StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Death and Philosophy - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Death and Philosophy

Nagel, interestingly, argues that it is not the death that is harm but rather the ending of life. He takes the a bit further by discussing prenatal life and life after death, almost equally qualifying the value of each "state" but fearful to arrive at a conclusion. Should we follow Nagel's premise, then the loss of life is the injury and the earlier loss of life compared to a later loss of life is far more injurious.
Indeed, by way of example he states that a corpse can suffer no injury because the corpse is a dead being. Thus perhaps, in Nagel's world, there should be no such thing as a crime committed against a corpse. For example, because the person is dead, one cannot have violated the law because he desecrated a corpse. One can be found guilty, if he contributed to the cause of death only. Nagel's focal point is time. Thus when a person dies, they have been robbed of the extra time that they would have lived. Thus if a man lived 80 years, the harm is not so bad, but if the man lived only 20, the harm is egregious.
Lacking here, is the discussion of what happens during that time. For example, if a man lives only 20 years, and becomes an astounding man, has he been robbed Nagel would probably argue in the affirmative. Conversely, if a man is 80 and has lived a life of no consequence, has he been harmed by being robbed of extra years Perhaps not. What if the person has spent 10 of those years suffering from a painful disease Has not death then rescued the person
Finally, I am asked to explain which theory I prefer. I do not believe that one suffers by death. I agree with Rosenbaum in that once death has happened, there is no harm. Indeed, it is the path to death in which harm lays in wait. Many religions herald the notion that we choose our own exit from this world by our behavior during the time in it. Rosenbaum however offers an explanation that agrees with my religious values and my basic common sense. Once I am dead, I expect that to be it. Indeed, depending on my condition at death, I may find death to be a ...Show more

Summary

Rosenbaum, following Epicurus, argues that death is never a harm to the one who dies. Logically, the statement makes sense. If we are dead, and death means total annihilation, then we are far beyond feeling at the time of death because we have already been annihilated…
Author : klockocyrus
Death and Philosophy essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Death and Philosophy"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

Philosophy of Life after Death
There exists many believes of immortality also known as life after death. Persons are believed to survive death and remain in a conscious mind after receiving some rewards and punishments. Christians believe in life after death and that their members go either to heaven, purgatory or to hell according to one’s morals.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Philosophy of Death
However, the fact that death ends life and any of its attendant benefits cannot be ignored. Epicurus' ethics are significantly based upon the Aristotelian common place which states that the highest good is not valued for the sake of anything else rather then its own sake and Epicurus accede with the thoughts of Aristotle that happiness is the supreme advantage.
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
Death in Greek and Hinduism Philosophy
In the context of Greek philosophy, death is seen as a means of achieving honor. Death becomes the path where an individual, depending on his status in life or what he did, would have a funeral suitable to the honor that he is worth. In addition to this, death is also seen as a means of showing power and ambitions of an individual.
8 pages (2000 words) Essay
Philosophy
The extract on which this research is based is made from ‘the Apology’ by Plato which comprises of Socrates’ defense in reply to the charges laid on him. It is not easy to give an account of the real Socrates
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Philosophy
As many writers have come out with the concept of what is happiness, Epicurus has his own philosophy of what and how to achieve happiness and be able to define the two major fears that could ruin the human soul as well as the
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Philosophy
Why is a quiet private life the best choice for the person who desires to be happy? Epicurean philosophy believed that the fact that Gods could mete out sufferings to humans even after their death, was a major cause of anxiety and apprehension among people.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
Death Penalty (philosophy)
The irony of an anti-death penalty activist ending up to be on the other side of the fence is where his case’s appeal lies. The shocking ending thus seems a little too over the top maybe because of its cinematic nature. But the
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Philosophy Life and death
However, on his way back home, an old snake eats the spiky plant and becomes young. He thus loses his chance of becoming immortal. From Gilgamesh, there are two world views that emerge from people and beings. First, as much as all human beings desire to live
3 pages (750 words) Essay
Philosophy
In comparison, it exhibits differences to other ways of addressing problems through its dependence on coherent arguments like that of God (Lawhead 345). In addition, philosophy mainly refers to basic principles and ideas in life that guides individuals in
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Philosophy
In the past Socrates was considered unguilty, but recently some scholars stated that the accusations were founded and the accusers were absolutely right. The given paper will prove that the Socrates argument about the necessity of education and
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
YOUR PRIZE:
Apply my DISCOUNT
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation