be expected to fully comprehend. Student-athletes would be forced to employ agents, accountants, and attorneys for assistance.2
Tax Issues. Problems that universities have avoided by preserving amateurism would begin to haunt them under pay-for-play. As one commentator has noted, a costly problem universities would face under pay-for-play would be the loss of their tax exempt status for income derived from athletics.3 Currently, universities pay no federal tax on tuition or other payments attributable to educational activities.4 Like other tax-exempt institutions, universities are taxed only on "unrelated business taxable income."5Unrelated business taxable income is income from a trade or business that is regularly carried on, but is not "substantially related" to the institution's primary purpose.6 The primary purpose of a university is education.7 Currently, college athletics are considered to be substantially related to education. ...
mpensated for playing, the IRS most likely could no longer support the idea that athletics are rationally related to education and would tax the earnings derived from such events. This loss of profits due to taxation would significantly lower college revenues and would likely result in less popular sports being discontinued due to lack of funding, as well as the possibility of limiting funds for athlete services such as scholarships, financial aid, and tutoring.
Athletes as Employees: Labor Law Issue. A pay-for-play system could also open a Pandora's box for employment claims, including salaries, the right to form unions, and workers' compensation benefits.8 Due to the nature of athletics and the potential for injury, the addition of workers' compensation claims would be especially costly. Student-athletes' entitlement to workers' compensation is generally held to rest upon whether they are "employees" under the applicable workers' compensation law.9 Under the NCAA's current system most courts have held that universities are not liable for injuries suffered by student-athletes under workers' compensation laws10. In support of these holdings the courts have repeatedly pointed to the concept of amateurism.11 These courts reason that because student-athletes are non-compensated amateurs they are not employees and thus are not entitled to workers' compensation.12 If the amateurism policy is abandoned and a pay-for-play system adopted, courts could no longer deny student-athletes workers' compensation benefits because they would be employees. A second justification for paying student-athletes is that they are university employees13. This idea directly conflicts with established principles of amateurism. Consequently, courts are reluctant to alter the dynamics of collegiate ...Show more

Summary

Synopsis of Issues. The payment of money to amateur athletes has traditionally been viewed to be contrary to the very essence and true meaning of amateurism.1 The proposal to pay college athletes who are amateurs poses several legal issues like taxation, labor law, not only to the university but the student athlete as well…
Author : vgrant
Debate notes essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Debate notes"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

NOTES
ist states with public hospitals -Restructure in the system was hoped to improve quality, clarity, effectiveness, and accountability -New agreements require reports on performance in exchange for increased funding -Hoped to solve problems of preventable diseases, gap in life expectancy between indigenous and non-indigenous people, and wait times -NHHRC released a June 2009 final report on health care—proposed that the Commonwealth Government assume full responsibility for funding of primary health care Nicola Roxon – Minister for Health and Ageing who reports directly to the Prime Minister Ten Key Elements of a future Australian health system: 1.
11 pages (2750 words) Essay
Debate
In relative sense, an unmitigated conflict had been conspired by dividing opinions, where professional recommendations clash with religious and familial sentiments when it comes to deciding and acting in behalf for the patient’s condition--to preserve life no matter what the outcome may be or end it when medical prognosis is severely discouraging The ethical dilemma for the medical profession and the family of the afflicted individual give rise to ongoing debates.
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Debate
The very essence of the debate relays on the question of “what is life?’ Life in its most basic physiological sense is the presence of vital signs. As long as you are breathing, your heart is beating, you are living. Consequently, death is the exact opposite, the absence of vital signs.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Debate
Under the process-based curriculum, students perceived as weak in universal skills such as reading, oral communication, writing, creative thinking, problem solving, mathematical computations, working with groups, managing self, and working effectively within an organization.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Debate
Therefore it is an essential responsibility of the company managers to maximize the return for its shareholders. The return is given in the form of dividend or in the form of shares (David, 2007). Shareholders invest in the company with the purpose of gaining profits and every profit oriented firm always seeks for maximizing the shareholders value (Roe, 2000).
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Debate notes
Others are forced to participate due to threats of reduced playing time or other coercive acts. An excellent example of the potential involvement of religion in the locker room can be highlighted by events at the University
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Debate
This is attributed to the fact that employers and managers find it much more convenient to offer the merit increase by distributing it evenly to all employees to avoid misunderstandings and conflict in the workplace. In a bid to escape the conflicts, employers and managers end
2 pages (500 words) Essay
DEBATE
The statistical methods used in estimating the pay differences between men and women may be appealing, but are not perfect since they entail computational errors and researcher bias.
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Debate
The move led to the hiding of more than 15M documents from the public (Ginsberg et al., 2015). The documents constituted of documents the government perceive to be sensitive to the
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Debate
This statement also brings about the argument of when an unborn fetus attains the qualities and equality of a born child. It also brings about the question of whether a fetus should be treated with equal rights as an already born child (Ginsberg, Theodore,
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation