StudentShare solutions
Triangle menu

Nativism and Immigration Restriction - Essay Example

Not dowloaded yet

Extract of sample
Nativism and Immigration Restriction

However, the year 1882 would become a turning point in our nation's history with the passage of the federal Chinese Exclusion Act that prohibited immigration based on race and ethnicity. The next four decades would continue to affect the country's perception of immigration and would culminate with the passage of the National Origins Act in 1924. Our national views and policies towards immigration continue to be shaped by the nationalism, fears, and nativism that were spawned in California over a century ago.
By the middle of the 19th century the residents of California were openly expressing their resistance to Chinese immigrants and these feelings were being exhibited through worker demonstrations and violent outrages. Advocates of the open door policy clashed with anti-immigrant forces over immigration policy for one of the first times in our nation's history. The working men in California had begun to believe that the immigrant Chinese were taking jobs from them and suppressing wages. By 1876, the Chinese were working in gold mines, manufacturing, and in agriculture. A New York Times article of the era contends that, "In all these vocations, as a rule, they [the Chinese] work for lower wages than are usually paid to white men."1 The outward displays of discrimination against the Chinese workers would often force them out of the white dominated workplace and into lower paid occupations. Because there was a shortage of women in California at this time the Chinese men often turned to becoming domestic servants, cooks, housekeepers, or laundry attendants.2 This forced the Chinese workers into the lower wage positions and fulfilled the perception that they were willing to work for less money.
The Chinese were also the subject of intense racism in the press and in the public debates over the employment issue. These emotions prompted the federal government to consider passing the Chinese Exclusion Act, which would ban Chinese immigration and prevent Chinese workers from attaining citizenship. A newspaper of the era argued that the white worker should "be excused if he is impatient with the competition of a laborer who lives on the cheapest food, lives in a dry goods box, has no more interest in the State than a bird of the air, and returns to his own land as soon as he accumulates a little money."3 Though these were the prevailing attitudes toward the Chinese, there was a small oppositional viewpoint. As the Chinese Exclusion Act was being debated nationally, the merchants and businessmen warned of taking such extreme action aimed at a single country and race. Their interest was in increasing trade with China that was just beginning to open up to American products. The merchants warned, "The Chinese government would be perfectly justified in retaliating upon us, if we commit such a base act of international treachery as that contemplated by this act."4 The issue that had begun as a labor dispute in California had risen to the level of a national debate as Congress considered the Act.
In the emotionally charged political debate, the voice of reason and truth was often obscured by the polarization of emotions. Professor Wells Williams of Yale College, a leading Social Scientist of the period, published a paper in 1879 after studying Chinese immigrati ...Show more


Immigration continued to weave the tapestry of America for over 300 years after the Mayflower brought the first European settlers to America's shores. The new country needed new inhabitants, skilled labor, workers, and new ideas. Immigration was encouraged and the country maintained an open door policy to people from all over the world…
Author : gregorioolson
Nativism and Immigration Restriction essay example
Read Text Preview
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Nativism and Immigration Restriction"
with a personal 20% discount.
Grab the best paper

Related Essays

The basic fact of immigration is that it has always been a reality, and the various types of benefits of immigration can be realized as the fundamental reason behind ever growing figure of immigration. Significantly, immigration is an international phenomenon and reality, and almost all the nations of the world are affected by this global phenomenon.
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Calorie restriction
Interest in the modern era has sprung as a result of evidence from insect and animal studies pointing to increase in life span and beneficial impact on reducing the impact of conditions and diseases associated with the aging processes. Yet, an understanding of calorie restriction among humans is not limited to the modern era, but runs back to earlier historical times in the development of humankind.
7 pages (1750 words) Essay
Race and Immigration Restriction
What astonishes the Americans is the manner in which Higham developed varying views on nativism and immigration policies as he expressed them in the remaining decades in his long career. In his book he draws his statements to Congress and the federal council concerning the need for immigration reforms.
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
In keeping with the United Nations records, 2010 recorded nearly 214 million international migrants. In comparative terms, this figure was over 3 per cent of total human population in the world. However, the proportion does not seem extraordinarily elevated, particularly if it is contrasted against the percentage of other cross-border connections, for instance, investments and trade.
6 pages (1500 words) Essay
The Debate over Immigration Restriction
The concern of those who want to restrict immigration is the effect on the quality of life of Native Americans by the influx of foreign people. The main consideration as stated is the evil effects to the political, social and moral standard of the community assuming that the current group of immigrants is of inferior quality to the past (Fetter).
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Academic restriction
I am writing this letter to exercise my right to appeal my recent placement as a student on academic restriction. It is not my intent to suggest that the underlying facts are inaccurate, for they are quite accurate, but to suggest instead that I am deserving of a second chance for very special reasons.
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Immigration is the most evident manifestation of the developing relations between the United States and developing nations. The torrent of these new immigrants is creating a repercussion of resistance, for the justifications that
10 pages (2500 words) Essay
This paper tends to discuss major causes of immigration, their effects, and subsequent issues. Various socio-economic and political factors cause
4 pages (1000 words) Essay
Immigrants and nativism
With the migration of the Irish Catholics to America, antagonism was aroused by the American Protestants not only on religious ground but also on job competition. An unofficial political party was formed against the Irish Catholics and other immigrants in the mid
1 pages (250 words) Essay
Nativism and Xenophobia
, or family members of them, have come to appreciate the power and resiliency that the United States has been able to achieve as a direct result of its policies of immigration. A such, these two camps come in near constant conflict with one another; with pro immigration
2 pages (500 words) Essay
Get a custom paper written
by a pro under your requirements!
Win a special DISCOUNT!
Put in your e-mail and click the button with your lucky finger
Your email
Comments (0)
Rate this paper:
Thank you! Your comment has been sent and will be posted after moderation